Take The Slow-Speed Train To Philly!
Jason Laughlin writes for Philly.com about the state of things Amtrak -- how it's faster to drive to Pittsburgh from Philly than take the train:
It's nearly 7½ hours on 350 miles of rail from Philadelphia to Pennsylvania's big city in the west. It's slower than an hour-and-15-minute flight or five-hour drive, and, at $47, comparable to the cost of tolls and gas on the Pennsylvania Turnpike. Amtrak's Pennsylvanian, which connects Pittsburgh with New York City for about 230,000 passengers a year, also leaves little room for flexibility.One train a day leaves 30th Street Station for Pittsburgh, at 12:42 p.m. There's only one return trip, at 7:30 a.m.
...Geography and track rights are the obstacles to better rail service in Pennsylvania. As far back as the 19th century, industrialists were frustrated by the current rail route. The trip's most famous stretch is Horseshoe Curve, a scenic bend around a picturesque valley near Lake Altoona, but it also illustrates the problem posed by the Allegheny Mountains. In the mid-19th century, the Pennsylvania Railroad used a route that ribboned between the mountains, rather than tunneling through them. Amtrak trains typically travel close to 80 mph, but many of those sharp turns require the train to slow. The average speed on the line is 45 mph.
The 250 miles of tracks between Harrisburg and Pittsburgh belong to the freight carrier Norfolk Southern. About 60 freight trains a day use the route, said Dave Pidgeon, a spokesman for the rail company. Passenger trains stop to make way for freight behemoths up to 130 cars long carrying products from the Great Lakes region to the East Coast, he said. And Norfolk Southern charges Amtrak to use the tracks. Amtrak didn't disclose the fees but said the cost varied based on miles traveled and incentive payments for on-time performance. Each additional train would cost more in usage fees, officials said. As for track improvements that would allow faster travel, Norfolk Southern officials said it wasn't a priority for them.
Meanwhile, the Megabus is $26 (or thereabouts). And check out cross-country ride-sharing with Skedaddle electric buses! Jonathan Schieber writes at TechCrunch:
Users can think of Skedaddle as a Lyft line or Uber pool for either a public or private weekend getaway.Initially someone planning a public trip can post their route on the app (in a bid to encourage user adoption, the person who plans the trip rides for free), and then enlists at least 9 other people to come along (at a discounted rate). Once a group of 10 is booked, the ride will happen and anyone else can come along. The chartered rides max out at 54 seats per trip.
Private trips can be scheduled for any number of people, and Nestler says the bulk of the company's business is coming from public trips.
"As we grow density and users in each city... this becomes as reliable as a schedule without a schedule," Nestler said.
Personally, because I get motion-sick in cars over any sort of distance, I'd rather take the train than a bus to Philly -- in the morning run, that is -- but train travel has to be subsidized and doesn't ever seem to pay for itself.
Here in California, we have what I call the Traindoggle.
via @Mark_J_Perry








But if you take the train, you get sex with Jill Clayburgh.
...And Patrick Magoohan may burn the Rembrant Letters and then try to kill you, but we totally make choices in life.
Crid at September 28, 2016 9:52 AM
You bring up good points here. I also just love trains.
Amy Alkon at September 28, 2016 1:15 PM
Don't miss the real obstacles to decent rail service: fees and land-use blockages.
Here in the SE, hundreds of rights-of-way lay abandoned, including straight runs to port cities from Atlanta, Augusta, etc.; these date from WW2 and earlier. When everybody thought "unlimited gasoline and clear roads", they were allowed to lapse. Now the roads are packed. Now what?
We should wait until the barn is on fire to buy a fire extinguisher, that's what.
Radwaste at September 28, 2016 2:51 PM
That must only be on the trains bound out of California. I took the train between San Francisco and Bakersfield once and not only did I not get sex with Jill Clayburgh, but I was on the Deliverance car, and I looked around and didn't see a Ned Beatty....
Conan the Grammarian at September 28, 2016 2:53 PM
You know what they say, If you dont see Ned Beatty, you ARE Ned beatty
lujlp at September 28, 2016 6:40 PM
I would like to take the train some times - particularly to visit my parents. But it just doesn't work.
Price is about the same for train ticket vs gas. Train ride takes a little longer but not too bad - totally acceptable for less stress and I can do what I want on the train.
The schedule is a bit of a hassle and just plain doesn't work for some other trips. The big problem is getting from my house to the train station. A taxi costs around $100 each way (uber does not go out this far). I can take public transit but that adds 1.5 to 2 hours. I could drive but parking is very expensive. THen when I get there some one has to pick me up and then drop me of...it is about a 20 min drive each way.
I looked at taking the train for a weekend trip where I wanted to a see a particular performance. Too far to drive but I thought I could take the train over night. Going my only option to leave was 11am and then I got in at midnight. Coming back the train left at 5:30am and in at 8pm. If I wanted a basic sleep chair it was $300 each way---$600...now here is the kicker...I had 3 flight options each way all under $300 round trip!
The Former Banker at September 28, 2016 9:18 PM
Okay, that was funny.
(Also, NB was pretty good in Charlie Wilson's War, as was everybody else.)
Crid at September 28, 2016 9:19 PM
On account of reasons, I fairly often have to go between Basel, Switzerland and Düsseldorf.
Plane: via Paris, nearly 6 hours.
Train: four and a half hours.
In Europe trains are frequent and reliable.
Also, the population density is more than twice the US. That just might have something to do with it.
Jeff Guinn at October 1, 2016 8:03 AM
Busses are more comfortable and less sickness.
Greg Nelson at June 12, 2019 8:15 PM
Leave a comment