Demeaning Or Humanizing?
CNN's Alexander Mooney writes that "Saturday Night Live" is in hot water for making fun of New York's governor Paterson, who happens to be legally blind:
"SNL," famous for mocking politicians and newsmakers, portrayed the governor in a four-minute "Weekend Update" segment as confused and disoriented -- often looking in the wrong direction and mistakenly walking in front of the camera when it was not his turn to speak.The "SNL" skit featured cast member Fred Armisen as the governor. It referred to cocaine use, with Armisen saying he became governor because of a "sex scandal I was miraculously not at the center of."
"Come on, I'm a blind man who loves cocaine who was suddenly appointed governor of New York. My life is an actual plot from a Richard Pryor movie," Armisen said in the skit.
Maybe it actually means they see you as a regular guy when they make fun of you on "Saturday Night Live." Maybe the real problem is when they treat you with kid gloves because you're blind.
I know this isn't a common point of view, but it's one shared by my cartoonist pal John Callahan. He was always getting in trouble from people who thought his cartoons were terrible, horrible, and rude to quadriplegics, because they made fun of them. They'd write him angry letters about how awful he was -- "How would you like it if you were quadriplegic?" Um...actually he is, and buzzes around Portland in his motorized wheelchair picking up girls with lines like "See my new shoes? I hear they're very comfortable."







people are idiots, my best friend is handicapped and her young daughter thinks its hilarious when I call her mother speedy gonzales. We don't fight, but we have been friends since we were kids so we bicker, you wouldn't believe the looks I get when we argue while I push her in her wheel chair. I dont treat her any differently then i do my non-handicapped friends and if i did i doubt she would want me as a friend.
Nina at December 16, 2008 3:33 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2008/12/demeaning-or-hu.html#comment-1613993">comment from NinaI love that, Nina. I think the worst thing you could do is show somebody pity. I do feel sorry for a guy I see -- Tom, with his big yellow lab, California, who must have Muscular Dystrophy or something that makes him pretty incapable of muscle control. He's in a motorized wheelchair and comes into a Starbucks I go to on Sundays, and just a great guy with a sunny disposition -- incredible considering the struggle he goes through to do the stuff we all find easy (like opening his Subway sandwich). I don't act like I pity him -- I talk to him like I would anybody else. California sniffs my crotch like I'm anybody else.
What's great about Tom is that I told him I was writing a book about rudeness and he said he didn't find people rude. Everybody's nice to him. "Tom, I think that's a reflection on you," I told him.
Amy Alkon
at December 16, 2008 5:27 AM
Callahan has a whole run of great cartoons skewering people who get pious about handicapped people. My favorite is the one where there are two disempbodied heads on a blanket with begging cups out in front of them, and the head with one patch says to the other with two eye patches "You're such and inspiration to me!"
He also has a bunch of religious cartoons, of which my favorite has Peter and Jesus at the bottom of Golgotha, where Peter says "I don't know, Jesus - could be a good career move..."
Jim at December 16, 2008 11:14 AM
I agree Amy.
I was watching TV yesterday and one person mentioned how the Family Guy cartoon in one episode was planning on doing a schtick on Marlee Matlin, and the way she talks.
She thought this was so hilarious, she called the producers of the show asking to use her own voice, and they agreed, re dubbing the entire episode with her voice over.
I watched it. I was hysterical.
I have a dear friend with MS. He makes a point of it to crack jokes publically at himself which usually results in nervous laughter or horror from onlookers. "Hey, make way for the cripple". "Do you think everyone stars at me because i walk with a limp, or because I am so damn handsome...", "Do you think my special shoes make my ass look fat"... he said to a lady one day (I almost pissed myself laughing so hard).
I asked him once why he did this...he told me that he does it when he feels people get an awkwardness around him...breaks the ice, and offers a way for people to overcome their compulsion to feel as though they NEED to treat him differently. He's just like everyone. He does have a funny walk, AND a good heart and a wicked sense of humor.
Feebie at December 16, 2008 12:43 PM
I saw the skit, and it was hilarious. The best part was when Amy Poehler was giving her good-bye speech, and Armisen-as-Paterson walked back into the shot talking on his cell phone. It was a fitting good-bye for one of my favorite cast members.
Amy K. at December 16, 2008 3:09 PM
It's true, people really are awkward around "disabled" people...often making themselves look like idiots in the process. The Family Guy thing is one great example of people being aware of their peccadilloes, and not being afraid to spoof them.
I was watching a comedian the other day who had a great story along those lines. He was on an airplane on an international flight (so the story goes), and there was a guy with a hook for a right hand sitting next to him.
He opened the conversation (apparently) with the question:
"So....what did you steal?"
They then (as per skit) got into a conversation about the ridiculousness of the comedian not being able to take a Bic lighter on board, but here's a guy with a friggin' HOOK on his arm and no one bats an eye.
It's silly to think this stuff shouldn't be talked about. Sensitivity does not preclude recognizing the disability, nor does it preclude cracking a joke or two. And it shouldn't either.
Factory at December 16, 2008 3:30 PM
Has anyone else seen the "Penn & Teller: Bullshit!" episode about the Americans with Disabilities Act? I think it's on point about the whole issue.
Tyler at December 16, 2008 4:32 PM
I think blind people need to stop watching the show. The boycott will teach them a lesson.
Toubrouk at December 17, 2008 8:44 AM
Back when I was in college, there was a blind guy in one of the dorms. He would go flying around campus waving his white cane in front of him like a light saber. Now and then he would run into someone, and he'd invariably say in a loud voice: Sorry. Didn't SEE you...
A friend described going through a power failure in the dorm one night. It got pitch black inside and nobody could see a thing. When the blind guy realized that no one else could see anything either, he started cackling and I believe used some rather salty language in expressing his vast amusement at their predicament.
That always cracked me up.
fustian at December 19, 2008 3:10 PM
Leave a comment