The Wages Of The Pill Paranoids
We're so terrified that somebody might get high that we needlessly leave people suffering horrible pain. NYT's Tierney takes on the issue, often covered by Sullum in reason:
At a news conference Wednesday, Dr. Portenoy and the other co-chairman of the Mayday panel, Dr. Lonnie Zeltzer of the University of California, Los Angeles, said patients' needs had to be better balanced against the concerns of law-enforcement officials, whose prosecutions of Dr. Hurtwitz and other doctors have made physicians reluctant to prescribe opioids. Dr. Zeltzer said doctors were especially reluctant to prescribe such painkillers to young people, and she cited the example of a teenager who had been incapacitated for six months until finding a doctor willing to prescribe opioids."Don't assume that your doctor knows what to do to treat your pain," Dr. Zeltzer advised patients.
She and the other members of the panel urged better pain-management training in medical schools and more money for pain research, which, according to the report, receives 1 percent of the budget of the National Institutes of Health.
The panel also urged the federal Department of Health and Human Services to reform the way doctors are reimbursed for treating pain. Dr. Portenoy said that the current system had "misaligned incentives" encouraging doctors to preform procedures like injections and surgery and that doctors who performed those procedures could make 10 times as much per hour as doctors who treated pain in other ways.
I deal with the drug paranoids in getting Ritalin, an ADHD drug I've probably been taking for over a decade. Luckily, my troublesome last shrink, the short guy, retired. He had "The Breakdown Of The Bicameral Mind" and other vintage tomes on his shelf, and never gave me one drop of advice or counsel; he just fought with me to make me come in once a month (instead of once every six months, as I had been until my previous doctor retired).
His interest, of course, wasn't in protecting me, but in protecting himself from the drug police. Before I had to see the short guy, I had two old Jews (old New Yorky men) prescribing for me. They got me from the start -- saw me for who I am: an ambitious nerd who is more productive and less unfocused writing on Ritalin, not some prescription junkie who's going to risk all to sell pills for $5 on the playground.
Meanwhile, to try to keep the short guy from killing one of my writing days once every month by making me come in (plus part of another day dropping off and collecting my Sched. 3 prescription), I kept bringing in stuff like my book deal, the finished manuscript, so he could see where the pills were going. In a way, I can't blame him for trying to hold out on me -- the government makes doctors this way. My convenience and productivity or his medical license? "See you next month!"
Of course, I'm a persuasive girl (big pain in the ass, plus debate ability), and I always eventually managed to squeeze six months out of him...or accidentally/on purpose call when he was on vacation and get one of the unretired old Jews to prescribe them for me.







I have to go once per month to get my meds...and that is after finding a doctor. I spent a couple of months seeing doctor after doctor when my previous doctor was picked up by the Popo. It took awhile to find one that believed my pain and was willing to address it.
At the same time, we are going to try to get me off of the morphine. I do well on it, but the next time I can't find a doctor, I don't want to be forced to worry about withdrawal. By the end of the week I will likely be on a reduced dose...we will see how it goes.
Doctors around here are getting thrown in jail for prescribing 540 Tylenol 3 tablets in a 6 month period. That sounds like alot, but the math will tell you that is an average of 3 per day. That isn't even the maximum dose.
-Julie
JulieW at November 9, 2009 10:44 AM
I was on morphine once fora three day tint after having part of my lung removed - comming down off of it after that short a time was a maddening experience
I cant imagne what it would be like for someone who needed it for long term pain managment
lujlp at November 9, 2009 11:48 AM
Amy - are you sure that there aren't nutritional causes for ADHD? I'm not convinced pharmaceutical response is the best way, oh no...
Crusader at November 9, 2009 12:14 PM
My doctor and I decided to give me one more 'bye' month before starting to titrate my morphine down. I have pretty bad disk degenerative disease (in addition to everything else) and we are trying to build up my muscles to support my back so that I don't end up with a fusion.
There is an interesting article in this months Scientific American about glia cells and how the contribute to narcotic medication tolerance (might have some impact on anti-depressant tolerance as well) and how some researchers are creating medications that work on the glia rather than the neurons with much better success.
-Julie
JulieW at November 10, 2009 8:53 AM
"Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" - holy crap, you could beat someone senseless with any paragraph out of that thing. Reading it was pain.
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at November 10, 2009 4:18 PM
When I got my IUD my doctor recommended that I take 6 ibuprofen every 2 hours and 4 extra strength Tylenol every 2 hours in between, rather than prescribing me something that actually works. I said "So, let me get this straight, you would rather make me take 120 pills a day then give me some Vicoden?" And the answer was yes. I found an old prescription lying around and used those instead.
It's the new "Reefer Madness", except now prescription pot is legal and pain patients are suffering. A comedy of errors.
Christina at November 11, 2009 2:37 PM
It's the new "Reefer Madness", except now prescription pot is legal and pain patients are suffering. A comedy of errors.
It is actually worse. Reefer Madness restricted recreational chemical consumption with stupid racist propaganda. This sadly keeps people from getting legal medical care because the DEA is bored, I guess. I still haven't figured out the reason for it all.
-Julie
JulieW at November 11, 2009 2:47 PM
Leave a comment