What's Your Biggest Regret?
Tara Parker-Pope asked that question at NYTimes.com, inspired by a survey:
Researchers at Northwestern University and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign collected data from 370 adults in the United States during a telephone survey. They asked respondents to describe one memorable regret, explaining what it was, how it happened and whether their regret stemmed from something they did or didn't do.The most common regret involved romance, with nearly one in five respondents telling a story of a missed love connection. The second most common regret involved family issues, with 16 percent of respondents expressing regret about a family squabble or having been unkind to a sibling as a child.
Other top regrets involved education (13 percent), career (12 percent), money issues (10 percent), parenting mistakes (9 percent) and health regrets (6 percent), according to the study, to be published in the journal Social Psychological & Personality Science.
I'm not a very regretful person, so I'm going to have to think about this and see if I can come up with something tomorrow. I tend to live life pretty fully, and try not to hurt people. I regret times I've inadvertently hurt people, and I regret that I didn't get diagnosed with ADHD and take Ritalin far sooner (like, in high school instead of in my 30s), but that's not really a regret that belongs to me, but more to circumstance.
When people talk about missed romantic connections, I'm sure there were some I missed, but the goal of living fully probably meant I did that a lot less. So, eight years ago, when I saw Gregg at the iPod display (all tall and guy-guy, wearing his shirt with the mange and his smart guy glasses), I said something -- instead of just thinking, "He's cute" and walking away.
When I was trying to get a job where I could learn about production and get paid right out of college and nobody at Ogilvy & Mather (which had the best production dept. in New York) would respond to my letters, I took the subway up there and tried to sneak in. I got caught by the guard and sent right back out the door, where I stood in the August heat, wondering what to do, and then I had an idea: I waited for somebody important-looking to walk out. This man did -- with a shock of gray hair cascading down his forehead and this Dr. Zhivago shirt and seersucker businessman pants. I followed him to Fifth Avenue, squeaked out, "Do you work at Ogilvy & Mather?"
Yes, he did, he said. I asked him to "give my resume to somebody who can do something with it." And a week later I had an interview with the head of production, who saw my cute student film I made at NYU undergrad (where I went to finish college after three years at University of Michigan), and they hired me. The man I stopped? Norman Berry, head of creative for Ogilvy Worldwide.
And then, after I quit Ogilvy but was still giving free advice on the street corner with my two friends from the agency, a reporter named Eric Messenger wrote a piece about us in The New York Times "Styles" section, and I ran with it, and got us a TV deal with De Niro, a book deal, an entertainment lawyer, and a column in the New York Daily News. And then, when no syndicators would pick up my column ("Ann Landers and Dear Abby have all the real estate -- you'll never make any money"), I spent years and years mailing out samples of my work and syndicated it to 70 papers all by myself.
Basically, I live without taking no for an answer or giving in to fears, and try to figure out what I want to do and how to make it happen instead of what I can do. (Sometimes that takes finding the guts to do it -- or just making myself do it when it scares the shit out of me.)
Also, I try to look pretty continually to see where I'm being an asshole and try to be better. And I make plenty of mistakes but they're part of my life and I try to learn from them. Sometimes, the mistakes turn out to be helpful. The way I see it, they aren't to be rued (it's senseless -- they're in the past); they just are.
Actually, after writing that, in reading the comments below the piece, I think this commenter at the NYT site gets at why I don't have regrets:
Alex Lickerman, M.D. Chicago March 23rd, 2011 8:53 am A great survey, but one that doesn't get at an important core issue: why do we regret things at all? Regret, it seems to me, is premised on the notion that we have the ability to know, or at the very least we suspect, that had we only chosen a different path from the one we actually did our life wouldn't have merely turned out differently, but better. We idealize the road not taken, imagining only the good things that would have resulted from our taking it, conveniently leaving out the bad that accompanies almost every choice, if not the bad that occurs simply as a result of remaining alive while time passes. Would any of the people in the survey have turned out with better lives--happier lives--had they made choices different from those they now regret? Most likely not.
Here's one from the comments that struck me:
Ella Washington, D.C. March 23rd, 2011 4:24 pm I had to make a connection on a flight home and a man on the plane asked me to get off with him. I didn't because my bag was checked through. He looked so hurt. I always have regreted that!
Your regrets? Your thoughts? And here's a question: Do you regret having regrets?







Just three regrets in my life, in order of import.
