No Special Snowflakes: Stop Special Privileges For Cops, Government Honchos
Glenn Harlan Reynolds is right on with this USA Today column noting that cops and pols do not deserve special treatment, but they're getting it all over the place:
Sometimes it involves freedom from traffic and parking tickets, like the special non-traceable license plates enjoyed by tens of thousands of California state employees or similar immunities for Colorado legislators. Often it involves immunity from legal challenges, like the "qualified" immunity to lawsuits enjoyed by most government officials, or the even-better "absolute immunity" enjoyed by judges and prosecutors. (Both immunities -- including, suspiciously, the one for judges -- are creations of judicial action, not legislation).
He notes that the Constitution prevents this:
Article I, Section 9 of the Constitution prohibits the federal government from granting "titles of nobility," and Article I, Section 10 extends this prohibition to the states -- one of the few provisions in the original Constitution to impose limits directly on states. Surely the Framers must have considered this prohibition pretty important.Well, yes. But since then we've read it rather narrowly: Basically, so long as people aren't granted titles like Baron, Duke, or Sir, nobody even considers the question of titles of nobility.
He'd like to see the ban on titles of nobility be given a second look:
How would I do it? I'd provide that any rule giving government officials -- whether elected, appointed, or members of the civil service -- preferential treatment compared to ordinary citizens would have to withstand "strict scrutiny." That is, I'd treat discrimination based on government employment status the same way we currently treat racial discrimination. To withstand strict scrutiny, a government action must serve a "compelling government interest," and must be narrowly tailored to serve that interest. And there must be no less restrictive means of achieving the same goal.
And the problem, ultimately:
The growth not only of government, but of a governing class that believes, in a very real way, that it is fundamentally above the law.
I've certainly had enough of that, and I'm tired of people re-electing legislators who lap up these privileges instead of doing the right thing and discontinuing them.








Can we start by mandating that every member of the House and Senate must participate in Obamacare like the rest of us?
No exception. No exemption.
I R A Darth Aggie at August 27, 2013 6:41 AM
A little off-topic; but still related.
What's even worse about these "special privileges" is when they actually hurt an ordinary citizen.
I've heard of a few auto accidents in which the guilty party is an off-duty cop (often times drunk!) and the other party is an average John Doe.
Not only does the drunk cop not get a ticket; the innocent party ends up getting screwed over by the "system" because the cop's friends are all trying to protect their buddy; not giving two shits about the civilian they are harming.
Also, there was the case with Gov. John Corzine (hehe, he's had some legal troubles; too bad he is not in jail) who had the state troopers speeding on the NJ turnpike (dangerously I might add) and caused an accident. The cops tried to pin the blame on a young casino worker. Luckily enough, folks came to that young guy's defense that the cops couldn't just sweep their wrong-doing under the rug.
And why was Corzine's car speeding? Was he rushing off to some state emergenct? Was he hurrying to save the world?
None of these, he was rushing so the fucker could make it to a Rutgers press conference because the women's basketball team had their feelings hurt when Don Imus called them "nappy-headed hoes."
Imagine that the Gov had to endanger other's lives because some college women had their feelings hurt by a has-been shock jock!
The founding fathers knew what they were doing when they tried to get rid of these special privileges. They knew how they could be abused and hurt ordinary civilians.
Charles at August 27, 2013 6:54 AM
"Can we start by mandating that every member of the House and Senate must participate in Obamacare like the rest of us?"
There's already a specific provision in the Obamacare law that says exactly that. Congress and the White House have decided to simply ignore it.
Cousin Dave at August 27, 2013 10:43 AM
Has anyone read the The Liberty Amendments: Restoring the American Republic?
There are a few suggestions I would add, and a few changes -- but let's get rid of "retirement" from Congress.
Jim P. at August 29, 2013 6:48 PM
Leave a comment