The Students Who Actually Need Help At Columbia
No, it isn't the "microaggressed" doing all the squawking about their hurt feelz, but those who are quietly embarrassed about being "micro" of money, food, and housing.
Toni Airaksinen writes in the Columbia Spectator about hungry and homeless students:
The first time a Columbia student asked me, "What's the best library to sleep in?" I thought they were being facetious. When I realized the student's question was serious, I felt my face flush and was overcome with emotion. I did not have an answer.I have been asked this same question by three Columbia students so far. I've also talked with students who experienced homelessness during the summer. One such student from Columbia College told me that he lived on the streets of New York before I was able to find him someone to crash with. Another, a Barnard student, explained to me how she spent nights sleeping in Riverside Park. Some graduate students are also affected.
I have been asked by dozens more about where they can find free food and food pantries. I've had people tell me stories about how they've had sex to pay for groceries and how they've passed out because of hunger.
I've heard and read about all these stories because last year I founded Columbia University Class Confessions, an online project designed to raise awareness of socio-economic issues. It went viral for about a week, and because of that, students began to see me as a person who could connect them to help.
But I am not a social worker, and my abilities are limited. Columbia, an institution with an endowment of $9.6 billion, is not limited by the same constraints that I am. Columbia, like many other universities, has a hunger and homelessness problem. Yes, it only affects a small subset of the population, but nobody should have their ability to learn and self-actualize so dramatically impeded.
Thus, I believe Columbia (inclusive of the graduate schools, the School of General Studies, and Barnard) needs to invest in long-term resources such as a food pantry, social workers, and emergency housing for students at risk.








"As such, Columbia should invest in a food pantry. Professors such as Temple University’s Sara Goldrick-Rab have conducted research showing the prevalence of food insecurity at community colleges, resulting in a growing conversation in the media about starting food pantries at colleges. "
Wanna bet if they put food pantries in college it's going to be the BLM/Gender Studies/OCR personal FREE junk food stash?
Sixclaws at April 14, 2016 9:11 AM
"... but nobody should have their ability to learn and self-actualize so dramatically impeded."
Sorry, you lost me with 'self-actualize'.
Yes there are homeless and hungry college students. They shouldn't remain college students. Asking someone to spend thousands of dollars on education when they don't have food or shelter is a gross misordering of priorities.
Also, most cities have food pantries and homeless shelters. Colleges don't need to take on those efforts. Just keep your former students informed of available services.
Ben at April 14, 2016 9:21 AM
Disagree totally w/having special facilities for 'homeless' students.
Use the existing charities/churches.
You are not special or different from the military vet, the battered wife/mother, or the mentally troubled.
UNLIKE THE ABOVE you made a choice to be homeless in order to attend a school of your choice. NO ONE owes you anything.
Bob in Texas at April 14, 2016 10:36 AM
Personally, I couldn't attend USC, where I got in, because I couldn't afford it.
However, it's a nice change from the hurt feelz whining, and it is true that students really differ in ability to pay and how supported they are and have been financially, more than anything else.
Amy Alkon at April 14, 2016 11:00 AM
Yeah, I suppose it is a nice change of pace from the usual. However, I hear my father saying God gave more brains to a door knob than these people.
To channel Dave Ramsey, your first priorities: food, water, clothing, shelter. Then, if you can afford it, Columbia.
If not, there's always your local community college if it will get you into a 4 year program. Or, if worse comes to worse, there's always barber school.
I R A Darth Aggie at April 14, 2016 11:25 AM
I'll give a little sympathy to them, because in your 4-6 years at college, financial situations can change, and you don't want to throw away what you have already spent. Sure a leave of absence for a semester or 2 is possible, but some places won't do longer.
For example, knew one whose father died, family income dropped to basically nothing,financial aid kicked in somewhat, but vanished the next year when life insurance policy paid off.
However, these are rather rare as opposed to those who don't plan or look at the actual costs.
As to food and housing, colleges are probably the easiest places to find them with student id.
Joe J at April 14, 2016 12:35 PM
Darth Aggie explains well.
These students purposely choose to start/continue something they can not afford.
Period Dot F#$% Period
Charity dollars should not be wasted on them as they are not needy. Simply pig-headed.
Not even stubborn describes this foolishness as they could not bring themselves to solve the "problem" themselves (join the Army, find an alternative, find a sponsor or even a'sugar daddy', ...)
NOOOOOO! They just ignore the obvious.
(But Daddy, the gas stations looked dirty!)
Bob in Texas at April 14, 2016 12:37 PM
It is an interesting diversion from the cries of the professional discontents. I suspect that for a lot of the homeless students, being determined to attend Columbia was part of what put them in that position in the first place.
But nothing in the Airaksinen talks about why the students are homeless, or what proportion of the student body has nowhere to eat or sleep. Did they start out living in the dorms, but had to leave due to financial issues? Did they have some kind of problem that forced them from student housing? Were they determined to go to Columbia no matter what the cost, even if it meant living on the streets?
So many questions. If only a few students (whatever "few" means) are homeless, maybe some kind of food pantry needs to be provided. But if student homelessness is a large problem, maybe Columbia needs to be a little more careful about the financial means of the students it admits. Surely, their financial aid people are aware of how rich or poor their incoming students are; anyone applying for financial aid will have filled out a FAFSA, CSS profile, or both. Why would Columbia allow an incoming student to enroll without making sure he or she is able to manage the cost of housing?
Old RPM Daddy (OldRPMDaddy at GMail dot com) at April 14, 2016 12:57 PM
You have homeless starving students at all universities. There was a couple at OU who hung out in one of the student rec areas. When another student threw out a half eaten meal they would snatch it out of the trash. They slept in the library or lounges.
But at the end of the day reality kicks in. If you cannot afford food and shelter you cannot afford that school. You need to drop out and get a job. I don't really care about leave of absence issues. Unless you are one semester away from finishing you cannot afford to do this any longer. It sucks but that is life.
Ben at April 14, 2016 1:49 PM
Eh. There were students who slept in the libraries at UT. I can see the point of doing so. Short term shittiness for (hopefully) long term gain. I'd rather sleep in a library a few years and then get to move on to nicer things, than live in a crappy studio apartment on the bad side of town, with a car that barely runs, and no money, for my entire life because I can't get a decent job. I don't feel sorry for them, they've looked at the options and made their decision, no differently than the people who enlist and risk possible death/disability, for the long-term payoff of college paid for afterwards. Good for them for being go-getters.
Very probably, some of them could get fin aid for housing etc, but would rather not graduate deep in debt, and choose to sleep where they can, instead. Valid choice.
momof4 at April 14, 2016 5:19 PM
I have nothing but admiration for people who work through tough times to achieve their goals.
Real Americans call it "self reliance" or "pulling yourself up by your bootstraps".
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at April 14, 2016 6:00 PM
There's always a way. I let the government pay for mine, and I gave them a few years of my life (which had the potential to be the rest of my life) in return.
Life isn't fair. Then you die.
MarkD at April 15, 2016 5:40 AM
Leave a comment