Schneier: We Need A Special Prosecutor
Security expert Bruce Schneier blogs about the NSA's disgusting warrantless spying on U.S. citizens:
It's time to start cleaning up this mess. We need a special prosecutor, one not tied to the military, the corporations complicit in these programs, or the current political leadership, whether Democrat or Republican. This prosecutor needs free rein to go through the NSA's files and discover the full extent of what the agency is doing, as well as enough technical staff who have the capability to understand it. He needs the power to subpoena government officials and take their sworn testimony. He needs the ability to bring criminal indictments where appropriate. And, of course, he needs the requisite security clearance to see it all.We also need something like South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission, where both government and corporate employees can come forward and tell their stories about NSA eavesdropping without fear of reprisal.
Yes, this will overturn the paradigm of keeping everything the NSA does secret, but Snowden and the reporters he's shared documents with have already done that. The secrets are going to come out, and the journalists doing the outing are not going to be sympathetic to the NSA. If the agency were smart, it'd realize that the best thing it could do would be to get ahead of the leaks.
The result needs to be a public report about the NSA's abuses, detailed enough that public watchdog groups can be convinced that everything is known. Only then can our country go about cleaning up the mess: shutting down programs, reforming the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act system, and reforming surveillance law to make it absolutely clear that even the NSA cannot eavesdrop on Americans without a warrant.
Comparisons are springing up between today's NSA and the FBI of the 1950s and 1960s, and between NSA Director Keith Alexander and J. Edgar Hoover. We never managed to rein in Hoover's FBI -- it took his death for change to occur. I don't think we'll get so lucky with the NSA. While Alexander has enormous personal power, much of his power comes from the institution he leads. When he is replaced, that institution will remain.
Trust is essential for society to function. Without it, conspiracy theories naturally take hold. Even worse, without it we fail as a country and as a culture. It's time to reinstitute the ideals of democracy: The government works for the people, open government is the best way to protect against government abuse, and a government keeping secrets from its people is a rare exception, not the norm.








WIRED did a good profile on Alexander. Apparently Washington got out of his way while he built his shadow empire.
DaveG at September 8, 2013 5:59 AM
Good luck getting the special prosecutor.
Patrick at September 8, 2013 6:05 AM
I think the whole government needs to be cleaned out. But it is the Augean stables. So full of shit you need a river to clean it out.
Jim P. at September 8, 2013 6:31 AM
Snowden wasn't the first whistle blower. There was Russ Tice before him.
Jim P. at September 8, 2013 2:11 PM
It's interesting how anyone who mentioned government spying and other secret ops-du-jour got labeled a "Conspiracy theorist", usually by the mainstream media. Now the MSM has jumped on the bandwagon, and the wolves are being let loose. It begs the question "Whose agenda is being worked on now?" Who was holding back the wolves, and suddenly decided to let them out?
No matter how much exposure the alphabet agencies are required to endure, one thing is certain-- that they'll simply move their most offending ops under new covers.
jefe at September 8, 2013 3:20 PM
That would help, but it's only the barest start. If we're ever going to deserve to be called a free country or even a republic again, we need:
* An end to the war on some drugs;
* An end to the practice, by both wings, of making up a phony emergency whenever there's a slow news day (and I include environmental and health scares as well as national security scares);
* A sunset law until the bureaucracy is cut back to something close to what the founders would ever have tolerated;
* An end to the system of lobbying (=bribery) and cronyism, so that businesses have to operate in an actual free market;
* Real accountability -- by the individual perp to the individual victim, in a fair court -- for every case of corruption or overcriminalization or "contempt of cop" or torture or civil asset forfeiture;
* And for the common people to once more be better armed than the government, so that we can count on all of the above staying that way.
As far as I'm concerned, any official who won't commit to all of the above does not represent the United States. He is part of an occupying enemy army.
jdgalt at September 8, 2013 4:57 PM
You should pick up a copy of The Liberty Amendments and pass it on to your friends.
About the only one I think he missed is adding one more:
It would totally blow out gerrymandering, the two party system, corporate favoritism and many other things.
Jim P. at September 8, 2013 6:10 PM
Here is a commentary on how the encryption is broken.
Jim P. at September 8, 2013 6:53 PM
Leave a comment