Not giving a home to the skittish tomcat my (cursed) sibling had in the 80s when our father moved south. :(
Not working through the issues that sweet orange Manx cat I adopted in the early 90s had then surrended back to the shelter. :(
Blowing off the advances of a particular
Asian lovely back in High School. *sigh*
NordicOnTheEdge at March 24, 2011 12:32 AM
Most my regrets aren't really because they involve knowledge gained later.
For example, At my first job out of school we would often times go to the place across the street. One of the bartenders was interested in me - she told me on her last day before she moved to AZ - she was cute but I have been unable to see even the slight hint that she was at all interested in me. If anything, I could see indications of a slight dislike.
I regret taking that job - I didn't realize that would be a black mark when trying to get hired at other companies for years to come.
I regret staying in my second job way too long. Though at the time it seemed like a good idea.
I regret not getting not getting my jaw fixed right when it was discovered that it would need fixing.
The Former Banker at March 24, 2011 2:15 AM
I found, when searching my memory, the most horrible moment. I was offered a job caring for the maritime part of the estate of one of the oldest names in citrus in Florida. Had I taken it, I would have been able to save my family business and home from the changes in legal and financial environment brought to Florida by masses immigrating from the North.
Now home is just a heartbreaking mass of concrete - a tropical barrier island buried under the ignorant asses of thousands of people trying desperately to turn it into the hell they left.
Radwaste at March 24, 2011 3:38 AM
I regret not pursuing my life goals more vigorously. Ah, well, too late now. Nothing to do but start from where I am.
Patrick at March 24, 2011 4:01 AM
I had horrible post partum depression after my first kid was born. I suffered through it, didn't seek help, and unfortunately had a rotten OB/GYN at the time who didn't even ask about my mental state after giving birth. After baby #2, I found a good psych, got on meds, went to therapy, and was much MUCH happier. I regret that I didn't do that sooner, the first time, because I could have been a much better mommy to #1. Thankfully, he was only 2 when #2 was born, so mommy got better when he was still young. But I think about those days when I needlessly put myself, my husband, and my child through bone-crushing sadness, and I'm regretful I didn't get help sooner.
Oh, and I'm also sorry I didn't tell that bitchy cheerleader in high school who used to be so mean to me to go fuck herself.
UW Girl at March 24, 2011 4:33 AM
My biggest regret is being blind to the red flags that flew up before I married my ex-husband. The real regret is that my self-esteem was so low that I was so desperate to be loved that I let a man abuse me. Of course I'll never regret my kids, but I do regret that I didn't choose a better father for them.
Kristen at March 24, 2011 5:30 AM
I'm only 22 so maybe I haven't lived long enough to regret anything, but I don't really have any. There are things I wish I did differently, but I do my best to live my life for the future so I would never look back and wonder if I could have worked harder to get a desired residency/fellowship/job.
I guess it depends what you prioritize in your life. I measure my success in terms of advancing my knowledge as a dental student in a very tough dental school, but my best friend measures her success in terms of planning her wedding and starting a life with her future husband. Both are equally valid but we might have significantly different types of regrets.
Katie at March 24, 2011 5:33 AM
Amy, your theme song?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q3Kvu6Kgp88
BlogDog at March 24, 2011 5:50 AM
I can't say I regret much-not the stupid marriage to the con artist at 18, nothing, because everything that happens in life brings us to where we are, and I'm very happy where I am now. 2 things I do regret-
1) my mom bought me a little kids lipstick thing when I was maybe 8. I accidently put the lid on while it was still rolled up, and ruined it. I tossed it behind the couch. I'm sure she found it and thought I hadn't cared about it, but I had been really really excited. DOn't ask me why that bugs me, I just hate thinking mom thought I didn't appreciate it.
2) at maybe 12, my dad was sick or out of town on mother's day (don't remember which) so my older bro drove to the store and bought a cake for her. WHen we had it at lunch, mom was going to take a pic of it, and I said "Oh no don't, it looks awful!'. I was referring to a little icing that had been smudged. I really wish I hadn't said that (it was a pretty cake) when my bro had gone to so much trouble and no doubt paid for it himself.
