Government: A Thing We Do Together To Make Everything Slower, Stupider, And Ineffective
Being over 50, I can get a "jab" soon, to borrow from across the pond. I plan to grab an appointment that opens up at a drugstore I can walk to. I already tried their sign-up thingie online: super fast and easy.
Gregg, who got his months before, had to get it at Dodger Stadium, way far away from where he lives.
Meanwhile, via Politico's Erin Banco:
The Biden administration is rethinking a costly system of government-run mass vaccination sites after data revealed the program is lagging well behind a much cheaper federal effort to distribute doses via retail pharmacies.The government has shipped millions of doses to the 21 mass vaccination hubs, or "pilot" community centers, in states such as California, Florida, New York, Illinois, Massachusetts and Texas. The hubs are part of a $4 billion federal system that funds more than 1,000 smaller vaccination locations across the country and provides other vaccination support -- such as supplies -- to states across the country. The Federal Emergency Management Agency did not respond to repeated questions about how much the pilot sites cost.
...Despite the money the federal government has spent on the mass-vaccination pilot sites, they are administering just a fraction of the shots given across the country each day. Federal data show the retail pharmacy program -- which has signed up 21 chains and 17,000 stores -- can reach far more Americans in a shorter time, according to four senior officials with direct knowledge of the matter. The bottom line, those sources said, is that more Americans seem to be willing to walk to their local pharmacist to get the vaccine than to travel to a federal vaccination site for the shot.
That represents a shift in strategy for the Biden administration, which touted the hubs as a powerful tool to rapidly accelerate the nation's vaccine rollout and a symbol of the president's push to give the federal government a larger role in the pandemic response. But FEMA data obtained by POLITICO make clear that the pharmacy sites are far outpacing the stadiums, arenas and convention centers enlisted as mass vaccination sites.
..."We see enormous potential with the retail pharmacy program," one senior Biden health official said. "More and more pharmacies sign up to distribute each day."
Others argue FEMA's pilot sites are filling a major gap in the vaccine rollout because they are situated in areas populated by traditionally underserved populations. And if they were to shut down, the federal government would lose a crucial platform for fulfilling its promise to ensure the Covid-19 is distributed equitably.
Um, woke-ese question that forgets to ask: "How many poor people live near or have transportation to stadiums, convention centers, and the like?"
Big government fantasists -- those who believe government is the cure for everything -- must be people who either have very little experience with government or are getting a government salary.
She gets it:
I never understood this from the beginning. Pharmacies run mass flu shot campaigns annually- this is their area of expertise- why wouldn't you simply have them run with the program from the beginning
— CanLen 🕙 (@CandiceLen) March 30, 2021








Wasn't the original Trump Administration plan to push distribution through local pharmacies? And wasn't that plan panned by progressives because it didn't adequately reach "underserved" populations who didn't have a Rite-Aid or CVS near them? The mean, racist Trumpistas were ignoring minorities and leaving them to die.
Probably lots. After all, most of the mass transit systems in cities across the US seem to be geared to get people to the big-money venues, like sports stadia, convention centers, and the like; less so to places like universities, museums, and libraries.
Conan the Grammarian at April 5, 2021 5:17 AM
Probably lots. After all, most of the mass transit systems in cities across the US seem to be geared to get people to the big-money venues, like sports stadia, convention centers, and the like; less so to places like universities, museums, and libraries.
Conan the Grammarian at April 5, 2021 5:17 AM
Most elderly people ( those most in need of the vaccine) have a pre existing relationship with some sort of pharmacy.
I suspect very few of the target population are going to want to spend hours on public transportation followed by more hours of paperwork, and waiting in line twice to get the two shots they need.
I went to my local Air Force base and the process was pretty daunting.
It was a lousy set up for anyone elderly or with mobility issues.
Isab at April 5, 2021 7:23 AM
I suspect you're right. And I suspect that it being troublesome to get to a "central" facility would discourage many who need it from getting the shots. As you put it, most elderly will have an existing relationship with a pharmacy.
My 90-something uncle got his shot early. I took him to the medical office of a local healthcare provider -- they'd set one up in a recently-closed facility of theirs -- and he was in and out in less than 20 minutes. Despite the speed of access once at the facility. it was in an inconvenient location for the non-driving elderly who did not have a ride provider. So, I can only imagine the inconvenience in store for those trying to get a shot in a "central" facility.
I talked to a CSR on the phone when making his appointment and the guy all but admitted that using this facility was for the convenience of the provider, not the patient. It was empty and they were still paying rent on it, so why not use it for the shots?
Using a "central" facility is for the convenience of the provider, not the patient. Providers, government or private, only have to deliver the vaccine to one location, not coordinate inventory over dozens of locations.
On the other hand, coordinating inventory over dozens of locations is what retail companies do every day. They're set up for it. Why not let them do what they do best, deliver things to customers.
Conan the Grammarian at April 5, 2021 8:12 AM
Another option to consider for all this is that the more the unnecessary bureaucratic hoops, the bigger the chances of graft slipping through the cracks.
Sixclaws at April 5, 2021 8:32 AM
The convention center by me has been used on weekends. It does not have mass transit on weekends. Nearest is roughly a 1mile walk. On week days there is occasional bus service right out on the street focused on the rush hour times. We don't have any big name teams so there aren't any big places to hold these things.
The former Banker at April 5, 2021 9:36 PM
Then again, most of those venues are deliberately located in poor areas. It's the result of "Not In My Backyard" syndrome. Kind of like routing interstate highways through poor neighborhoods.
I agree that pharmacies are a very useful component of the vaccination program. It's familiar and convenient for most people. However, they have so few appointments that you have to spend hours, over days, to finally get an appointment. My sister-in-law spent most of several days last week trying to get an appointment for her son (he's disabled).
On the other hand, venues large enough to handle large numbers of people every day are also useful. My daughter at college doesn't have a car and the pharmacies in walking distance (about a mile away) only had a handful of appointments available each day. It's a small school without a student health center. When a mass vaccination clinic opened up about 5 miles away, I asked the school if they would consider offering shuttle transportation. It turns out they were already making arrangements for their students to get vaccinated en masse at the site as well as shuttle buses to get them there.
Mass vaccination sites are just starting. Like any new program, including vaccinations at pharmacies, there are logistics that need to be worked out as unexpected problems arise. Give them some time. They have their own useful place in the overall vaccination program.
Jennifer at April 6, 2021 8:28 AM
I was also wondering about not using local pharmacies for vaccines, but apparently not many local pharmacies had the freezers needed for the first batch of vaccines and the government wasn't subsidizing buying (or renting?) them. Since I went on medicare, my doctor stopped giving me my flu shot - I went to CVS. But flu shots don't have to be super refrigerated. I do hope this will change as we learn more and innovate more, since it looks like booster shots for Covid may be needed eventually.
mmmwright at April 7, 2021 10:58 AM
Leave a comment