The "Shut Up!" Tool Of "Islamophobia"
At Quillette, Jeffrey Tayler lays out how the left betrays the most vulnerable with the notion that if we criticize Islam, we are ugly and horrible bigots:
Those who deploy the "stupid term" ... "Islamophobia" to silence critics of the faith hold, in essence, that Muslims deserve to be approached as a race apart, and not as equals, not as individual adults capable of rational choice, but as lifelong members of an immutable, sacrosanct community, whose (often highly illiberal) views must not be questioned, whose traditions (including the veiling of women) must not be challenged, whose scripturally inspired violence must be explained away as the inevitable outcome of Western interventionism in the Middle East or racism and "marginalization" in Western countries.Fail to exhibit due respect for Islam -- not Muslims as people, Islam -- and you risk being excoriated, by certain progressives, as an "Islamophobe," as a fomenter of hatred for an underprivileged minority, as an abettor of Donald Trump and his bigoted policy proposals, and, most illogically, as a racist.
Islam, however, is not a race, but a religion -- that is, a man-made ideological construct of assertions (deriving authority not from evidence, but from "revelation," just as Christianity and Judaism do) about the origins and future of the cosmos and mankind, accompanied by instructions to mankind about how to behave. Those who believe in Islam today may -- and some do -- reject it tomorrow. (Atheism has, in fact, been spreading in the Muslim world.)
Calling the noun Islamophobia "sinister," Ali A. Rizvi, a Canadian Pakistani-born physician and prominent figure among former Muslims in North America, told me via Skype recently that the word "actually takes the pain of genuine victims of anti-Muslim bigotry and uses that pain, it exploits it for the political purpose of stifling criticism of Islam." In fact, denying Islam's role in, for instance, misogynist violence in the Muslim world, said Rizvi, is itself racist and "incredibly bigoted, because you're saying that it's not these ideas and beliefs and this indoctrination [in Islam] that cause" the "disproportionately high numbers of violent, misogynistic people in Muslim majority countries, it's just in their DNA."
Also, remember that Islam claims jurisdiction not just over its followers, but over us all, with a message directed to humanity as a whole. Which means Islam should be susceptible to critique by all.








“Islamophobia is a word created by fascists, and used by cowards, to manipulate morons.”
-- Andrew Cummins (often misattributed to Christopher Hitchens)
earthquokka at May 5, 2016 11:15 PM
Great line. And right on.
Amy Alkon at May 6, 2016 6:25 AM
Remember, a phobia is an irrational fear.
I have no fear of Amish people. They may disagree with my lifestyle, but they're not inclined to chop my head off and stick it on pike because I do not partake of their lifestyle.
I R A Darth Aggie at May 6, 2016 6:51 AM
"Islam, however, is not a race, but a religion..."
It's not even that. It's a theocratic system of government with certain religious trappings. The religious observances are of secondary importance to the government and laws.
Or do you think everyone in Saudi Arabia really prays five times a day? And Conan recently shared a link about alcohol use in the Middle East, despite the fact that alcohol consumption is forbidden in Islam.
Patrick at May 6, 2016 7:27 AM
Most religions include a government Patrick.
Ben at May 6, 2016 10:59 AM
Jesus didn't preach to his followers that they must destroy the Roman Empire and replace it with a theological government.
"Render unto Caesar" and all that.
I R A Darth Aggie at May 6, 2016 12:03 PM
If that was directed at me IRA, yes that is one religion. Christianity is hardly the only religion out there and even it often acted as a government by taxing it's subjects, providing a court system, and providing for the general good (however you want to define that). Judaism used to be a government and due to conquest became solely a religion. Taoism and to some extent Confucianism boil down to the government is god.
Ben at May 6, 2016 5:26 PM
Most religions include a government Patrick.
Bullshit.
Patrick at May 6, 2016 6:01 PM
To add a few more religions:
-Shintoism - the emperor was god.
-Ancient Egypt - the emperor was god (or his relative).
-I don't know what the North Koreans call their religion, but once again the leader is god.
By far the most common form of religion has been the guy in charge is god or a relative of god. So a key doctrine of these religions is opposition to the state is immoral.
Personally I enjoy the Confucian twist on this concept. While the government is god he is not necessarily a moral or just god. So Confucian philosophers focused on how to make their god/government into as moral and just a god as possible.
Ben at May 7, 2016 8:12 AM
Leave a comment