Colleges Are Pressing Out Lifelong Victims
Heather Mac Donald writes at City Journal on the modern Salem Witch Trials -- "The Microaggression Farce, the latest campus fad, which sees racism everywhere." Mac Donald believes -- and I agree -- that it's creating a new generation of permanent victims.
Even the most multi-culti on campus are not safe.
UCLA education professor emeritus Val Rust was involved in multiculturalism long before the concept even existed. A pioneer in the field of comparative education, which studies different countries' educational systems, Rust has spent over four decades mentoring students from around the world and assisting in international development efforts. He has received virtually every honor awarded by the Society of Comparative and International Education....Rosalind Raby, director of the California Colleges for International Education, says that ..."There is no one more sensitive to the issue of cross-cultural understanding."
Again, sorry, that won't stop you from being the head du jour on the platter.
Rust had changed a student's capitalization of the word "indigenous" in her dissertation proposal to the lowercase, thus allegedly showing disrespect for the student's ideological point of view. Tensions arose over Rust's insistence that students use the more academic Chicago Manual of Style for citation format; some students felt that the less formal American Psychological Association conventions better reflected their political commitments. During one of these heated discussions, Rust reached over and patted the arm of the class's most vociferous critical race-theory advocate to try to calm him down--a gesture typical of the physically demonstrative Rust, who is prone to hugs. The student, Kenjus Watson, dramatically jerked his arm away, as a burst of nervous energy coursed through the room.After each of these debates, the self-professed "students of color" exchanged e-mails about their treatment by the class's "whites." (Asians are not considered "persons of color" on college campuses, presumably because they are academically successful.) Finally, on November 14, 2013, the class's five "students of color," accompanied by "students of color" from elsewhere at UCLA, as well as by reporters and photographers from the campus newspaper, made their surprise entrance into Rust's class as a "collective statement of Resistance by Graduate Students of Color." The protesters formed a circle around Rust and the remaining five students (one American, two Europeans, and two Asian nationals) and read aloud their "Day of Action Statement." That statement suggests that Rust's modest efforts to help students with their writing faced obstacles too great to overcome.
The Day of Action Statement contains hardly a sentence without some awkwardness of grammar or usage. "The silence on the repeated assailment of our work by white female colleagues, our professor's failure to acknowledge and assuage the escalating hostility directed at the only Male of Color in this cohort, as well as his own repeated questioning of this male's intellectual and professional decisions all support a complacency in this hostile and unsafe climate for Scholars of Color," the manifesto asserts.
...The Ph.D. candidates who authored this statement are at the threshold of a career in academia--and not just any career in academia but one teaching teachers. The Day of Action Statement should have been a wake-up call to the school's authorities--not about UCLA's "hostile racial climate" but about their own pedagogical failure to prepare students for scholarly writing and advising. Rust is hardly the first professor to be criticized for his efforts to help students write. "Asking for better grammar is inflammatory in the school," says an occasional T.A. "You have to give an A or you're a racist."
The authorities chose a different course.
Yes -- ye olde head on platter.
This behavior is coming from students who have grown up in what, at any other time in history, would be considered luxurious comfort. And that is true of almost most people who grow up in America, even those who do not grow up in middle-class families.
I believe that so much comfort -- and the notion that even the slightest discomfort is a form of injustice -- has played a role in both many people's unwillingness to stand up for our civil liberties and in the witch hunts going on on campus. Oh, the horror that a professor would correct your grammar!
And yes, there's obviously all sorts of multi-culti victim studies-think behind this, too -- of course -- but I think the perceived "right" to comfort at all times is something we've overlooked.








Since these Ph.D. candidates are in a field with no career prospects other than the few and decreasing slots in their field in academia, being unable to effectively communicate while feeling full of grievances will make them well suited to join the ranks of those who demand $15/hour for performing unskilled, menial labor.
Wfjag at November 26, 2014 2:30 AM
Think of all the aggravating conversations you're going to have with these pretentious idiots while you're waiting for your latte grande at Starbucks. Then again, anyone who uses a foreign word for large while ordering coffee in the United States deserves some aggravation in their life.
The mob won. UCLA will give these "scholars" a diploma, signifying that the students have met the school's standards. I will give a degree from UCLA the respect it merits. Sometimes life is fair.
MarkD at November 26, 2014 4:17 AM
Isn't wiping your arse with their diploma a form of macro aggression, MarkD?
At this point, unless that degree is in a STEM field, I'm likely to hold it in contempt. And the person holding it? well, pity that you're now tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt for...a piece of paper with ever diminishing returns.
You could have spent the last 7 or 8 or 10 years slinging lattes at Starbucks, and at this point probably be a store manager with some prospects for your future, and not nearly as much debt.
I R A Darth Aggie at November 26, 2014 6:03 AM
"...being unable to effectively communicate while feeling full of grievances will make them well suited to join the ranks of those who demand $15/hour for performing unskilled, menial labor."
They'll demand government jobs. And they'll get them.
Cousin Dave at November 26, 2014 6:36 AM
Trying to follow Mama's advice to say something positive or don't say anything.
Multiculturalism has been great for America... when it comes to food.
OK, I feel better now.
Bob G at November 26, 2014 6:48 AM
Clearly Rust didn't know who he was dealing with. Kenjus Watson is somewhat of a scholar on microaggression. He was even invited to be on a panel at the May 2014 conference of the Black Male Institute Think Tank on behalf of the LAUSD, where he presented his views on racial microaggressions. His co-panelists, EZ Money Harper and Travis Dumas spoke about “colorism” or bias against skin colors within the Black community; they were followed by Munir Griffin who explored the role of the hip hop music genre in education.
And it works. With Val Rust booted off the UCLA education school campus for the remainder of the year, someone more culturally malleable will be brought in to lead his class.
Folly marches on.
Canvasback at November 26, 2014 7:51 AM
Based on their chosen field of study and the limited job opportunities: most of them will end up being waiters.
David at November 26, 2014 12:40 PM
I won't touch their diplomas, IRA. I'm just voicing my opinion of what it's worth, at least in the field of "comparative education." The chances of a PhD in that field applying for a job here approximate my chances of playing in the NFL, but we all have to make decisions.
MarkD at November 27, 2014 1:41 PM
Leave a comment