A Reaganite Republican Calls Bush On The Carpet
In the face of cries from Republican National Committee chair Ken Mehlman for apologies from the Democrats to Karl Rove, Doug Bandow, former special assistant to President Reagan, currently a senior fellow at Cato (after a stint at the Heritage Foundation), points the finger at the Republican side -- very high up on the Republican side:
President Bush took the United States into war based on a falsehood. His appointees talked about mushroom clouds, Iraq's stockpiles of biological and chemical weapons, and unmanned aerial vehicles that could hit America.Vice President Cheney claimed that Saddam Hussein was involved in Sept. 11. Various administration officials, from the president on down, declared that the Saddam regime was a "threat," a "significant threat," the "most dangerous threat of our time," a "threat to the region and the world," a "threat to the security of free nations," a "serious threat to our country, to our friends and to our allies," a "unique and urgent threat" and a "serious and mounting threat."
None of these claims was true. Bush and his appointees had ample reason for doubt. Indeed, as John B. Judis and Spencer Ackerman of the New Republic pointed out, "Unbeknownst to the public, the administration faced equally serious opposition within its own intelligence agencies." The CIA, the State Department's intelligence bureau, the Defense Intelligence Agency, the Department of Energy, the Air Force and the International Atomic Energy Agency all disputed particular administration claims.
If the president's insistence on believing what he wanted to believe had only cost America $200 billion, it would be bad enough. But more than 1,750 servicemen and women have been killed, nearly 14,000 have been wounded (many of them maimed), and Iraq, as even President Bush admits, has become a vortex of international terrorism. The president should apologize.
... The result of the administration's war of choice has been to make America far less secure. The president has involved the nation in a conflict that Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld now warns could run a dozen years. Yet the military is badly stretched, with no relief in sight. The reserves are breaking, and recruiting is off even for the active forces: "We are getting toward the end of our capacity," warns retired Gen. Barry McCaffrey. It is hard to imagine the volunteer military surviving many years more of this war.
Unfortunately, Bush gives no evidence of recognizing his mistakes, let alone admitting his responsibility. The Republican-controlled Congress is unwilling to hold him accountable. Even longtime conservative activists have been largely quiet. Other than a few courageous souls at small publications such as the American Conservative and Chronicles, most conservatives have said nothing publicly. They apparently hate the Democrats too much or fear the loss of power too greatly to break ranks.
Political apologies tend to be cheap, exacted only under duress and offered to quell criticism rather than to right a wrong. But as Republicans busily demand public repentance from their adversaries, they should look in the mirror -- the president most of all.







We passed 2,000 coalition fatalities a few hours ago.
1806 Americans
93 British
101 Other Coalition Soldiers
eric at August 2, 2005 1:44 PM
7,000 people died building the Panaman Canal, should we shut it down too?
Look, war is hard and people die. Saddam had WMD specialists on his payroll, just waiting for the sanctions to become just a little more of a joke. Because of this war we aren't going to wake up some morning to discover that LA has been cloaked in a cloud of Anthrax cooked up in one of Saddam's labs, and millions of Iraqis don't have to worry about Chemical Ali's science experiments.
Shed all the tears for Saddam you want, but I'm glad the bastard's in jail and don't care what it took to put him there.
Richard Bennett at August 2, 2005 2:17 PM
Don't forget the second Death Star they were working on.
eric at August 2, 2005 3:32 PM
> Because of this war we aren't going to wake up some morning to discover that LA has been cloaked in a cloud of Anthrax cooked up in one of Saddam's labs
Instead we're going to wake up some morning to discover that LA has been cloaked in a cloud of Anthrax cooked up in one of Osama's labs. Because personnel were diverted from hunting down the bastard by this insanity in Iraq.
Stu "El Inglés" Harris at August 2, 2005 3:48 PM
A friend of mine likened the idea of Bush firing Rove to Pinocchio firing Geppetto. I have to disagree. Geppetto merely crafted Pinocchio, but it was the Blue Fairy who actualized his aspirations to become a real boy. So, obviously, Pinocchio firing Geppetto is comparable to Dubya firing his parents. Pinocchio firing the Blue Fairy would be like Bush firing Rove.
Patrick the cynic at August 3, 2005 8:17 AM
Leave a comment