Sanity Is A Perilous Condition These Days
Tom Slater writes at Spiked of the case of Kathleen Stock, one of the latest smeared by trans activists -- but with a heartening response by the university where she's a professor:
Cowardice is the fuel of cancel culture. When someone is sacked or punished for offending a handful of intolerant saddos, this has nothing to do with the power or number or strength of argument among said saddos, and everything to do with the cowardice of institutions or employers, who invariably roll over after the slightest bit of trouble.Which is why it is so heartening - not to mention unusual - to see the University of Sussex stand up for one of its professors, Kathleen Stock, in the face of a long-running campaign of intimidation and demonisation aimed at smearing her as transphobic. After a renewed call from campus activists this week to have Stock sacked, Sussex said no, and more should follow its example.
Stock is a philosopher and a gender-critical feminist. She's never said anything transphobic; she believes that trans people should be free to live their lives in dignity. She just also believes that allowing male-bodied people into women's spaces, purely because they self-identify as women, is dangerous, and that we should be careful about giving confused kids life- and body-altering treatment.
For daring to voice these unspeakable heresies she has been subjected to a witch-hunt. In January, when Stock was awarded an OBE, 600 academics signed a letter denouncing her 'harmful rhetoric'. This week a student group called 'Anti Terf Sussex' put up posters on campus demanding she be sacked, branding Stock 'one of this wretched island's most prominent transphobes'.
This week, Stock laid down the gauntlet, calling on her colleagues to speak up about what was happening or surrender Sussex to mob rule. 'What kind of future does a university have where intimidation determines what is said or taught?', she asked. The university clearly heard her, and issued a statement yesterday saying it 'will not tolerate threats to cherished academic freedoms'.
Other higher-education leaders should learn from this. After all, gender-critical feminists across the country have been subject to the most appalling treatment. Oxford history professor Selina Todd was given a security detail last year to accompany her to lectures. After a debate on gender self-ID, Reading law professor Rosa Freedman found her office door covered in urine.
The mix of censoriousness and misogyny is breathtaking. And yet so far, too many academics and university leaders have either stared at their shoelaces or joined in. One of Stock's colleagues this week actually said he saluted the protesters.
The more universities and individuals stand up against cancel culture, the better the chances of turning it back.
Not everyone has the capital -- social, emotional, or professional -- to be able to stand up. But I hope those who can will stand up doubly to take the place of those who can't.








The problem is the mainstream left-leaning papers aren't covering this. I read the Washington Post... just did a search for her, nothing. Boston Globe, nada.
I think if most people knew about it, even your average Democrat, they'd be shocked when these things happen, but they don't hear about it.
You only hear about these things from right-wing or libertarian sources, or radical feminist ones.
NicoleK at October 11, 2021 9:52 PM
Most of the time it isn't cowardice, it is a pretext for something else.
At universities it isn't unusual for administers to groom student protesters to complain about something the administer wants to change. When their manufactured issue comes up the administer claims they have to give in. It is a way to shift the blame for generally unpopular changes onto a third party.
Ben at October 12, 2021 5:11 AM
I don't blame anyone for being afraid to challenge the Marxists who push this nonsense, when they have the power to get you fired or even physically attacked. But more of us need to fight back, because their goal is nothing less than to repeat the Chinese Cultural Revolution here.
jdgalt1 at October 12, 2021 8:02 AM
Everything I've read about this story suggests that the university is "standing up" for Stock, in the form of ONE high official of the university, who spoke out in favor of free speech. However, this professor still remains a target for everyone else on that campus -- students, other professors, and probably the rest of the administration. IOW, it's only a tiny bit "heartening."
Gene at October 12, 2021 9:40 AM
Leave a comment