Ally Sheedy Is Irate That Actresses Are Judged On Their Looks
Hollywood is a place (and a situation, really) where the hottest cheerleader from every town in America comes, only to find that she's just, oh, a solid 7, compared to all the other hot cheerleaders from all the other towns.
The actresses who do well in the movies -- save for the character actresses who dress up the scenes as best friends, criminals, or whatever -- are earning a living for being hot on screen and (ideally) for having okay or better acting talent.
There's something else, too -- it's force of personality. But if you aren't hot (meaning that you look fuckalicious), and you aren't very, very lucky, you're unlikely to be big in Movieland. (TV, on the other hand, has become something different, where "character actresses" can do pretty well -- but fuckaliciousness counts there, too, of course.)
This is pretty obvious to most people -- and kind of a given.
Yet, professional actress Ally Sheedy takes it upon herself to lament the looks-driven reality of Hollywood -- which is kind of like lamenting how in professional baseball, somebody's always throwing a ball your way.
On one of my first auditions, a director told me he liked me but could not possibly cast me because there was a "beach" scene. Apparently, my thighs and ass were going to get in the way of my fledgling career. I was five seven and weighed about 130 pounds.It did not matter that I did a good job on auditions, that I was smart, that I had natural ability. My thighs were the "thing."
So I dieted. All. The. Time. I learned that whatever I might contribute to a role through talent would be instantly marginalized by my physical appearance. I learned that my success would be dependent on what the men in charge thought about my face and my body. Everything I had learned back home had to go out the window as I adapted to these new requirements: what I looked like was paramount.
It wasn't even just whether I was pretty or thin; it was that I wasn't sexy. When I managed to land my first part in a big movie, I was given a ThighMaster as a welcome present and told to squeeze it between my legs at least a hundred times a day. A director of photography told me he couldn't shoot me "looking like that" when I walked on set one day. He said it in front of the whole crew. I was too wide, I guess, in the skirt they had given me to wear.
A few years later, I was told point-blank that my career was moving slowly because "nobody wants to fuck you." There was something about me, sexually, that wasn't selling.
...I'm still navigating the sexual appearance standard in professional work. When I am called to consider a role or audition for a role in TV/Hollywood Land, my talent is never in question. The "studio" or the "network" wants me on tape to see what I look like now.
This is the movies, dear, not the genetics lab.
Her entire essay is an example of intrasexual competition -- criticizing and trying to change the standards of female competition by one who falls a bit short of them.
Because so many people are so ignorant of our evolved psychology and in denial of biological sex differences (and the psychological sex differences that come out of them), they don't get that there is pressure on men, too, to meet women's differing mating priorities.
As for those differing priorities, well...you don't see men writing essays about how rotten it is that you can't get a hot girlfriend (or probably any girlfriend) while unemployed and sleeping on a couch in your grandma's basement.








Hollywood is a place (and a situation, really) where the hottest cheerleader from every town in America comes, only to find that she's just, oh, a solid 7, compared to all the other hot cheerleaders from all the other towns.
College is a place (and a situation, really) where the smartest kid from every town in America comes, only to find that she's just, oh, a solid 7, compared to all the other brainy kids from all the other towns.
Yep, welcome to life. Happens to most of us, one time or another.
Old RPM Daddy (OldRPMDaddy at GMail dot com) at May 13, 2018 5:41 AM
When your looks are central to your life, growing old is tough, and even more so when you don’t have much else to offer.
Wfjag at May 13, 2018 5:55 AM
I wouldn't kick Ally out of my bed.
Well, except to go make me a sammich.
I R A Darth Aggie at May 13, 2018 6:10 AM
I found a similar article by her cousin Alan Sheedy:
On one of my first auditions, a director told me he liked me but could not possibly cast me because there was a "fight" scene. Apparently, my 5'2" height and beer gut were going to get in the way of my fledgling career. I was five two and weighed about 200 pounds.
It did not matter that I did a good job on auditions, that I was smart, that I had natural ability. My soft appearance was the "thing."
It seems I was unable to get starring roles as super heroes or macho spies, gunslingers, etc. despite my great acting ability and character.
A few years later, I was told point-blank that my career was moving slowly because "nobody wants you to fuck them." There was something about me, sexually, that wasn't selling.
I was shocked, shocked I tell you that producers wanted stars that people would pay to watch in their movies. Oh, the humanity!
Jay at May 13, 2018 6:38 AM
That was my story. In high school, I was the smart but lazy kid. I was sleeping in class, doing my homework on the bus, and writing term papers in the class before the one in which the paper was due. Then, I got to college and half-assing it didn't work.
========================================
To Sheedy's point, Hollywood is overly fixated on looks and drama. I was watching a British mystery program last night and the women were unusual in that they were ordinary. The frumpy housewife was not played by a supermodel with fake glasses, but by a somewhat dumpy hausfrau. Likewise, the tired, middle-aged detective was not played by a tall, thin guy with a full head of hair, but by a short, dumpy, balding guy with the beginnings of a gut.
