We Can't Just Release Somebody From Prison And Expect Them To Be Functional
But that's exactly what we do -- which often sends the person on a path right back to prison or debilitates them in other ways.
An example is the case of two brothers chronicled in a New York Times piece by Joseph Neff:
FAYETTEVILLE, N.C. -- The state of North Carolina paid $750,000 to Henry McCollum in 2015 to compensate him for the 30 years that he, an innocent man, spent on death row.Seven months later, he was broke. Mr. McCollum, who is intellectually disabled, then began borrowing money at 38 percent interest. He kept his financial plight hidden from friends and supporters from his death row years.
But last fall, he briefly and wearily opened up when he was handed documents showing he owed $130,000 on $65,000 in recent loans.
"Sometimes I feel like I shouldn't be out here," he said.
Mr. McCollum and his half brother, Leon Brown, who is also intellectually disabled, were demonized and convicted in one of the state's most notorious rape and murder cases. Their decades in prison and their disabilities would have made for a difficult return to society under the best circumstances.
What happened to them after their release proved even more problematic. As exonerees, they emerged with big dollar signs on their backs. Most states compensate the wrongfully imprisoned in amounts that can reach millions of dollars, and exonerees can also win settlements from police agencies -- awards that can attract predators.
Mr. McCollum, 54, and Mr. Brown, 50, proved virtually helpless as hundreds of thousands of dollars of state compensation were siphoned off by their supposed protectors: a sister back home; a lawyer from Orlando, Fla.; a self-proclaimed advocate from Atlanta, and her so-called business partner, a college instructor from Brooklyn, according to documents and interviews by The Marshall Project.
By the time a federal judge intervened in the spring of 2017, no trust had been set up for the brothers and money intended for their care had been spent on predatory loans, exorbitant legal fees, multiple cars, women's jewelry and children's toys.
A man named Jeffrey Deskovic, also an exoneree, created a foundation to help the wrongfully convicted. He told Neff that he had advised about 60 other exonerees on managing compensation and the attention from those trying to get a piece of it.
He deemed McCollum and Brown's experience extreme, but said the underlying dynamics are common: "All were hit up for money by family and friends or were targets of scammers."
This story was especially resonant for me because, last week, at the professional non-fiction authors group I'm a part of, three of us with books out recently did a reading.
Cari Lynn went just before me, and read from "Becoming Mrs. Burton," which she co-authored with Susan Burton, a former felon who started halfway houses for other women released from prison.
The subtitle: "From Prison to Recovery to Leading the Fight for Incarcerated Women"
This is, as the jacket copy on Amazon puts it, "the life story of Susan Burton, whose organization A New Way of Life has transformed the lives of more than one thousand formerly incarcerated women in Los Angeles." She did this through halfway houses she created to provide a landing pad and structure for women just released from prison so they wouldn't go back.
A bit from the book that Cari allowed me to print here:
There's also no logical reason why federal prisons offer halfway houses to those newly released, but state prisons provide nothing. Four thousand newly released women arrive in Los Angeles County every year to nothing. No re-entry programs, no counseling, no services, no assistance. You have no house key, no credit card, no check-book, no driver's license, no Social Security card, no identification of any sort because anything you were carrying when you were arrested has been destroyed by the state. You're just one woman in the crowd of mostly black and brown faces, one number in the recidivism stats that are decidedly not in your favor.Like vultures, the pimps circle, eyeing you, assessing you. The drug dealers circle. You know them from the old neighborhood, and they call you by name, offering their brand of a welcome home party. You have little incentive to say no.
Ego tells you you're gonna make it by any means necessary. Ego tells you you're a grown woman. But you're scared. How do you calm yourself? How do you connect with something healthy and hopeful when you're surrounded by Skid Row? When you haven't been allowed to make a decision in five, ten, twenty years? When all you want to do is wash prison off you, but you can't, because it's in you. It's seeped into your psyche and into your soul.








If a broad and thoughtful coalition of private individuals (or churches, maybe) decided to reach out to help prisoners upon their release, I'd contribute.
But most every time someone uses the word "we" nowadays, they mean government. I get tired of being told that citizenship *compels* me to take an intimate interest in the lives of others.
