Oxford Understands That The Real World May Prove Too Ouchie For Today's Students
From The Daily Mail, Sanchez Manning and Charlotte Wace write that Oxford undergrads studying law are being are being "trigger"-warned before lectures on cases involving violence and told they can leave if they fear the content will be too "distressing."
But some staff are unhappy with treating students as such fragile creatures.Law lecturer Professor Laura Hoyano last week ridiculed the concept when she jokingly warned any students from 'a farming family' that she was about to discuss a case involving foot and mouth disease.
Last night, Prof Hoyano said: 'We can't remove sexual offences from the criminal law syllabus - obviously. If you're going to study law, you have to deal with things that are difficult.'
When reruns of "Prime Suspect," the great detective show with Helen Mirren, comes on -- do they take to their beds for days, or is it just school work that provides them with all the trauma?
Oh, and how do these poor dears manage to ever walk past a newsstand without collapsing?
The reality is, if things are so terribly disturbing to you that you cannot function, you need to learn to deal with them rather than expecting the world to transform to be ouchless for you.
But the reality is, very few people are so traumatized by things that have happened to them that they cannot function; these "triggered" students are choosing to be emotionally infirm as a way to be socially "in style" and get attention.
This is covert narcissism, not real trauma. And for those who have real trauma, there's an institution that can probably help you, but it isn't one where the employees are professors. Come back to college when you, with the help of your psychiatry team and exposure therapy, get that perpetual ouchie patched up and healed.
via @CHSommers








Here's the sort of person who actually can suffer trauma:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/04/22/a-judge-sentences-a-veteran-to-24-hours-in-jail-then-joins-him-behind-bars/?tid=pm_national_pop_b
Amy Alkon at May 9, 2016 5:45 AM
I pity the poor sap who gets a public defender that skipped the lecture because of triggering on rape or armed robbery or whatever that guy is being charged for. Doubly so if that poor sap is actually innocent.
Shtetl G at May 9, 2016 7:23 AM
This 'empowers' SJWs and the students 'triggered' but adults will soon be saying "this material is for adults only, all others fail the class".
Otherwise as Shteti G says poor performance reviews will doom job opportunities (except for Human Resources),
Bob in Texas at May 9, 2016 7:39 AM
What kind of world will it be when we have to give our lawyers, therapists, and doctors trigger warnings?
Conan the Grammarian at May 9, 2016 10:38 AM
And once again, I must point out that "trigger-warnings" have no place outside a medical diagnosis of PTSD.
As long as they keep claiming to be triggered, I will keep on pointing this out. I consider this very important. And those that have co-opted this term need to be shamed.
And even more important is what "trigger-warnings" are for. People with PTSD do not use their triggers as leverage to bully people or reshape their surroundings so that everything that offends them can be removed.
Trigger-warnings are used to help PTSD patients control themselves. PTSD patients do not demand safe-spaces or that curriculum be adjusted for them. They learn to cope with what triggers them.
But I wrote an essay about that on my new Tumblr account. I find very helpful to have an outlet to express my feelings for the idiocy of today's world.
Amy, I hope you don't mind me linking my own blog post on your blog. If that's inappropriate, just remove it and let me know, so I know not to do it again.
Also, if you can, Amy, since I used your quote by Dr. Ofer Zur, can I ask where you got it from? It's this quote: “To meet the diagnostic criteria for PTSD, the stressor experienced must involve actual or threatened death or serious injury.”
I don't doubt the accuracy of his statement or that he actually said this; I just want to give the source on my own blog.
I know my stuff will never catch on with the Tumblr audience. I don't think anyone reads anything I write. I'm too wordy. But it is nice to be able to put my feelings into words and post them.
Patrick at May 9, 2016 11:02 AM
The first person singular appeared 19 times in that blog comment.
Crid at May 9, 2016 1:46 PM
Was reading about the life of Andy Grove (Intel pres). From Hungary. During WWII, the armies passed over their town multiple times, a bomb landed on their house seconds after they got to the bomb shelter, they lost everything, and had to keep moving to avoid the Nazi death squads. Then, under the communists, he had to flee through the woods to Austria. Came to US penniless.
And he did not have PTSD.
What will triggered people do when there is a shooting in their neighborhood, someone they know is killed or raped? Will they tell the world to not tell them about it?
Craig Loehle at May 9, 2016 2:10 PM
Craig: Where were you reading this?
Crid at May 9, 2016 3:09 PM
http://www.referenceforbusiness.com/biography/F-L/Grove-Andy-1936.html
I R A Darth Aggie at May 9, 2016 4:41 PM
Are you Craig?
Crid at May 9, 2016 6:48 PM
"The first person singular appeared 19 times in that blog comment."
And honestly. Yet, a more capable master of English prose would have been able to make it all about him without using it once.
Eh?
Radwaste at May 10, 2016 10:01 AM
Are you Craig?
Crid at May 10, 2016 12:49 PM
Leave a comment