Nor were we asked to believe that he was a former Navy SEAL out for vengeance or a genius with a 197 IQ. He was just an astute observer of humanity doing a job. No one was gay or transgendered. No one was fighting the demons of a troubled past come back to haunt them. The characters in the show were just people, ordinary people - except for the one who committed murder.
Conan the Grammarian at May 13, 2018 9:04 AM
A few years later, I was told point-blank that my career was moving slowly because "nobody wants to fuck you."
I think this might mean nobody like Harvey Weinstein.
Ken R at May 13, 2018 9:15 AM
"As for those differing priorities, well...you don't see men writing essays about how rotten it is that you can't get a hot girlfriend (or probably any girlfriend) while unemployed and sleeping on a couch in your grandma's basement."
Google "incel".
Maybe their writing doesn't rise to the level of an essay, but they are certainly making the complaint.
Steve Gerrard at May 13, 2018 11:42 AM
Is she only complaining because she can't land an acting job any more?
charles at May 13, 2018 12:23 PM
Steve, you beat me to it. Especially the part about how their pieces aren't exactly mature/articulate/sophisticated enough to be called "essays." But they certainly count.
For anyone who didn't see this:
"Sex and Shame: What Incels and Jihadists Have in Common"
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/30/opinion/sex-shame-incels-jihadists-minassian.html
Check the comments too - the NYT Picks mention things the op-ed writer didn't.
And in Google News, I found scary articles ABOUT incels by David Futrelle and Dan Savage - plus conservative Ross Douthat's column on sex robots - I never thought I'd see the day.
Btw, while I certainly don't want to date someone who's chronically unemployed, there are other pretty important factors too; anyone who never wants to go outdoors or who has almost no speaking vocabulary (believe it or not, I know a novelist who's like that) is also off my list.
lenona at May 13, 2018 1:37 PM
"Is she only complaining because she can't land an acting job any more?" charles
Probably a big part of it. Much is due to how high of a pedestal young pretty women are put on, they think they deserve it always, and when their youth and/or looks fade it's quite a drop. They cry unfair about the drop but conveniently ignore the crazy heights they got when they were young.
Joe J at May 13, 2018 2:16 PM
Everything about life is "unfair" in some sense. It is unfair that I'm too short for basketball. Unfair that I didn't inherit a fortune. Unfair that we get old. People really need to get over it. In hollywood, there are maybe 1000 top actresses (the name ones) out of 350,000,000 people in the US. And part of many roles is sex appeal because life includes sex and looks matter, especially for beach or nude scenes. It is like saying it is unfair that sports require speed.
cc at May 13, 2018 2:23 PM
The market doesn't lie, even to make you feel better.
Let Sofia Vergara walk into your restaurant, and few will notice much else.
That should answer any question about who the public will pay to see.
Radwaste at May 13, 2018 3:14 PM
The one grain of truth in Sheedy's screed is that Hollywood is, in fact, pretty damn shallow. But it's that way for everyone. John Wayne was a great actor, but he didn't get all those roles solely for that reason.
Cousin Dave at May 13, 2018 6:46 PM
How sad that Marie Dressler, Mae West, Kathy Bats, and Queen Latifah are unknowns.
KateC at May 13, 2018 9:22 PM
KateC, explain? I don't follow. I would very much have wanted to meet Marie Dressler (1868-1934), but I suspect that for the last half-century or so, only diehard film enthusiasts have recognized her name. (Unlike with Mae West, who was also clearly better looking.)
But if you're simply referring to the fact that all four of them were highly successful despite three of them being overweight and Mae West's not getting into the movies until age 39, I get it.
lenona at May 14, 2018 10:10 AM
Steve, you beat me to it. Especially the part about how their pieces aren't exactly mature/articulate/sophisticated enough to be called "essays." But they certainly count.
______________________________________
Of course, anyone who's unknown and chronically unemployed likely CAN'T write well enough to get published in a respected publication anyway.
I would add that WOMEN who are reasonably attractive but have trouble holding a job should not complain about not being able to get a boyfriend, either. After all, even a man who thinks he wants a housewife might think twice about marrying someone who couldn't support him should he get hit by a car.
Also, if you only count those men who actually CALL themselves incels, I wonder how many of them really have trouble earning a living, as opposed to those who think their good looks and good jobs should make up for their very bad issues. Like George Sodini, who couldn't get a second date with anyone for years - and became a murderer.
lenona at May 14, 2018 10:25 AM
I used to want to bang Breakfast Club Ally Sheedy.
Rodney B Smith at May 14, 2018 10:47 AM
And here's a cartoon I remember (sorry, I don't know how to find it online):
A slim woman, who's job-hunting, is standing before her interviewer. She says unhappily:
"You're not hiring me? It's because I'm fat, isn't it?"
lenona at May 14, 2018 11:47 AM
Leave a comment