The Mindfulness Bullshit
I write in "Unf*ckology: A Field Guide to Living with Guts and Confidence," about what a crap-pile the "mindfulness" research arena is.
A long read by Ronald Purser in The Guardian takes it on just right:
In 2014, Time magazine put a youthful blonde woman on its cover, blissing out above the words: "The Mindful Revolution." The accompanying feature described a signature scene from the standardised course teaching MBSR: eating a raisin very slowly. "The ability to focus for a few minutes on a single raisin isn't silly if the skills it requires are the keys to surviving and succeeding in the 21st century," the author explained.But anything that offers success in our unjust society without trying to change it is not revolutionary - it just helps people cope. In fact, it could also be making things worse. Instead of encouraging radical action, mindfulness says the causes of suffering are disproportionately inside us, not in the political and economic frameworks that shape how we live. And yet mindfulness zealots believe that paying closer attention to the present moment without passing judgment has the revolutionary power to transform the whole world. It's magical thinking on steroids.
There are certainly worthy dimensions to mindfulness practice. Tuning out mental rumination does help reduce stress, as well as chronic anxiety and many other maladies. Becoming more aware of automatic reactions can make people calmer and potentially kinder. Most of the promoters of mindfulness are nice, and having personally met many of them, including the leaders of the movement, I have no doubt that their hearts are in the right place. But that isn't the issue here. The problem is the product they're selling, and how it's been packaged. Mindfulness is nothing more than basic concentration training. Although derived from Buddhism, it's been stripped of the teachings on ethics that accompanied it, as well as the liberating aim of dissolving attachment to a false sense of self while enacting compassion for all other beings.
What remains is a tool of self-discipline, disguised as self-help. Instead of setting practitioners free, it helps them adjust to the very conditions that caused their problems.
In the bit about not passing judgment, I'm reminded of my late friend Cathy Seipp. When told, "Hey, that's a value judgment," she would say something along the lines of: "I have values, so I make judgments."
City Attorney Mike Feuer, bizarrely, is killing the program -- a grant-funded, mostly volunteer-staffed program that prevents homelessness (via the landlord-tenant mediations we do) and stops people from calling out the police constantly on their neighbor.
It's a different kind of mindfulness that was required to do this -- to revolt, to try to preserve the program, to tweet constantly and write op-eds and go on KABC (Dr. Drew) and KFI (Brian Suits).
That's being mindful that there's wrong being done and then saying, "What can I do to change it?"
I bet Feuer and his team had no idea we volunteer mediators would do anything but roll over and accept the death of the program.
Um, nope-ies!








In the bit about not passing judgment, I'm reminded of my late friend Cathy Seipp. When told, "Hey, that's a value judgment," she would say something along the lines of: "I have values, so I make judgments."
I'll have to remember that. Judgments have gotten a bad rap in our declining age.
A man shows the lack of judgment to go on a drinking skylark to North Fucking Korea, and I express the opinion "That'll learn ya" and I'm somehow "judgy"? I think not.
Once someone in conversation referred to a certain first lady's previous job as "modeling," when we all know it consisted of being photographed rubbing her shaved beaver against another woman's puss for the purpose of making men masturbate.
It's a living, sure, but "modeling" isn't the word.
I suggested, gently, that modeling traditionally involves clothing, and I was subsequently accused of "slut shaming."
"I'm glad you agree she's a slut," I said, "and it's a damn shame."
Kevin at June 25, 2019 11:10 PM
Should we presume the mediation team is being disbanded because it interferes with the generation o f legal fees?
Crid at June 26, 2019 6:42 AM
I'm reminded of the great research showing how eating from a bowl held in one had upright with chopsticks greatly increased the mindfulness of the eater. Of course it does. You are worried about dropping your food on the floor.
Far too much of soft science research falls into one of two categories. Either it is blindingly obvious or it is wrong. I understand replication studies cost money. But until the soft sciences are willing to pony up that money their work is worthless.
Ben at June 26, 2019 6:50 AM
Quoted article:
Sounds great to me - from Boomers on, Americans are sorely lacking in any type of discipline.
Ben David at June 26, 2019 7:25 AM
If I wanted to be religious in any way, I'd get library books on the subject. For free, obviously.
Beware of anything that costs money; chances are it's a scam. Yes, that goes for the majority of other things as well. Example: Not all home repairs need experts to fix them, so even though they're not necessarily scamming you, it's worth trying to work out the problem yourself first. With the help of books.
Also, I seldom go to movies or theaters these days, since it's pricey and I typically forget what I've seen in just a few days. (And, when I recently went to see Offenbach's opéra bouffe "La Belle Helene," since I hadn't seen it since I was little, I couldn't make out more than half the words - as often happens in opera.)
Why spend money on short-term luxuries when you can have long-term luxuries instead? Even then, you have to be cautious, because it's too easy to take something permanent for granted after a while - such as antique furniture - and then it doesn't feel like a luxury any more.
Money is power, so don't fritter away your power. After a while, one loses one's taste for short-term things like Starbucks coffee, just as a new vegetarian loses the hunger for meat.
lenona at June 26, 2019 8:07 AM
I think the mindfulness people have a point. There is something very zen like and calming about focusing on only one thing at a time. Anything with controlled breathing, and no distractions is good for most people.
Not just an American problem, but modern life is geared to turn all of us a bit ADD. Not sure about focusing on chewing a raisin but I do know, if I am not hungry enough to focus entirely on my food, with maybe a bit of light conversation, with family and friends, I have no business eating, because I’m not hungry enough.
The person who is doing two things at once, (like driving and eating). is rarely doing either of them well.
Isab at June 26, 2019 8:49 AM
“But anything that offers success in our unjust society without trying to change it is not revolutionary - it just helps people cope. “
What precisely is wrong with coping? Especially with things that can’t realistically be changed?
Please name one “just” society.
This article seems to think that mindfulness is somehow undermining the social justice revolution. Something needs to undermine it, because a lot of the social justice warriors are not only naive, they are just plain Bat shit crazy.
Isab at June 26, 2019 1:07 PM
Grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference.
I R A Darth Aggie at June 26, 2019 3:06 PM
Oh, by all means take radical action, destroy the system, all without any plan whatsoever. What could go wrong? And if your political plan is so flimsy that some people concentrating on eating a raisin are sufficient to undermine it...well.
cc at June 27, 2019 1:14 PM
There's an appropriate time for everything. Meditation isn't supposed to be done in lieu of doing anything to improve the world. It's to support and develop your ability to be effective in other activities.
When I was doing death penalty cases and practicing at SF Zen Center, I felt that my law practice was supported and informed by my religious practice and vice versa. I had little patience (ha) for the Zennies who focused exclusively on working on themselves and planned to tackle the rest of the world when they were, I don't know, fully enlightened or something. (Thanks, we'll be looking for you at the soap kitchen in 2056.)
Training in mindfulness in the quiet of your room can make you more mindful and resilient in your work. So ... why not do both? Why make it either/or?
szoszolo at June 27, 2019 3:08 PM
But just for a few moments, that dried grape is their entire raisin d'etre.
I'll just let myself out.
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at June 27, 2019 11:56 PM
Leave a comment