Mel Brooks On Political Correctness
He told Yahoo Movies that he was lucky he made (my favorite movie) "Blazing Saddles" before the PC police became so powerful. From Rotten To The Core:
Politically correct is absolutely wrong. Because it inhibits the freedom of thought. I'm so lucky that they weren't so strong then and that the people that let things happen on the screen weren't so powerful then. I was very lucky.
I had black friends in New York who sometimes called me "Pasty." I found this hilarious, and we would joke about race sometimes, including joking about the boring, all-white place I came from. There was no hate behind it, so it was fun -- like all our other jokes.
When you declare one group -- or certain groups -- off-limits for jokes...when that group becomes a protected class, rather like human spotted owls, that's when that group is suddenly not just made up of people, but people who need special treatment...a coddled class.
That sets them apart from the rest of us in a way that joking about them -- in the same way we joke about, say, geeks or Italians -- does not.
via @adamkissel








The next man that makes a move, the n- gets it.
Jeff at May 10, 2014 8:37 AM
The great thing about Political Corectness is that we can now eliminate any creativity,speech or activity that might offend the most delicate snow flake.
Jay at May 10, 2014 12:04 PM
My favorite movie as well. The versions shown on TV have been cut so many different ways over the years-at one time a few additional scenes with Sheriff Bart and Mongo were added to make up the time loss.
I saw parts of Blazing Saddles last week. They might as well stop running it, because without all the unPC words they cut, it sounds as if the actors all have speech impediments.
bmused at May 10, 2014 2:43 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2014/05/mel-brooks-on-p.html#comment-4609700">comment from bmusedI just love, love, love that movie. It was probably formative for my humor in a number of ways.
Mel Brooks is one of my great idols.
I just saw a question online (I think from LA Times books editor David Ulin) about what book was most formative for you as a writer. The answer is: A vast many of them -- and "Blazing Saddles."
Amy Alkon
at May 10, 2014 5:06 PM
Still think the movie would have been better if Mr. Brooks had stood up to the studio and made the movie with Richard Pryor as originally conceived.
drcos at May 11, 2014 5:16 AM
"When you declare one group -- or certain groups -- off-limits for jokes..."
Somewhat related; I'd argue somewhat the same about certain words.
When you declare certain words off limits (the "N" word comes to mind) you give that word more power than it deserves. The fact that some schools have tried to "ban" Mark Twain because he called the runaway slave "Nigger Jim" supports this view. They take offense at the language and seem to miss the whole anti-slavery point Twain was making.
An opposite example is the word "Chicano." Some things I've read suggest that the word Chicano was used mostly in a derogatory manner prior to the 1930s. Many Mexican-Americans took control of the word and turned it into a positive. How many folks today recognize Chicano as a slur instead of simply an ethnic identity without any negative connotations?
It does make me wonder if the PC police are really interested in improving things, or do they wish to retain the status quo? (rhetorical question, we all know they wish to keep things the same so that some politicians and others can claim "you need me to help fight for your rights!" without actually giving you anything.)
Charles at May 11, 2014 7:07 AM
FAVORITE movie of all time!
It does make me wonder if the PC police are really interested in improving things, or do they wish to retain the status quo? (rhetorical question, we all know they wish to keep things the same so that some politicians and others can claim "you need me to help fight for your rights!" without actually giving you anything.)
This is it EXACTLY. And then there are the race-baiters like Sharpton and Jackson to keep the momentum going.
bmused, I saw it on cable a couple of weeks ago, UNCUT and UNEDITED. It was delightful!
Flynne at May 11, 2014 7:40 AM
Politically correct is absolutely wrong.
And this. I've always said that political correctness is neither political nor correct. What it is, is an excuse for people to not take personal responsibility for themselves. It absolves them of taking any responsibility for their lives. It makes it possible for those people to justify getting hand outs. And THAT, too, should be wrong.
Flynne at May 11, 2014 7:44 AM
Me, too, about favorite, along with Young Frankenstein. I didn't remember that the extra Mongo scenes were not part of the theatrical release. I own it and watch it a couple of times per year. I miss the extra Mongo scenes -- I think it should have taken more than one attempt to "woop" him.
"...but *not* the Irish!"
Kix at May 12, 2014 6:59 AM
I went to a boys' Catholic high school in a major city in the late 60's. About half the boys were from ethnic minority groups, mostly black (although the term of art back then was Afro-American).
I am white with an Italian heritage made evident by my name. One of my teachers would occasionally call me "the WOP." It was funny. I loved the guy; he was my favorite teacher.
In an all-boys school, as you might imagine, a good old-fashioned fist fight broke out from time to time. We found them pretty entertaining; nobody was scared, and they either ended naturally (trust me, true fist fights are self-limiting) or a priest separated the combatants. Nobody made a big deal out of it.
I don't remember RACE being an issue in any of this. Maybe it was and I've forgotten. But, truly and sincerely, our school was a melting pot and nobody seemed to care about stuff outside an individual's control. What you did - your accomplishments as a scholar, a member of the debate team, a yearbook editor, an actor, a quarterback - was far more important than your ethnic heritage and your socio-economic class.
DrPinWV at May 12, 2014 4:15 PM
Anecdote (from the 1984 "The Book of Kisses" by Danny Biederman - check out his more recent book, "The Incredible World of Spy-fi"):
College campus in 1977. A male student - Wesley - asks Brooks if he would ever consider doing a sequel to "Blazing Saddles". Brooks says no and explained why:
"It's like kissing the same girl twice. You know how it is, Wesley...you kiss her once, that's a breakthrough. Twice, what are you trying to prove?"
"But I LIKE doing it twice," said Wesley.
"Then marry the girl, Wesley! Marry her! This time, it's for real!"
lenona at May 12, 2014 5:41 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2014/05/mel-brooks-on-p.html#comment-4620181">comment from DrPinWVOne of my teachers would occasionally call me "the WOP." It was funny. I loved the guy; he was my favorite teacher.
I likewise loved the guys I skated with who teased me by calling me "Pasty."
A friend of mine, Italian, refers to himself as "a wop from the Bronx."
Amy Alkon
at May 12, 2014 10:29 PM
Leave a comment