SO yeah, I most regret things that hurt other's feelings when it wasn't justified. I don't regret bigger things, like say cheating on my college BF and breaking his heart (and mine, too) because that's what led me to my hubby now, and I'm sure he's better off now too. Plus, had I married him, I wouldn't have my kids. And I really love THESE kids.
momof4 at March 24, 2011 5:52 AM
I, like Kristen, regret that I missed those red flags of my ex's, too. Other than that, nah, I don't think I have any regrets. Except maybe that I haven't won the lottery yet (but that's a-comin'!).
o.O
Flynne at March 24, 2011 6:17 AM
In 6th grade, I dropped my best friend because she was unpopular and I knew I would have trouble making other friends. God, kids can be such shits. I regret that. She is now a high powered lobbyist in D.C. so I've seen her name on the web. I'm tempted to email her and apologize but it seems like a selfish act to make myself feel better rather than on her behalf.
Astra at March 24, 2011 6:24 AM
1. I regret going through with my first marriage. I knew it was wrong, and I was retarded. On the other hand, part of what makes my second marriage work so well is that we're both OK with the fact that we're not fresh out of the packaging.
2. I regret getting married instead of going to graduate school. I'm having a hard time finding the motivation now, and it would have been so much easier had I done it straight out of college. And yet, two of my most meaningful friendships came out of that first job out of college.
3. I regret not being more forceful in pushing my mother to prepare for her death more effectively. She left me and my husband in a clusterfuck power struggle with my batshit-crazy sister over my father's care and the house, and that could have been so much easier for us if I'd pushed harder for her to make more binding legal arrangements.
MonicaP at March 24, 2011 7:13 AM
I think it depends on how people define "regret".
If it's simply "I wish I had done something different or better", then I think most self-reflective people can think of thousands of things that they "regret" ("I wish I had studied harder in organic chemistry", "I wish I hadn't dated that woman who broke my heart", "I wish I had been more grateful to my parents when I was a teenager".) I don't think there's anything wrong with that kind of "regret" -- it's part of our life-long learning process.
But I think most people use "regret" to mean "if only I had/hadn't done that one thing, my life would be so much better". That kind of "regret" is pointless and often disheartening.
I have lots of the first kind of regret, none of the second kind.
TestyTommy at March 24, 2011 7:31 AM
I don't have regrets per se because I've had a wonderful life so far. It's mostly curiosity about how life would be different had I made various different choices. I think that my life would still be great with any of a number of different choices, so it really is just curiosity.
My most significant missed opportunity was not trying to date this wonderful girl in high school. She was the class valedictorian, head of the student council, cheerleader captain, and the homecoming queen. And a very nice person on top of all of that. She had every boy in the tri-county area after her and so I never tried. I bumped into her in the mall when we were in our late twenties (after I was married) and she was in med school. She admitted to me that she had a crush on me too in high school. Doh! She's now a successful pediatrician with a nice family.
allenws at March 24, 2011 8:00 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/03/whats-your-bigg.html#comment-1956183">comment from BlogDogLove that song, BlogDog, and momof4, your story about your mom and the lipstick is really sweet.
Oh, and I have the HP doorstop/mobile printer, the 450, and your experiences with HP customer "service" mirror mine. Hideous, horrible, and they never tell you that you will eventually need this very expensive ink "spittoon," which is near impossible to purchase.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2011 8:11 AM
I think my only regret is that I didn't recognize and deal with the anxiety disorder 20 years ago.
But considering where I am now, I've led a pretty damned charmed life.
So maybe my other regret is not having actually bothered to notice that until now.
Otherwise, no regrets. As Michael Kay would have it: that's the fallacy of the predetermined outcome.
brian at March 24, 2011 8:12 AM
My primary regret not getting over my shyness sooner. Being too shy/insecure/complacent made life more difficult than it had to be, branching out weed-like into things such as letting people take advantage of me, and emotional eating. I've been improving markedly over the years (not to put the whammy on it :-)), especially once I got up the courage to get serious about polishing and marketing my novels. (You and Vinnie have been a big part of that -- thanks a million!) Wish I'd started doing all the good stuff in my twenties, but it's never too late, so I'm pursuing my goals and leaving regret in the dust!
DorianTB at March 24, 2011 8:14 AM
The thing in life that provides me with the most satisfaction came from a decision I KNEW I would regret, but it was the right thing to do.
My only regret is I got married thinking that I could fix someeone else's life, and I have been trying to do that ever since, to my own detriment.
Lost in space at March 24, 2011 8:42 AM
I'm with the posters who said that they don't regret much because it made us who we are today, and I do pretty much like where I am.
I do regret the last thing I said to my husband before he killed himself, but all I can do about that now is try to never say hurtful things to people, because you never know if it's going to be the last time you see them.
