Misunderstanding Trump (As A Tribal "Yoohoo, I'm With You!" Or Out Of Lazy Thinking)
I'm a libertarian and am at odds with both Democrats and Republicans for various reasons. In short, nobody I vote for willingly (an occasion rare like snow leopards in a mall) ever wins.
It serves us not at all to leap to assumptions about Trump or anything or anyone else. Scott Greenfield, a lawyer and thinker I respect, gets into the nuances of Trump in a post, and I think he's right.
Scott opens with the assumption by many that Trump is a racist; for example, because he said there were "fine people on both sides" when white nationalists marched in Charlottesville -- a march that turned deadly.
As commentator after commentator from both left and right opined on the tube, Trump has now shown what he really believes.But what if that's a completely wrong assumption, a projection of morality of the people who have beliefs, even if they differ, on a person who has none. Over grilled steak the other night, I spoke with a few people who are in the CEO class, who had done business with Trump over the years, who have serious issues with the Democrats and Hillary, and who, to a person, thought Trump a blithering idiot and a disgrace.
But they did not believe that Trump was immoral. They believed he was amoral.
What if there was only two things that drove Trump: self-aggrandizement and self-enrichment? What if he's not racist, not because he's against racism but because he has no moral compass to steer him toward or away from racism.
For people who have any sense of morality at all, it seems almost impossible for any person to be amoral, to simply feel nothing about morality and be truly sociopathic. The people who knew him, did business with him (or at least tried to, as a recurring theme was that he was so utterly lacking in integrity that neither handshakes nor contracts constrained his actions). His word meant nothing. Not to him.
So what was this tone deaf, impossibly stupid noise that was emitting from his yap? Others more qualified to explain pathologies have, and will, provide better explanations, but consider that the narcissist believes his golden tongue can somehow talk his way through the middle of a situation so that he can walk away making everybody happy, feigning concern for the bereaved without alienating perhaps the only group who has anything nice to say about him?
Like most insipid thinkers, Trump assumes others parse information like he does. If it works for him, it must work for you. And if it doesn't, then it's because you are wrong, you don't "get it" like he does, further entrenching him in his own bizarre narrative. The depth of his compensation for his Impostor Syndrome precludes his ability to recognize that his mad rhetorical skillz didn't cut it. After all, he got himself elected president spewing empty nonsense and attacks. He must be smarter than everyone else.
...Perhaps we've given Trump far more credit than he's due by imputing immorality to his incapacity to condemn white nationalism and racism. That would require him to hold a belief, wrong as it may be, about an issue of substance. Perhaps he holds nothing dear except himself.








In general I did not support Trump and was not happy with him.
BUT
It is true that people got mad at him for doing the same things Obama did, or blamed him for things out of his control, or took quotes out of context to make them look worse (which I don't get because he has so many quotes that are bad enough, I don't see why people needed to make up more, except that it seems to be human nature that once you start piling on someone you keep going whether true or false).
It also works in reverse, the right getting mad at the left for doing the same things.
And that's what bothers me, it is more about what tribe you are in than what the actual policies are.
NicoleK at November 11, 2021 4:00 AM
Blah blah blah. As NicoleK says this is just another tribal nonsense piece.
Ben at November 11, 2021 5:22 AM
What a bunch of crap. Is there no one in America who doesn't huddle in elementary-school cliques and whisper atrocities about others?
There are abundant pictures of Trump embracing Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton, warmly, before any political campaign. There is video of The View (hack, spit) cheering him wildly on set.
But people lost their minds when he didn't magically give them things. All of a sudden, it was a crime to suggest that work was a solution - and the problems in Chicago were solvable, if city managers just let the police do their jobs.
Then, insanity arrived by the busload.
Trump has not changed at all in the last fifty years. While you thought he might be mean to gays, many of you voted for a woman who took money from regimes that killed them. Later, you voted for a man notable for how little he's done, with a running mate famous for imprisoning blacks.
That's how far your emotions and lack of research have led you astray, and I'm not about to let that be forgotten.
Radwaste at November 11, 2021 5:40 AM
There are several things wrong here.
1) Trump respected the law. Border security is the law. When trump tried to do things to enforce that and the courts said no, he stopped. Immediately. Biden has not only issued illegal executive orders he is telling people to ignore the vax injunction.
2) He has no animus toward anyone. He hired black, gay, women in his admin. His statement about good people on both sides was about protesters. It is certainly a factual statement. The media tried to make all the conservative protesters into monsters.
3) He genuinely loved israel and instituted the Abraham accords which this admin is trying to undo.
4) He recognized that Iran, NC, china are either enemies or adversaries. Biden is all kissy kissy with dictators and tyrants. Sends $ to terrorists in Palestine and Afganistan.
5) He recognized the importance of energy whereas this admin is waging war on energy.
6) Lest I be accused of being naive, his trade policy was pretty stupid.
All politicians are somewhat pathological (as liars at least). Many high up people are sociopaths (no empathy). Sorry but this essay is just stupid.
cc at November 11, 2021 5:40 AM
Amy,
You posted a horseshit article by someone who thinks he is more intelligent and clever than he is. He could write an article showing how people drive to work in pirates.
