Cellulite Cream Works!
...At improving cellulite cream-selling companies bottom lines. Jessica Seigel writes in The New York Times:
THE marketing campaign generating so much free publicity for a giant cosmetics company shows real women, rather than anorectic teenagers, in white bras and panties posing next to the slogan, "New Dove Firming. As testedI personally love the images, but woe to Neanderthals like Richard Roeper, a columnist for the Chicago Sun-Times, who derided the Dove gals as "chunky," igniting apoplexy over how much of a male chauvinist pig he is. With the ink flying, Mr. Roeper defended himself as just being honest - something we never doubted.
If only Dove would also come clean about its firming lotions. The truth is that anticellulite creams don't work.
That's why Dove, which is owned by Unilever, makes the campaign about images, not facts. Perhaps that explains why the multinational company's elaborate marketing includes a 48-page report on women's attitudes about beauty, but not one sentence giving information about how its firming ointments were "tested on real curves," reducing flesh dimpling in just two weeks.
Despite my repeated requests, Dove declined to release testing data - not surprising considering the pseudo-scientific babble driving this more than $40 million market, according to figures from research firms NPD Group and Information Resources.
Of course, snake oil isn't all bad. The Dove lotions largely contain glycerin, an old-fashioned moisturizer that your grandmother might have used. And studies show that women see improvement from fake creams with no active ingredients - a visual placebo. Considering today's pressure to be beautiful, women may need that.
But according to 27 years of medical literature recently reviewed in the Journal of Cosmetic and Laser Therapy, scientific proof that creams make a real, lasting difference does not exist. "There is no evidence to show that any topical medications improve cellulite," says Dr. Mathew Avram, the study's author and a Harvard Medical School faculty member.
Yet marketers and even some doctors promote the idea that lumpy flesh is a shameful but treatable condition caused by aging and obesity. That is, if you call puberty "aging," because that's when skin dimpling first appears, likely connected to the release of female hormones. (For that reason, oral contraceptives may worsen skin puckering, and males who lose testosterone after prostate surgery may develop it.)
Cellulite is a concocted idea imported from France. Hardly a disease or condition, it is how fat is arranged inside the female body, especially on thighs, hips and rear. And it affects some 90 percent of adult women. To change it, says Dr. Avram, you'd have to rejigger underlying body architecture, which is why exercising and losing weight helps some. But only some. "What you have here is normal female physiology," he says. "Skinny women have it too."
How do women not know that this stuff is a crock? I never buy any of that stuff -- not that I have cellulite, probably thanks to my running -- but I just ignore all that wrinkle-repair cream ads, too. It's all crap. Black women I know put vaseline on their skin for moisturizer. That seems to work. The cheapest stuff, in fact -- like Ponds cold cream -- works best. Anything else, you're paying for marketing lies and coverups -- which is like paying a fine for being stupid.







Heh. My mom used to swear by Preparation H around her eyes to reduce puffiness. I once asked my dermatologist what the best anti-aging product available was. His answer: sunscreen. And a woman I know with gorgeous skin swears she rubs in a few drops of olive oil every night at bedtime.
As far as cellulite goes, I also think genetics plays a large part in if or how much you have. I've never had much of it either, and I don't exactly have Buns N Thighs of steel.
deja pseu at August 17, 2005 2:09 PM
So Preparation H really works, eh? I've been thinking about buying a tube. And what's the name of the suncreen you use, Amy (or what's a kind with Meroxyl you recommend- I'm going to have some shipped in from Canada!)
Kate at August 17, 2005 2:51 PM
My mother, who is 68 and has NOT ONE WRINKLE has, for the past 40 years, used a regime of Dove soap and Johnson's baby oil.
As for the cellulite cream: it's amazing to me that any woman over the age of 20 has not heard it's a crock. But for those who haven't: IT'S A CROCK! Oh, and I run marathons, and am relatively lean, and I still have some.
nancy at August 17, 2005 5:59 PM
Sunscreen is right. And Visine removes redness on skin, too. I believe it reduces swelling in capillaries.
I use Anthelios XL #60 "pour visage" (for face). The FDA, in its continuing battle to protect us from protecting ourselves, has knocked it off eBay. But they sell it at Zitomer and some other pharmacy in Manhattan. Can't remember the other one, but they had an ad in NY Magazine in the past coupla months. If I haven't recycled it yet, I'll tell you which store. They sell it in Canada, but I think the formulation's different. That's the best one on the market though. And remember, it's important to get an undereye stick. Also, I'm getting my car (driver's side only, since Lucy doesn't burn, and Gregg is too big to ride in my toy of a vehicle) Llumar-ized. It's the best window film on the market, far as I can see. It prevents what I call "car face." Look at people who've been living in So Cal a long time. Look closely at their faces. Is the driver's side slightly older and saggier? That's car face. Eeek!
Amy Alkon at August 17, 2005 6:36 PM
PS Check as to whether they're still letting it through by mail from Canada before you order.
Amy Alkon at August 17, 2005 6:37 PM
Amy, what about L'oreal Solar Expertise? I just found it in a bag of cosmetic goodies that my father-in-law gave me when he flew over here from London. (A bag of freebies from some event he played at - musician gig.) I was ready to toss most of the items when I looked at the sunscreen and saw it contains Mexoryl! I probably would have thrown it away, too, if I hadn't been reading your blog! So, is this similar to the brand you like?
Claire at August 17, 2005 7:14 PM
I must be missing something, here. If you're already wearing SPF 60 sunblock
with UV-A protection, what do you expect a Llumar-ized window will do for you?
Ron at August 18, 2005 6:02 AM
Anthelios is by L'Oreal, too. It probably just has less Mexoral/less protection. Llumar is in case I can't reapply sunscreen or miss a spot. It's $45 for my tiny hybrid Honda. No biggie.
Amy Alkon at August 18, 2005 8:03 AM
If you're a redhead who doesn't tan at all (like yours truly), you can get your skin messed up by just looking at a 300 - watt light bulb sometimes.
Dmac at August 18, 2005 8:06 AM
Is it meroxyl or mexoryl?
Stephanie at April 17, 2006 5:37 PM
Mexoryl.
Amy Alkon at April 17, 2006 7:33 PM
I used to use Prep H for under eye bags until I read it contained high levels of mercury! I'd rather have the bags that put that stuff sooo near my brain!
Puffyeyes at May 18, 2007 3:27 PM
Leave a comment