Daghain at March 24, 2011 8:48 AM
I don't have a lot of regrets b/c I don't necessarily believe they're useful or helpful. Mostly I just feel bad about shit I'll say and it comes out wrong and I seem like a bitch...when really I just was phrasing myself wrong. I do that a lot b/c I can be a talkative spazz especially when I'm drinking.
I WILL regret something in the future if I don't accomplish this huge life goal: After I work a few more years to establish some economic security for myself and husband I want to open an indoor dog park with doggy daycare/training/agility course and a (people) gym attached to it. The idea is that if you're a member of the gym you can workout and drop your dog off for an hour to run around and get tired. I think it'll be good for people who like to workout at the gym, want to give their dogs time to burn off their energy and yet don't have tons of time to make both things happen. For me, when I get home from work I am pretty tired and taking Ruby to the park (at least a 1 hour affair) or working out sometimes becomes an either/or.
Also, the weather and dog parks in Mass can be iffy at best. For a small fee you can enjoy a clean, friendly, safe environment to run around with your dog and socialize with other dog owners. Like Gymboree but for dogs. Maybe have a little coffee stand inside with doggy biscotti.
The second part of that goal is that the business will donate all profits to animal rescue - mainly helping spay/neuter programs and getting animals out of high-kill shelters and into safe places to wait for adoption. I'd also like to have a home/yard that can accommodate several dogs so my husband and I can always have one or two foster dogs in the house. Fostering dogs is really important to keep them happy and socialized and allows the foster guardian to work on any issues the dog might have (like food aggression or leash walking). That makes them more adoptable.
Basically I just want to be Jesus of the animals. Give money to support awesome animals who are euthanized simply b/c of space/money limitations and chop the heads off of assholes who run puppy mills or abuse animals. As you can see, in my version of events Jesus is vindictive.
Gretchen at March 24, 2011 9:29 AM
UW, don't beat yourself up for missing post partum when the doctors missed it too. I'm glad you got help as soon as you did because a lot of moms feel inadequate and don't want to admit they may have a problem. Be proud of yourself!
Flynne, I share the lottery regret as well.
Kristen at March 24, 2011 9:30 AM
Looking back, I can't say that I regret too much. With a lovely wife, three lovely daughters, and a pretty good job, all I can say is I've stumbled into wholly unearned good fortune!
As others have said on this thread, it's no fair saying "Gee, if I'd known then what I know now," since you didn't know then, and that's that. Similarly, you can't regret what other people did or didn't do (although I kind of wish the little blond girl in high school who passed me the note saying she's always kind of dug me had managed to do that before I was about to graduate!).
But there's always something, isn't there? I guess with me, it's not understanding completely the idea that I could, in fact, do pretty much what I wanted if I was willing to work and learn. I didn't think I could get into music school, figuring I lacked the talent (talent's only part of it). I didn't think I could join the Marines, as I didn't have the physical strength (I could have gotten it). Would I have been happy doing either? Oh, who knows? But I try to steer my girls away from that line of thinking if I can.
Old RPM Daddy at March 24, 2011 9:40 AM
I actually have a boatload of regrets, but most of them boil down to doing one thing wrong; being so unsure of myself that I have lived my life pretty much as other people told me to, rather than how I wanted to live it. Marriage, career, interests, pretty much every aspect of my life has been hard-coded by people who just knew what was best, most moral, most respectable for me.
Living your life the way you want to live it is nearly as important as breathing, and not automatic, so you have to put effort into it. If anyone, parents, friends, relatives lovers, tell you that they know best for you, leave them in the dust.
Regretful Jones at March 24, 2011 9:42 AM
"Living your life the way you want to live it is nearly as important as breathing, and not automatic, so you have to put effort into it. If anyone, parents, friends, relatives lovers, tell you that they know best for you, leave them in the dust."
That's awesome advice.
Gretchen at March 24, 2011 9:57 AM
Awesome advice, but damn near impossible to implement when your life is so interwoven with others.
Eric at March 24, 2011 10:15 AM
One: Not getting a grilled cheese sandwich from a vending machine (a VENDING MACHINE!!!) at a hostel in London.
Two: Not trying to find an internship or related job to my major while in college. It would have made finding a job after college sooo mcuh easier!
ruby at March 24, 2011 10:21 AM
Generally, not being a nicer person.
