"Shut Up" Rules Are In Effect
More and more, there are chills placed on speech in our society by those who are offended by someone else's message.
That's sounds like what happened here -- in a situation in New Mexico that led to a teacher resigning.
From KOAT's Alana Grimstead, a creative writing teacher left her job after student wrote about Jesus and pot rather than loaves and fishes and some other student went home with her panties in twist:
"I love teaching," said creative writing teacher Katrina Guarascio. "I'm not there to judge them. I'm there to encourage them."Guarascio said her creative writing class is a safe place for students to find their voices.
The assignment was to take a fairy tale or legend and rewrite it in modern times. One student changed the biblical story about Jesus handing out bread and fish to the poor to Jesus handing out marijuana to the sick.
"I don't take any personal offense. It's not written for me. It's written for them. It's how they can express themselves," said Guarascio.
But according to the teacher, during peer review, one of the other students got highly offended by the story and told her parents. And then the teacher was put on administrative leave while the district investigated.
Guarascio said she felt targeted, harassed and forced to resign.
Actually, it is a teacher's job to judge them -- another bit of Jell-O-headed thinking that's all too common these days. But it isn't her job or anyone else's to sand down anything and everything that might be "uncomfortable" for another person.
via @mpetrie98








I heard this story last night on talk radio on my way home from work. Supposedly, the girl who wrote the story told some friends she was going to write it to get the teacher fired. I'll have to see if I can find the story with that info.
sara at December 11, 2014 6:16 AM
"Actually, it is a teacher's job to judge them -- [...] But it isn't her job or anyone else's to sand down anything and everything that might be "uncomfortable" [...]" Amy.
Yup... but many people conflate the two, and then put everything into 'does it make uncomfortable?'
and that's all they care about.
SwissArmyD at December 11, 2014 9:13 AM
In re your closing para about judging, I am not sure how you mean it to be applied. Judge the writing, the content, the subject, or what?
I do have something of a bias here, circa 1962 I was in a somewhat similar (as a student, not teacher) situation. My class was told in late September to write an essay or thesis to be handed in the next May. In late April, we were suddenly told to submit an outline of the proposed paper. The teacher rejected my project because of the subject* - and only that. Yes, over fifty years on I still resent that treatment.
- *
"Prostitution - a Historical Glance"
One tidbit I recall, Aristotle was reputedly fomd of playing "horsie" at a local business...
John A at December 11, 2014 11:17 AM
It's the teacher's job to exercise judgment. This doesn't meant chilling speech -- it means thinking critically.
This notion that one shouldn't "judge" comes out of PC culture.
Amy Alkon at December 11, 2014 1:56 PM
If students had a choice of where and if to attend school, the overseers would have so much trouble with them.
tmitsss at December 11, 2014 2:19 PM
Leave a comment