Physics Doesn't Know Or Care What Color You Are
Ridiculously, the Portland, Oregon NAACP is leading a coalition protesting an ordinance there that requires building owners to announce with a plaque if their structure is not earthquake-safe -- meaning shored up so it won't collapse and kill or main all the people inside.
In the Portland Mercury, Blair Stenvick reports that "the coalition believes that the ordinance places an unfair burden on building owners affected by the ordinance--many of whom are people of color":
The ordinance specifically targets unreinforced masonry buildings, or URMs, the first buildings to collapse in the event of a major earthquake. It requires that these buildings--about 1,600 altogether--have an 8-by-10-inch plaque stating: "This is an unreinforced masonry building. Unreinforced masonry buildings may be unsafe in the event of a major earthquake."The Portland City Council voted on the ordinance, which also requires the earthquake-unsafe information to be mentioned in all future building leases, last October. It will go into effect on March 1.
The NAACP-led coalition argues that such requirements place a "Scarlet Letter" on older Portland buildings, including many Black-owned businesses, music venues, and churches, and will make it difficult for owners to lease, refinance, or mortgage their buildings.
If you own property that others live and work in -- or that people could be injured walking past -- you have a responsibility to make it safe (or at least announce that it is unsafe so people can decide whether it's worth it to them to risk being in or around it).
Typical race baiting:
In an energetic speech to kick off the rally, NAACP Portland chapter President E. D. Mondainé talked about the new ordinance in the context of Portland's broader racial history. He mentioned Vanport, the largely Black community that was created by discriminatory real estate practices and wiped away in a 1948 flood under suspicious circumstances, and suggested that the URM ordinance was a continuation of racist policies.
And naturally, at the end of the article, there's a quote from somebody who thinks building owners who can't afford upgrades should get financial handouts from the city. Really? What about renters? Bus drivers? Reptile daycare owners?








San Francisco has/had a very similar ordinance.
I believe the deadline has passed, so The City should no longer have any unreinforced masonry buildings (UMBs).
I think many cities adjacent to San Francisco also adopted similar ordinances. The small East Bay town in which I lived was dotted with buildings bearing plaques warning passersby that the building was unreinforced masonry.
Conan the Grammarian at January 9, 2019 6:21 AM
It's a stupid argument all the way around. The regulation is stupid, because once the initial story passes out of the news cycle, absolutely no one is ever going to pay the slightest bit of attention to those plaques. The protest against the regulation is stupid, because it can't possibly cost that much (unless the city has imposed a bunch of ridiculous requirements, or unless there's a corrupt city contractor involved).
Given that Portland is located where it is, some kind of thought to earthquake protection seems reasonable. I looked up some earthquake maps, and I see that there was a 5.4 magnitude quake there 26 years ago, and that it was within the effects radius of the 6.8 magnitude Seattle earthquake from 18 years ago. However, the plaques are going to wind up being like those cancer-warning signs that are plastered on everything that's more than six inches above ground level in California. People are warning-label saturated. More labels are not going to penetrate anyone's consciousness.
Cousin Dave at January 9, 2019 6:53 AM
Mondainé mentioned the black community wiped out in a flood. Wouldn't it have been better if signs were up notifying them that this was a flood danger zone?
Anyone who lives on the west coast and doesn't think worry about earthquakes is important should go back and look at video of the San Fran 1989 earthquake. My friend was about to get in his car and drive on the lower lanes of the bridge that collapsed. From the air it looked like a war zone: fires, no electricity, blocks of housing leveled.
cc at January 9, 2019 8:26 AM
"The Portland City Council contains materials known to the State of California to cause cancer."
Radwaste at January 9, 2019 11:31 AM
Brown Bricks Matter!
I R A Darth Aggie at January 9, 2019 12:44 PM
Leave a comment