There've been a couple times I have been very mean to people, or if not actively hostile then at least unfriendly. And I tormented my little brothers.
There were a couple times in which I treated animals in a way I consider unacceptable, that even at the time I considered unacceptable, but did anyways.
And lately I haven't been recycling, but I promise to get organized with that again when the baby is a bit bigger. I just need to get bins to make it easier to take everything to the recycling center.
See? See the lame excuses I make?
NicoleK at March 24, 2011 10:27 AM
"The idea is that if you're a member of the gym you can workout and drop your dog off for an hour to run around and get tired. I think it'll be good for people who like to workout at the gym, want to give their dogs time to burn off their energy and yet don't have tons of time to make both things happen. "
That's a freackin' awesome idea. Go for it!
momof4 at March 24, 2011 10:29 AM
y'know Amy you added this comment in [I cut it down]:"We idealize the road not taken, imagining only the good things that would have resulted from our taking it, conveniently leaving out the bad that accompanies almost every choice..."
But I don't think regret has to be some logical idea. We DON'T invest them with much more than a wistfullness, wishing we had known then what we know now. Most people realize that you can never go back, and even if you could what would they change?
But those regrets inform you going foreward. Sometimes they make you kinder, sometimes meaner, but they are experiences, just like any other.
What I find most, is that what one person calls a regret, is what another person calls experience, and they both remember the things for the same reason, because they learned from them. Sometimes your life circles back and you apologize for what you didn't do right, but that is from THIS moment, not that other one. The person or thing you say sorry to, reacts at THIS time, they also cannot return to that one...
In that light, I think regrets aren't such a bad thing, if you learned something positive from it, even IF it was a negative thing at the time.
SwissArmyD at March 24, 2011 10:29 AM
In my situation, and what I tell my kids, is that you regret what you don't do.
For me It was Cross Country. From 7th grade thru 11th grade I was on the Cross Country team. My senior year I quit after the first week. My younger brother followed me and quit as well. His social group changed and to this day I have an empty memory. I missed out on one last season with friends.
Goo at March 24, 2011 10:30 AM
By the way, "Regret" by Guy de Mauppasant is (IMO) one of the best written, poignant short stories ever written.
http://www.readbookonline.net/readOnLine/1604/
Eric at March 24, 2011 11:04 AM
I've always been a workaholic, even at places that took me for granted. Not only to better my skills and myself, but to better the business, even if higher-ups didn't know what they were doing.
Looking back on it all, and considering how much time and effort I sunk into it all, where else could I have done so and made an honest effort that was appreciated?
I regret not signing up for national service.
lsomber at March 24, 2011 12:06 PM
Thanks, momof4!!!
NicoleK: just stop throwing out your recycling. My husband doesn't want an extra barrel in our too-small kitchen so that's why we didn't recycle. I stopped throwing away everything that is recyclable. We reached a compromise: we save all the bottles and keep them in a trash bag behind the moveable island in the corner of the room. You can't see the stuff and it gets recycled.
If you stop throwing it out it'll annoy you enough to at least put it all in a big shopping bag in the corner of the room. Eventually it'll become easier/habit.
Gretchen at March 24, 2011 12:13 PM
In my situation, and what I tell my kids, is that you regret what you don't do.
The saying is that you "regret what you don't do." I find I can regret things either way (doing or not doing). Maybe I am weird, maybe the saying is wrong, or maybe it is a matter of perspective.
I think it is perspective. For example, I mentioned that I regret staying at a job too long, though that could be viewed as not going out and looking for another job. If I had a job offer that I turned down to stay there I would probably view it differently - that I regret not taking the job offer.
The Former Banker at March 24, 2011 1:04 PM
Gretchen... the village I live in doesn't pick up recycling. The recycling center is only open 3 days a week, for two hours. I found myself often saying, "Oh, Ill go Monday", but then the baby would be napping, or nursing, or whatever. It's a pain in the ass. But, that's the disadvantage of the country.
It was piling up in the corner. I will get back to it, I swear, but I've been a bit overwhelmed lately.
NicoleK at March 24, 2011 1:12 PM
Living your life the way you want to live it is nearly as important as breathing, and not automatic, so you have to put effort into it.
It is great in theory, but can often times difficult or even basically impossible to do. Choices in one area affect others.
For example, A guy I knew from college wanted to dress his way - this was in the time of grunge and that is how he wanted to dress - yet the jobs he wanted were all clean up, polo & khakis type jobs. Nobody would hire him for the type of work he wanted. Last I knew (along time ago) he was working as clean-up at a bar.
