Be Very Worried About Your Privacy
Jay J. Hector sent me the link about the latest incursion. G.W. Schulz writes for KGO/ABC:
Capitalizing on one of the fastest-growing trends in law enforcement, a private California-based company has compiled a database bulging with more than 550 million license-plate records on both innocent and criminal drivers that can be searched by police.The technology has raised alarms among civil libertarians, who say it threatens the privacy of drivers. It's also evidence that 21st-century technology may be evolving too quickly for the courts and public opinion to keep up. The U.S. Supreme Court is only now addressing whether investigators can secretly attach a GPS monitoring device to cars without a warrant.
A ruling in that case has yet to be handed down, but a telling exchange occurred during oral arguments. Chief Justice John Roberts asked lawyers for the government if even he and other members of the court could feasibly be tracked by GPS without a warrant. Yes, came the answer.
Meanwhile, police around the country have been affixing high-tech scanners to the exterior of their patrol cars, snapping a picture of every passing license plate and automatically comparing them to databases of outstanding warrants, stolen cars and wanted bank robbers.
The units work by sounding an in-car alert if the scanner comes across a license plate of interest to police, whereas before, patrol officers generally needed some reason to take an interest in the vehicle, like a traffic violation.But when a license plate is scanned, the driver's geographic location is also recorded and saved, along with the date and time, each of which amounts to a record or data point. Such data collection occurs regardless of whether the driver is a wanted criminal, and the vast majority are not.
While privacy rules restrict what police can do with their own databases, Vigilant Video, headquartered in Livermore, Calif., offers a loophole. It's a private business not required to operate by those same rules.
Data is being stockpiled on people, and that's a problem. The EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) on the ability to track and locate people:
EFF believes that perfect tracking is inimical to a free society. A society in which everyone's actions are tracked is not, in principle, free. It may be a livable society, but would not be our society.EFF believes that perfect surveillance, even without any deliberate abuse, would have an extraordinary chilling effect on artistic and scientific inventiveness and on political expression. This concern underlies constitutional protection for anonymity, both as an aspect of First Amendment freedoms of speech and association, and as an aspect of Fourth Amendment privacy.
More from the EFF on warrantless tracking by GPS:
"This gives police unbridled discretion to collect location data on everyone, even if there are no reasonable grounds for suspicion," said EFF Civil Liberties Director Jennifer Granick. "Investigators could track Americans on a whim -- 24 hours a day, seven days a week."At the same time, the cost of GPS tracking is dropping dramatically, while the accuracy keeps improving. This would allow law enforcement to create a massive database of Americans' movements without any judicial oversight whatsoever.
"GPS tracking enables the police to know when you visit your doctor, your lawyer, your church or your lover," said Arthur Spitzer, Legal Director of the ACLU-NCA. "And if many people are tracked, GPS data will show when and where they cross paths. Judicial supervision of this powerful technology is essential if we are to preserve individual liberty."







Going off the grid looks more appealing every day, doesn't it?
Flynne at January 17, 2012 5:54 AM
Once again we need to bifurcate society:
--All those who are willing to endure 24/7 surveillance on one side.
--All those who want "artistic and scientific inventiveness" in a more rogue state on the other side.
doombuggy at January 17, 2012 6:45 AM
They are all ready using this system in Cananda. There was a video showing it off on youtube. If I can find it I'll post it.
It's amazing how many plates it can run while driving down a crowded street, and how quickly it will pick up a hit on something. It usually gets someone for something minor like expired registration.
Mike Hunter at January 17, 2012 6:47 AM
A frequent justification for the constitutionality of this tracking is that anything you can do in public IS public, and all of these networked cameras perched on traffic lights, bridges, buildings, parking garages feeding information into computers designed to pull out the patterns and record them into databases are no different than having a beat cop notice the same information.
It's amazing we can get to 2012 and people can make this argument with a straight face.
jerry at January 17, 2012 6:49 AM
You're referring to Automated License Plate Recognition (ALPRs). Here's a video.
Jim P. at January 17, 2012 8:43 AM
I suppose the next step is a black market for "laundered" plates that crooks with enough future time orientation can swap.
doombuggy at January 17, 2012 10:02 AM
Well one that I can see happen -- your plate gets into the system because your deadbeat child, who hasn't been at home for three years, is wanted for child support. So then the ALPRs system picks your plate up. So then you end up in jail because of neglect or stupidity by the cops.
So for all intents and purposes a fat black woman in her mid 40s with missing teeth and still end up in jail.
Jim P. at January 17, 2012 8:30 PM
Leave a comment