Crid at April 18, 2018 9:27 AM
We Can't Just Release Somebody From Prison And Expect Them To Be Functional
Same thing applies to high school.
Ken R at April 18, 2018 12:58 PM
This.
As someone once said, "It's no fun helping people over 20 navigate their way through belated adolescence." Especially when you have to pay for it with your own hard-earned funds and you're approaching those years when what you have in the bank is all you're going to have.
Conan the Grammarian at April 18, 2018 1:22 PM
Just out of curioisty how is this dude any better or worse off than about half the players in the NFL, or people who win the lottery?
Simon says, unless you are judged mentally incompetent, you have the freedom to blow your own money, and many people do.
My father used to say, divide all the money in the world evenly among all the people and with a small percentage of exceptions, the rich and the middle class would have it all back again in five years, and the poor would be even worse off.
Because what counts is not the money, it is the values and the attitudes of those who know how to make it, and how to save it.
It’s like home ownership. You can’t just give people houses. They dont have the means to maintain them.
Isab at April 18, 2018 2:39 PM
"Same thing applies to high school."
Why not? We used to.
"You can’t just give people houses. They dont have the means to maintain them."
Correct. Guess what happened to a big number of Extreme Home Makeover winners...
Radwaste at April 18, 2018 6:07 PM
"Same thing applies to high school. " Ken R
When I saw the title I thought it would be about HS.
And frankly that is where we should start. Learning life skills and a non-entitled mindset in HS. Too often that takes a backseat to politically pushed.
Joe J at April 18, 2018 6:17 PM
I would say that making sure prisoners have the skills not to repeat their crimes is somethig we do for us, not them. It is not altruism it is self preservation.
Prison should be a place for rehabilitation and life skills, if the person is going to be released. And yes, a half way house or other easing out of prison solution should be part of that.
I agree they -should- get themselves a job and a social network of upstanding citizens immediately upon release but that is a fantasy.
Nicole Krieger at April 18, 2018 9:22 PM
> somethig we do for us, not them
If I may ask once again... Whaddya mean, "we"?
Because I'm pretty sure you mean compulsory funding for, deployment of and submission to government authority.
You ought not pretend to be all warm 'n fuzzy about this, even with a pragmatic eyeshade.
Crid at April 18, 2018 9:25 PM
By "we" I mean the government, yes. I do think crime prevention is part of government's job. I don't want to deal with criminals running around desperately becoming more hardened. I don't want to step over dying crack addicts as I go about my business. Towns with lots of beggars are very unpleasant.
If there is research that shows support systems reduces crimes and begging and general vagrancy, yes, I'm for it.
NicoleK at April 19, 2018 10:55 AM
As far as I can tell NicoleK studies show that support systems reduce crime but reality shows no effect. That whole nonreplicable issue Amy some times harps on. You can make this work with a small group of selected people but when you try to roll it out to the general populace you get nothing. So it is a waste of money and expertise.
Ben at April 19, 2018 11:10 AM
What do you mean by "reality shows no effect", do you mean that there have been studies that show that in larger populations there has been no effect, or do you mean a few people have some anecdotes?
If in fact there is no effect, then I agree it is pointless. If there is an effect shown, it should be replicated.
Like this one:
https://www.prisonerresource.com/recidivism/vegan-diet-impacts-recidivism/
It seems to have worked. Seems to me it would be worth replicating to see if it would work again.
NicoleK at April 21, 2018 3:44 AM
I forgot about THIS:
"Most criminals are careerists. Crime is what they do. It is all they will ever do. Look at their rap sheets. In and out, in and out. Seven grand theft auto, four rapes, four possession with intent to sell, six assault and battery. I don’t know how many times I’ve covered a woman stabbed thirty-seven times (an actual case) at an ATM by a guy out of parole for something only slightly less gaudy.
But he got out because he told some dumb parole board that he done found Jesus, yes, Jesus mah man now, all I wants is to do de Lawd’s work. Which apparently includes stabbing a woman thirty-seven times. The Jesus business is a staple of prison propaganda." - Fred Reed
Radwaste at August 6, 2019 5:30 PM
Leave a comment