Another guy lived a cash life - no cards or anything. The problem came when he needed to rent or own a place on his own and no one would - there was little record of him.
The Former Banker at March 24, 2011 1:31 PM
I regret both my marriages. The first one not so much, as it was a phase I had to go through to get where I am. But after that divorce and a later live-in, I had a mountain of evidence that I can't live with a woman for more than a couple of years without souring the relationship. Heedless of that, I broke up a perfectly good long-distance relationship and remarried someone else. We're still together (divorce would be more expensive than staying put), but we are, as Amy once put it, "roomies for life."
Rex Little at March 24, 2011 1:32 PM
When my old cat was put to sleep, they gave her one shot to make her doze off, and then the second one was the lethal injection. They asked me if I wanted to leave the room before the second shot, and I did, even though she wasn't quite all the way asleep yet and was still purring. I left my faithful friend alone before the end and will always regret it.
Pirate Jo at March 24, 2011 1:38 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/03/whats-your-bigg.html#comment-1956804">comment from Pirate JoSad, Pirate Jo. I'm so sorry. That one made me cry.
I'm guessing you made the rest of her life pretty great for being with you.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2011 1:50 PM
I spent my 40s thinking I had it knocked and had done everything "right." The regrets came much later. I regret not having a family when I was young enough to handle it. But I had never seen a successful marriage, didn't know how it worked, until it was too late. I have lots of friends and stepkids of all ages from two marriages (my first husband died) but it's not the same. Gonna be a lonely old age for me.
carol at March 24, 2011 2:09 PM
pirate :-( I want to hug you right now. Here, take this internet hug...You were probably overwhelmed and in some kind of emotional shock and just said yes because you were logically thinking "this sucks I need to get away". Amy's right - you most likely gave her an awesome life because you're that kind of person.
My faithful friend, Gus, died at home last year and I wasn't there. I wrapped his furry body in a blanket and told him how sorry I was that this happened to him. He was only two years old and I also regret the possibility that I didn't notice any signs he was sick. Or what if he ate something that I left around? Did my mom leave rat poison out? We didn't get a necropsy so we'll never know. I don't feel like I did right by him. So I lied in my first post - I have a regret...I I guess I just repressed it b/c it hurts.
Ok. Still at work. Eyes welling up. Must not lose my shit.
Gretchen at March 24, 2011 2:25 PM
I regret waiting for the soldiers. Ow, ow, ow, ow.
But they did my nails!
Jesus at March 24, 2011 2:45 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/03/whats-your-bigg.html#comment-1956996">comment from GretchenRight, Gretchen. Somebody who feels what Pirate Jo expressed is somebody who probably cared in ways that made the little guy's life pretty great. I try to see that Lucy has a wonderful little life...do the little things that make her happy. I'd take her everywhere with me if I could.
So sorry to hear about Gus. And sometimes, you don't really think about these things until something pushes you in that direction. But, even the bad things are part of my life and push me forward and hopefully teach me something that will make me better or at least not so stupid or clumsy about something.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2011 2:45 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/03/whats-your-bigg.html#comment-1957001">comment from JesusI regret waiting for the soldiers. Ow, ow, ow, ow. But they did my nails!
Thanks, we needed some levity...you dirty hippie.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2011 2:47 PM
Oy- I get it now.
Eric at March 24, 2011 3:03 PM
Well thanks, Amy and Gretchen. "Scooter" had been a shelter cat, and was kind of a cranky old thing, but yes, I think I gave her a good life, and she developed some sweet ways.
To be quite honest, from her perspective, I doubt she really knew the difference. She was pretty zonked out, knew she was being petted, and seemed happy. Gretchen is right, about what it was like. Scooter was half-asleep and enjoying the attention she was getting, and I was a shell-shocked basket case, just trying to keep it together so I didn't upset her. In my weirded-out mind at the time, I was thinking 'She doesn't know she's going to get a lethal injection, she's just enjoying the happy drugs, but if she can tell how spazzed I am, she might suspect.' Goofy!
So maybe I didn't do that bad of a thing, but I do wish I had done things differently, and when it's time for the Great Pug Buddha to reclaim my sweet little Holly-berry, I won't leave her side.
