Columbia Arts Journal Dumps Social Media Editor For Her Defense Of Choosing Contest Judges On Merit, Not Skin Color
Social media editor Sara Atrice Loitz got in trouble for this response to Yasmin Belkhr:
Greg Piper writes at The College Fix:
If you don't want to be accused of racism, sexism and oppression, make sure there aren't too many men - particularly white men - in important roles in your organization.If you can't immediately fix that problem - by firing or demoting them - then just abjectly apologize and hope for the best.
Your third option is to fire the woman who defends them, then abjectly apologize.
In a whirlwind that recalls one of the central incidents in Jon Ronson's book So You've Been Publicly Shamed, Columbia University's student-run arts journal dumped its social media editor, grad student Sara Atrice Loitz, one day after an open letter criticized Columbia Journal.
The journal's sin? Using all men to judge its writing contest this year. Even worse, two of the three men were white.
Racism and sexism are completely unacceptable these days -- unless you're using them against white men.
Columbia Journal, naturally, apologized for not choosing judges based on race and sex (that is, approved races and sexes).
Next year's slate, surely: Ask not whether they have the literary chops to judge; ask whether they're gender-fluid.
via @SteveStuWill








Yes, racism and sexism are alive and well in the U.S.A., just so long as you choose the right targets. Same as it's ever been. Few will recognize the irony.
Matt at December 29, 2015 11:47 PM
Sadly, the new dark age is upon us. It seems our future is to be either run amok Sharia or run amok political correctness.
Historians, if they exist in the future, will debate the suicide of western civilization, the same as the fall of Rome.
I have concluded that our natural state is tribal. The President is wrong about the "arc of history."
"Barack's Razor," anything Barack states as truth is most likely the opposite.
Bill O Rights at December 30, 2015 2:50 AM
I want to punch Yasmin...and I'm not a violent person. Personally, I thought the social media editor's response was on the money and shame on CU for throwing her under the bus.
sara at December 30, 2015 5:34 AM
"I have concluded that our natural state is tribal. "
You're right. That's how we evolved, and it is what most of the world's nations, past and present, are based on. There's the often-repeated saying that you can never be French unless you are born in France. It's even more blatant with a lot of African and South American nations. It doesn't work very well for modern society, because tribalism is the root of prejudice and bias.
The Left's conceit is embracing it for themselves, while denying it to others. They don't realize that in a backhanded way, they are doing the others a favor, because it's the others who are embracing the concepts of modernism, while the Left rejects those concepts.
Cousin Dave at December 30, 2015 6:19 AM
I hope the grad student is smart enough to realize that she should put this event on her resume.
PC/Left/Women's Rights businesses will not hire her but this will gain her points everywhere else.
Bob in Texas at December 30, 2015 6:38 AM
It reflects that she actually knows how to think and isn't a baby duck ready to follow the other baby ducks over the edge.
Amy Alkon at December 30, 2015 7:12 AM
The revolution is never interested in fairness or impartiality.
bkmale at December 30, 2015 8:42 AM
Some day, after they purge all white men, I'll be laughing my own white male ass off at them because they will, hopefully, realize that they've only mislead themselves into believing that white men are the root of their problems.
And, I will NOT lift a single white finger to help them.
charles at December 30, 2015 9:06 AM
"You actively contribute to oppression when you demand high fees from student writers just so you can offset costs." ~ Yasmin Belkhyr
Really? So, offsetting costs is oppression? The printer, papermaker, ink supplier, and typesetter should have voluntarily worked for free? Or been forced to?
This woman is an idiot. That the Columbia Arts Journal acted on her rant says nothing positive about it or Columbia University.
Conan the Grammarian at December 30, 2015 9:39 AM
Conan: " . . . says nothing positive about it or Columbia University."
Don't forget it was a professor, Nicholas de Genova, at Columbia University that called for "a million Mogadishus" on US troops.
Professor de Genova also stated that "U.S. patriotism is inseparable from imperial warfare and white supremacy."
That he was only verbally condemned and not fired from the University back then tells us, really, everything we need to know about Columbia.
charles at December 30, 2015 10:39 AM
According to Wikipedia, "De Genova is currently writing a book on free speech during wartime in which he will examine the context in which he made his statements regarding the war as well as the pressure he came under in their aftermath."
Wanna bet he'll paint himself as a shining beacon of free speech, speaking truth to power, and equate with censorship and oppression the exercise of free speech by those who criticized him - especially the president of Columbia University, Lee Bollinger, who harshly criticized de Genova's speech. De Genova later said Bollinger had "set himself up as an apologist of war crime and apartheid,” and called upon the university president to resign.
Conan the Grammarian at December 30, 2015 3:40 PM
". It doesn't work very well for modern society, because tribalism is the root of prejudice and bias."
Um, biology and evolution is the basis of prejudice and bias. Fear of the other is what kept your ancestors alive long enough to procreate. It's a healthy fear in both the primitive and modern world.
Tribalism as you call it, is just a social system based on those evolutionary selected human traits.
Isab at December 30, 2015 3:41 PM
" ... because tribalism is the root of prejudice and bias." Always has been because "tribalism is what kept your ancestors alive long enough to procreate."
"From shooting their enemies with darts and arrows to crushing their skulls and even harvesting body parts as trophies, the ancient foragers of central California engaged in sporadic, and sometimes severe, violence, according to a new archaeological study spanning 5,000 years."
http://westerndigs.org/from-stone-darts-to-dismembered-bodies-new-study-reveals-5000-years-of-violence-in-central-california/
Bob in Texas at December 30, 2015 4:23 PM
Well, I'm sure they could immunize themselves from criticism next year by picking Ms. Bruce Jenner as one of the judges.
mpetrie98 at December 30, 2015 9:08 PM
Not really mpetrie98, Jenner is white and still has a dick
lujlp at December 31, 2015 9:38 AM
Yes, but (s)he identifies as a woman and that's what's really important, feelings.
Conan the Grammarian at December 31, 2015 2:36 PM
"Um, biology and evolution is the basis of prejudice and bias. Fear of the other is what kept your ancestors alive long enough to procreate. It's a healthy fear in both the primitive and modern world.
Tribalism as you call it, is just a social system based on those evolutionary selected human traits."
Yeah, I know, it served an evolutionary purpose in the primitive world. Trouble is, there's an upper limit to how big a tribe can be, and it's controlled by the fact that Amy often quotes, that the limit for a community where everyone knows each other is about 150 people. Past that size, it becomes a false pretense -- that someone is "safe" just because they resemble me or were born in the area where I was born.
Cousin Dave at January 1, 2016 9:20 AM
Leave a comment