Demanding Discrimination In Museum Curator Hiring
When there's a show of French impressionists and they need to hire a curator, they don't look for a white French person whose great, great, great whomever lived next door to Claude Monet.
Accordingly, when The Brooklyn Museum was looking for a curator for their African art collection, they simply picked the person they found who was highly qualified for the job.
That's how things have worked in employment for employers who are not racists or dumbshits for a long, long time.
I always hire the best person for the job, and it's always interesting to see who that ends up being -- what their profile is. My assistants have been gay, straight, black, Korean, and white. There was an Irish woman and a guy who was half Eastern European Jew and half Persian. Currently, my assistant is a (now-sober) former junkie who was arrested on felony charges (knocked down to a misdemeanor with community service).
She's wonderful, thanks, and has worked for me for three years -- and shows up for me over and over in a way few people can be relied on to do.
Anyway, about The Brooklyn Museum, Dean Balsamini writes in the New York Post that there's outrage in the black community that white Kristen Windmuller-Luna was tapped to curate its vast African art collection.
She "has a Ph.D. in African art history from Princeton University, lectures in Columbia University's department of art history and archaeology, and once worked as an educator for the Metropolitan Museum of Art, where she was 'responsible for adult and college gallery tours in the African galleries.'
More from the Balsamini's piece:
Despite the stellar résumé, her hiring left some wondering why a qualified person of color did not get the post....The museum defended its decision.
"Kristen is the perfect choice to build upon the Brooklyn Museum's track record as an innovator in the collection and exhibition of the arts of Africa," said Jennifer Chi, the museum's chief curator, in a statement.
The museum said it was "committed to equity" but would not discuss the hiring process with The Post.
In other words, they're not letting themselves be bullied into a racist redo of their hiring process.
By the way, the article notes a Mellon demographic study noted that that "people of color" (possibly Balsamini's term, not Mellon's) occupy 42 percent of "intellectual leadership positions" at the Brooklyn Museum.
That's well over the percent of black people in the population. Let's just hope the hiring process was "best person for the job," which is how it should be.
Oh, and check out one of the tweets about the hire of Windmuller-Luna:
"People from the African Diaspora are frustrated w/white people being gatekeepers of our narrative," tweeted Kimberly Seldon.
Pathetic.
Does somebody eat, sleep, and breathe African art? Great.
Their skin color should be unimportant.








By the way, the article notes a Mellon demographic study noted that that "people of color" (possibly Balsamini's term, not Mellon's) occupy 42 percent of "intellectual leadership positions" at the Brooklyn Museum.
Sounds like pervasive and institutionalized racism to me. US DOJ should investigate!
I R A Darth Aggie at April 2, 2018 7:27 AM
What's with this "person of color" thing? That sounds like a hoity toity way of saying "colored person;" a term I thought was racist.
If these SJWs are going to change the politically correct term every couple of years they need to put out a memo. That way people with real lives won't be tricked into using wrong (read racist) language.
Jay at April 2, 2018 8:30 AM
Jay, Lewis Carroll will explain what's going on.
I R A Darth Aggie at April 2, 2018 8:57 AM
"That way people with real lives won't be tricked into using wrong (read racist) language."
But that was the goal Jay. They want to call you dirty names so you willingly cede authority to them.
Ben at April 2, 2018 9:09 AM
This just makes me more convinced of a nascent idea that I've been nurturing:
In South Africa, the White population is facing a dreadful level of persecution by some Blacks, as well as the ANC-led government in the form of land reform. This violence includes the killing and wounding of some White farmers. I would have no problem in accepting these persecuted folk -- all five million of them -- as refugees or green carders to come contribute to our wonderful country.
Meanwhile, we offer the 5 million most ungrateful, angry, and/or violent Black people (such as Je$$e Jack$on, Al Sharpton and the people screeching about this museum's hiring process) voluntary one-way trips to South Africa -- undoubtedly to be renamed Azania sometime in the future -- where they can live in racial harmony and where everyone hired will be Black, so complaints will be few. I would have no problem with our government paying their way.
Win-win.
mpetrie98 at April 2, 2018 11:57 AM
I have a vague recollection of another race-baited incident surrounding art. It seem that a white artist chose to paint a young black victim of white racists lying in state.
Apparently, white people aren't allowed to paint black people any more.
Patrick at April 2, 2018 5:01 PM
Oh, I almost forgot. Regarding the term "people of color," I refuse to use it.
It is intended to be an exclusionary term, so I call them what they are: non-whites.
Patrick at April 2, 2018 5:02 PM
about that tweet:
"our narrative"?
OUR?
Just what makes that person think that THEY, and they alone, own it and others don't have a say?
If one truly wants the truth of history; then, several voices have to be heard - there isn't just ONE narrative. That goes for ALL history.
charles at April 2, 2018 5:47 PM
I've just read an article in the Guardian - well skimmed really, a Very offended woman writing, then skipped to the comments, 350+ of them, and very very few were of the same opinion (didn't read them all, though). Sanity does still rule.
Article here - Why are white curators still running African art collections?
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/apr/03/brooklyn-museum-white-curators-african-art-open-letter
CarolBT at April 3, 2018 12:33 PM
wow. thanks for exposing this myopic crap view of the world...where others can dictate others' art and lifestyle just becuase, "justice?" NO.
elleb at January 4, 2021 10:13 PM
Leave a comment