Pirate Jo at March 24, 2011 3:24 PM
Cheer up, Jesus!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WlBiLNN1NhQ
Pirate Jo at March 24, 2011 3:27 PM
I don't really have regrets either. My life from the outside looking in may seem like it was a difficult one, but from my perspective, it is what it is. I try to make decisions using the best information I have at any given time, and really would not go back. Things right now are looking really good and everything else done led up to this point!
Melodt at March 24, 2011 3:32 PM
Ah too funny! I spelled my name wrong.
Melody at March 24, 2011 3:33 PM
Sheesh. I envy all you people with no regrets. I torture myself over which cat food to buy.
MonicaP at March 24, 2011 4:24 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/03/whats-your-bigg.html#comment-1957281">comment from MonicaPWell, I didn't list buying Costco's Farmer John bacon (which I don't much like) as a regret, but it seemed a little petty.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2011 4:26 PM
"Awesome advice, but damn near impossible to implement when your life is so interwoven with others."
"It is great in theory, but can often times difficult or even basically impossible to do. Choices in one area affect others."
To the first comment, it's a matter of degree, isn't it? One should make one's own decisions about many of the big issues in life, shouldn't one? Not to mention some of the smaller decisions, no? If your life is that interwoven with others, maybe you need some un-weaving.
To the second comment, of course choices in one area affect others, and no one can do exactly what they want all the time. That is not what I meant.
I wonder why the notion of not letting other people make decisions for you gets people so upset?
Regretful Jones at March 24, 2011 4:59 PM
"Well, I didn't list buying Costco's Farmer John bacon (which I don't much like) as a regret, but it seemed a little petty. "
thanks for the giggle
Melody at March 24, 2011 5:48 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/03/whats-your-bigg.html#comment-1957331">comment from MelodyI go from the profound to the ridiculous, what can I say?
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2011 5:52 PM
I regret not being able to stop a dear friend from killing himself last year. The police, my ex-husband, and nearly everyone else I've spoken with have said there was nothing I could do and in fact I would've been stupid to try to interfere with a man with a gun, but I think there will always be at least a little bit of guilt and regret, such as wondering how I could've changed the outcome (hindsight, you know.il
Meloni at March 24, 2011 5:56 PM
When I was twelve, I had profound doubts about the church my parents belonged to and were raising my siblings and I in. I regret not following up on those doubts and challenging my parents. (My younger brother did five or six years later, though when he was fourteen and fifteen.)
Joe at March 24, 2011 6:08 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/03/whats-your-bigg.html#comment-1957348">comment from MeloniVery sad, Meloni. I'm sorry.
Amy Alkon
at March 24, 2011 6:11 PM
As much as I hate to say it, since it is something I won't undo, I regret getting married. Not that I don't love my wife, and I wouldn't trade my little girls for anything, but inviting marriage law into our relationship irrevocably changed the structure of our relationship.
I've seen her through cancer twice, and I'd do it a thousand times out of love. But I really don't think it is coincidence that when uncle sam gave her certain guarantees, the mutual effort in the romance department sagged. But my little girls will never awake one day without their daddy in their home if I can help it.
Nothing different than 1 million other stories.
T at March 24, 2011 6:37 PM
I regret not realizing carbs to me are like alcohol to an alcoholic 17 years ago.
Prunella at March 24, 2011 8:24 PM
Pirate Jo the cat thing really got to me. I regret putting my cat to sleep. I had her since I was a little girl and lost her only 3 years ago. When I was a child and anyone dared enter my room when I wasnt there she would stand guard and politely but profusely ask them to leave. Then when I got older and I would go out to travel she would get depressed and when I would come back she would be angry and ignore me until I apologized. I dont think there was a more loyal companion.
Ppen at March 24, 2011 10:44 PM
I only have two regrets, one that I didnt kill a certain someone once it was obvious the law wasnt going to do shit to help me. And that I wasnt strong enough to help my sister at the time
lujlp at March 25, 2011 7:32 AM
Sometimes I regret being the bringer of my own misery. I think a lot of my unhappiness in high school was a little manufactured (why was I so determined to be negative?), and if I had let it go, I think I would've really been able to get more out of it.
But then I think of college, and that was my big epiphany. I remember getting furious one day that all the promises all the adults in life made to me about college was bullshit. That life is just like high school, you never get to "graduate" out of it, and to just deal. Be who you want to be, and don't worry so much about everyone else.
So if I didn't make myself miserable in high school, I don't think I would've "found myself" in college and beyond. So while I cringe when I think of the person I was back then, I know she made me into the person I'm comfortable being today.