Do you read more than the headlines and do you also believe that Trump told people to inject bleach?
"...Perhaps we've given Trump far more credit than he's due by imputing immorality to his incapacity to condemn white nationalism and racism"
https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2019/03/21/trump_didnt_call_neo-nazis_fine_people_heres_proof_139815.html
David H at November 11, 2021 7:34 AM
Like most people, we assume others parse information like we do.
Fixed it for ya. Yer welcome.
I R A Darth Aggie at November 11, 2021 10:02 AM
Later, you voted for a man notable for how little he's done, with a running mate famous for imprisoning blacks.
Worse than that, the 1995 crime bill is one of his shining moments of getting a bill across the finish line. A bill that empowered his running mate to imprison people of many stripes. If you need a refresher on what a horrible person she was as California AG:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2015/03/08/justice-honesty-government-prosecutor-column/24611623/
I R A Darth Aggie at November 11, 2021 10:07 AM
6) Lest I be accused of being naive, his trade policy was pretty stupid.
All politicians are somewhat pathological (as liars at least). Many high up people are sociopaths (no empathy). Sorry but this essay is just stupid.
cc at November 11, 2021 5:40 AM
In my mind, decoupling from China in every way possible is never a bad idea.
The looters, the grifters, Facebook, Google and the naïvely dumb but ambitious boys and girls of your local high school student council are now running the country. It isn’t an improvement.
Isab at November 11, 2021 11:12 AM
…….in fact, it is a fucking disaster, visible from Alpha Centauri
Isab at November 11, 2021 12:03 PM
Now, now. All of us veterans on Veterans Day appreciate how President Biden took a moment during his speech to mention Satchel Paige, or as he referred to him, 'the great Negro'.
I blame Trump.
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at November 11, 2021 1:44 PM
And listen, you can't say Biden is slipping just because he released the report condemning the Saudis for slaughtering the journalist Khashoggi and then turned around and agreed to sell them $650M worth of weapons like nothing happened.
I mean the report was released in February and the sale was announced in November. Who can remember anything from way back then? It's impossible!
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at November 11, 2021 2:41 PM
Greenfield seems to have started with the same misquote that the mainstream media seems unable to shake its addiction to. That kind of sloppy research. selective editing, or intended bias makes his article useless drivel, as David H points out.
There were, in fact, three groups at Charlottesville. The people who were lawfully protesting the removal of statues, the Alt-Right who wanted to get involved and stir up trouble, and the Alt-Left counter-protesters who also mostly wanted to stir up trouble. Trump was not referring to that second group in that quote, as a full reading of what he said made very clear. Greenfield is an idiot if he still doesn't understand what was said..
ruralcounsel at November 11, 2021 7:24 PM
The "fine people" quote has been so thoroughly discussed and explained that I thought only committed CNN people would even dare try to raise it again. You know, the people who care not one whit about the truth of what they say, so long as all of their buddies can sagely nod in agreement and bond in their Trump-hate.
Disappointing to see it here.
bobby b at November 11, 2021 7:41 PM
Hey Amy---
Did you post this because you are afraid you will be cancelled and have a burning hammer and sickle in front of your home in your Venice progressive paradise? Are you apologizing to you neighbors for your Libertarian leanings?
Your headline "Misunderstanding Trump (As A Tribal "Yoohoo, I'm With You!" Or Out Of Lazy Thinking)"
describes your lazy thinking in thinking his blather has any relevance.
Sylvia B at November 11, 2021 9:35 PM
"Over grilled steak the other night, I spoke with a few people who are in the CEO class,"
Meanwhile, over Taco Bell leftovers, a few people in the Worker Bee class are trying to figure out how to pay for a gallon of gas.
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at November 11, 2021 10:13 PM
There is some truth to Greenfield's characterization of Trump as a narcissist. But it's as exaggerated as Trump's own bloviating. Trump is more moral than most politicians. What alienates most of them, and the Hollywood crowd, is that Trump has never accepted contributions from lobbyists, like those he gave out when he was in the real estate business. Sure, he is not as rich as Bloomberg, but Trump has all the money he feels he needs, so more doesn't tempt him. If he wanted more he would have stayed in, or gone back into, real estate.
Harry Truman said there is no way an honest member of Congress could become a millionaire while in office. Look at the changes in net worth of most members: they flunk Truman's test. Now look at Trump's. He lost half a billion dollars after going into politics, and then refused his salary as president. That to me makes him more moral than the lot of them, regardless of his sex life.
As for the accusations of racism, that's BS and everybody competent knows it. Both January 6 and Charleston were planned as peaceful, non-racist demonstrations. Then the FBI and Soros/BLM sent agents provocateurs to make them look racist and to incite violence while blaming the victims. As a result it is no longer possible for the Right to have a peaceful demonstration unless we keep those two groups from finding out about it. Just like Big Tech the FBI is all about shutting up anyone who contradicts their propaganda narrative. This is why they're still holding all those political prisoners.
jdgalt1 at November 13, 2021 11:47 AM
Thank you for even bringing those topics up Jdgalt1. Most don't want to hear about it.
Ben at November 14, 2021 10:07 AM
Leave a comment