Are You Giving Your Children Diabetes For Breakfast?
Robert Lustig writes in The Guardian about some of the awful, unhealthy, sugary things parents feed their kids for breakfast. The subhead: "With kids consuming half their sugar quota first thing, it's no wonder they're getting diabetes and liver disease":
Consider Raisin Bran. Just raisins and bran, right? There are 19g of sugar in a serving; but the raisins only account for 11g. That's because the raisins are all dipped in a sugar solution to make them much sweeter. Second, my favourite - Lucky Charms - they're "magically delicious". Why are there marshmallows in the box? Because oats cost more than marshmallows. They take up room in the box, yet the company gets to charge more. A great business strategy.But it doesn't end there. Consider a pot of pomegranate yoghurt, which has 19g of sugar. A plain yoghurt has 7g of sugar, all lactose (milk sugar), which is not a problem. Thus, each pomegranate yoghurt has 12g of added sugar. Plus, the industry hides the sugar well. There are 56 different names for sugar; by choosing different sugars as the fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth ingredients, sugar can rapidly add up to be the dominant ingredient. The US Food and Drug Administration has promised labelling changes to abolish this practice, but the EU has yet to follow suit.
Perhaps the most pernicious danger is that of infant and toddler food. In 2015 the US Centers for Disease Control examined the nutritional information of 1,074 infant and toddler food products. It found 32% of toddler dinners, the majority of child-orientated snacks, and infant-aimed juices contained at least one source of added sugar, with 35% of their calories coming from sugar.
Juice is especially terrible. Many parents think it's healthy because it comes from fruit. I see parents giving it to their kids and I feel terrible for the kids that the parents apparently don't know any better. (They surely wouldn't give their kids Drano to drink -- they want the kids to be healthy.)
Lustig uses his piece to damn "corporate interests." Yawn. There are "corporate interests" at work in the oatmeal they sell you at Whole Foods -- those pricey oats, individually steel-cut and blessed by Irish monks.
Oats, like juice, potatoes, toast, and sweetened yogurt (all of which are sold by corporations -- as is healthy meat and other healthy food), are packed with the carbohydrates that cause the insulin secretion that puts on fat.
If you have kids or if you just have a body of your own that you'd like to keep from diabetes and fatty liver disease -- among other diseases -- it might be time, as of today, to start eating low-carb.
A few great resources for that:
Tips & tricks for starting (or restarting) low-carb, by Dr. Michael Eades. Part 1. Part 2. His most recent book, coauthored with his wife, Dr. Mary Dan Eades, The 6-Week Cure for the Middle-Aged Middle: The Simple Plan to Flatten Your Belly Fast!Drs. Jeff Volek and Stephen Phinney's The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Living: An Expert Guide to Making the Life-Saving Benefits of Carbohydrate Restriction Sustainable and Enjoyable.
And these two, by investigative science journalists I have enormous respect for, are less prescriptive but really good and a great journey through the scams that have been perpetrated on the public and called science:
The Big Fat Surprise: Why Butter, Meat and Cheese Belong in a Healthy Diet, by Nina Teicholz.The Case Against Sugar, by Gary Taubes. Here's also a shortie book by Gary, The Elusive Benefits of Undereating and Exercise: from Why We Get Fat -- just 34 pages. It lays out why the ways we think we get thinner -- not eating so many calories and exercising our asses off -- are not actually the ways we do.
Finally, I haven't read Lustig's book, Fat Chance: Beating the Odds Against Sugar, Processed Food, Obesity, and Disease, but it gets very good reviews. And I blogged his terrific YouTube video, 90-minute YouTube video "Sugar: The Bitter Truth," years ago and respect him and his thinking. Here's the condensed version, which also has a link to the original.
via @bigfatsurprise








Good point about the fruit and fruit juice. I can't tell you how many people think that the sugars in fruit are magically healthy for you because they're "natural". Belladonna is natural too.
Cousin Dave at June 23, 2017 6:01 AM
Juice and pre-sweetened cereals are only part of the problem. I was raised on that stuff and I didn't get fat.
The other part of the problem is that when I was a kid, playing meant going outside, getting on my bicycle and disappearing until dinnertime. Not sitting at home playing World of Warcraft.
Patrick at June 23, 2017 6:31 AM
I think you're being unclear about the "corporate" thing. The switch to sarcasm and back can't be tracked.
Juice.
Crid at June 23, 2017 7:09 AM
The other part of the problem is that when I was a kid, playing meant going outside, getting on my bicycle and disappearing until dinnertime. Not sitting at home playing World of Warcraft.
For some parents, though, a better diet is all that can be done. Letting your kid ride off on their bike or roam these days can result in a call to the police for child endangerment. Kids still can roam in rural areas and in low-income urban areas. But in "nicer" suburbs? You'll get nailed to the wall with the assistance of your "helpful" neighborhood moms.
But I agree that diet is only half the equation. My cousins' kids eat healthier than I do, but they don't have the coordination or core strength to climb a tree.
sofar at June 23, 2017 7:54 AM
Some veggies diced up, sauted in butter till warm, throw in some eggs, top with cheese. Takes 3 minutes. Super delicious.especially now with my home-raised eggs!