Hmm... I hope that made sense.
cornerdemon at March 25, 2011 8:58 AM
Ppen, I'm sorry to hear about your little cat. We always know we will outlive our pets, but no amount of foreknowledge can prepare us for how awful it is. But in the end, if they are suffering, you're caring more about yourself than about them if you don't have them put to sleep. Don't regret it - you did the kind and merciful thing.
And Gretchen you shouldn't blame yourself about Gus. Even at such a young age, he could have died from just about anything - it probably wasn't negligence on your part.
Obviously, it just sucks big-time to lose a pet. I think it's harder than many other losses, even our own parents, sometimes. Because our pets live with us, sometimes snuggle up to us at night and run to the door to see us when we get home. We start our mornings with them and see them every day. I can't wait to get off work so I can go home and see Holly. She is always so happy and such a wiggle-butt. How can we not love them? They just pull it right out of us.
Pirate Jo at March 25, 2011 10:34 AM
I don't really have any regrets. Looking back, there's not much I would have changed. The failures and screw ups really have made me a better person and certainly a lot more passionate about what I'm doing.
The one regret I have was falling off the face of the earth from my college friends for about ten years. It was really depressing to see them graduate without me and at the time I had an undiagnosed thyroid issue that left me with depression, anxiety, and very bad mood swings. Then I was held back by the embarassment of not having contacted them in forever. But I got back in touch with them via Facebook. So now I just regret being a stupidhead for the better part of a decade instead of having to regret losing them from my life forever.
Elle at March 25, 2011 11:40 AM
Pirate Jo's story hit home for me too. We very recently had to put an older cat to sleep that we rescued from an owner who gave her up. Very sweet cat, but due to being older she was also rather high maintenance (peeing all over outside the litter box, buying wee-wee pads and special food to accomodate her health issues), and I was occasionally really frustrated during the few years we had her. When she got sick enough that the hubby and I knew it was time, I felt awful for ever getting annoyed with her. In the end I was much more upset than I expected to be. So even though I know we gave her a good home, I feel regret over the exasperation and also feeling somewhat relieved that the daily clean-ups have abated.
JonnyT at March 25, 2011 11:59 AM
I don't know that I've made any decisions that I really regret (well, maybe one). There are some decisions where I wonder how my life would have been different had I decided differently, but "regret" isn't really the right word -- it's mostly just curiosity.
Cousin Dave at March 25, 2011 12:36 PM
I regret not learning, at a young age, how to be cold, hard, and calculating when it came to figuring out whom not to date. Even if it's just three coffee-house meetings or walks in the park.
That is, just as it makes sense to find out, early on, whether so-and-so does/doesn't want children, it only makes sense to determine whether that charming, well-mannered "sweetheart" just might have ulterior motives in wooing you. Such as serious money problems. (Even if you're clearly not well-off yourself.)
Trouble is, just how do you find out about those problems without asking, if there's no visible sign of them in person - or on Google? Asking "how much in debt are you" is going to sound pretty rude, no matter how you do it.
And within a year or so, you're being guilt-tripped and manipulated to the hilt. (This can start later, after marriage, of course - but not always.)
I still don't know how I could have avoided it - then, anyway - but I still hate myself for letting it happen.
Bizarrely, even the people I've told this story to don't always "get" it - e.g., years later, a very dear, gay friend of mine wouldn't speak to me for at least three months when I refused to rescue his friend (whom I don't really know) from being evicted. (If I had, I'd be worse than broke right now, assuming he wouldn't be able to pay me back within a year or so.)
What is so wrong with "neither a borrower or a lender be"? The way I see it now, borrowing money is the sort of moral disgrace that shouldn't even be talked about, much less done. (If one wants to beg for a monetary GIFT, that's sort of different - at least you're acknowledging that you're not likely to return the favor.)
Bottom line: People who have money problems should not be dating, at least not if they can't refrain from bashing innocent people over the head for help - as if the latter should be happy to be toilets for other people's problems.
lenona at March 25, 2011 2:43 PM
Thanks PJ. And the term a wiggle-butt is perfection for pugs.
Ppen at March 25, 2011 9:47 PM
I regret turning down all the girls who gave me the 'come on' because I was too stupid to know it. It started in the 8th grade and went on until I was about 30 years old. Some of them were knock-outs. I couldn't believe they were interested in me.
ken at March 26, 2011 11:14 AM
Leave a comment