I like potatoes occasionally. I like a good beer. Corn tortillas will always have a place here. For me, cutting carbs left room for the ones I really like. Im a nurse and patient families forever bring in Round Rock Donuts. The other day my coworker ate 4. They didnt even tempt me. Flour and sugar: ugh in any form. I had high triglycerides and high cholesterol when i ate a high carb diet. Now, i have super-high good cholesterol, low bad cholesterol and low triglycerides. My blood glucose level the other day, 3 hours after lunch, was 76. It doesnt spike and drop, it stays level. Leafy veggies, cheese, meat, fatty salad dressing. Eggs. Bacon. All so good.
Momof4 at June 23, 2017 7:57 AM
I struggled through Good Calories, Bad Calories, but it was The six Week Cure that got me started on low carb eating. Eight years later, my wife and I still have protein shakes for breakfast from the recipe in the book.
Thanks again for getting us started blogging about low carb.
Steamer at June 23, 2017 8:46 AM
Sofar, there IS something else the parents can do to keep kids trim - and so many don't. Namely: get them in the habit of "helping" with chores while they're young enough to be fooled into thinking it's just a game. Yes, your chores will likely take twice as long (or longer) that way, but not as long as it would take if you tried to get them to play or look at picture books by themselves (no, screen time is NOT benign), only to find you have to keep them from getting bored and into mischief all the time. Chore-helping will be good practice for later years, when they start complaining there's nothing to do. Even a three-year-old can use a dustpan and brush - or wash floors with a dripping sponge. Or fold small laundry items.
My point, of course, is that chores can be very good exercise if done daily - and too often, even school-age kids aren't expected to do them, for various asinine parental reasons!
(I suspect one big reason is that parents can't stand the thought of being accused of being "mean" if they don't let their kids have more than two hours of screen time a day when other kids probably have six hours, not counting homework.)
lenona at June 23, 2017 9:00 AM
Here's a way to incorporate juice into a healthy lifestyle"
Dilute it with vodka!
And hey, give some to the kiddies!5
Works wonders with those pesky behavioral issues!
Donald Hump at June 23, 2017 11:48 AM
Blarg! Please excuse the typos.
Donald Hump at June 23, 2017 11:53 AM
Sofar, there IS something else the parents can do to keep kids trim - and so many don't. Namely: get them in the habit of "helping" with chores
Agreed. That's what my parents did with me, ESPECIALLY on days I thought I had "nothing" to do. Yard work, especially. Cleaning the garage. Raking leaves. Pulling weeds. Cleaning the basement. Mopping, sweeping. Gardening.
At the same time, though, chores probably occupied 50 percent of my weekday summer vacation days. And, even if you give your kid 6 hours of chores a day to do, there's another 6 hours to occupy. If I didn't have the ability to roam the countryside, I don't know what I'd have done during the summer after chores. Because I know my parents wouldn't have been able/willing to spend the entire day shuttling me around to the kind of "safe," "structured" activities that are now the norm.
But, yeah, chores are falling by the wayside these days, and that's a shame.
sofar at June 23, 2017 12:25 PM
So glad, Steamer. Thanks so much for that note.
I didn't get fat on juice, either, but there are individual differences in how well we can handle carbs. All in all, from everything I've read, it makes sense to avoid starchy and sweet carbs (and only take in the few that are in vegetables, dairy, etc.).
I got food poisoning a few weeks ago and had some blood tests. My health stats are wildly, wildly better than when I was running seven miles three times a week back in 2007/8/9 -- wildly stupid and bad for my knees, by the way.
Anyway, I'm as likely to have a heart attack now as I am to be kicked in the knee by a unicorn. And I just spent about three years writing a book and barely leaving the house for the last year and a half or so.
Amy Alkon at June 23, 2017 3:22 PM
"Kids still can roam in rural areas and in low-income urban areas. But in "nicer" suburbs? You'll get nailed to the wall with the assistance of your "helpful" neighborhood moms."
Starting with the selection of neighborhood. I count bikes when I have to drive through housing, and the number is appalingly low.
I know a couple who WILL NOT buy their son a bicycle "because he might ride it out of sight".
The neighborhood moms have been successfully infected with fear, courtesy of for-profit "news" programs - which, you will note, feature talking heads before and after any actual footage of an event to carefully explain what you should think.
Radwaste at June 23, 2017 5:25 PM
That six week program... July is not a good time to take this on, but it looks like I won't be buying boxed wine come August.
Thank you.
Michelle at June 23, 2017 6:25 PM
Sorry, but at least 50% (of energy) of our diet should be carbohydrate. After all our brain runs purely on glucose. This is what the science of nutrition tells us. Taubes and Teicholz are dubious sources for nutritional advice. They cherry pick their research data and Teicholz has been accused of plagiarism by Seth Yoder at thescienceofnutrition.com. The best nutrition advice always comes from dietitians for they are the only professionals qualified to give it. Perhaps the best diet going right now is called the DASH (dietary approaches to stop hypertension.)diet and I am certain that all dietitians would agree on that. Whether or not it is sustainable is another story. Respectfully, Dan Bertini.
dan bertini at June 28, 2017 7:08 AM
Leave a comment