Advice Goddess Blog
« Previous | Home | Next »

"Amy Is Annoyed" Week Continues
Here's the piece I wrote for my friend Hillary Johnson, who edits the Ventura County Reporter, on irritating people shouting into their cell phones in public:

The North American Peace And Quiet Initiative: Amy Alkon takes on loud bores on cell phones

Thanks, but I'll pass on breaking stories of your raging yeast infection, your cat's irritable bowel syndrome, and live updates on your current location: "I'm walking down Third Street. I'm still walking down Third Street. Yep, still on Third Street."

Everywhere I go, someone on a cell phone is shouting something breathtakingly dull or unpleasant or both. I used to frequent this serene cafe, where you'd just barely hear the murmur of conversation under the classical music. I still go there, only it's no longer serene, because I'm usually sandwiched between two people having dueling high-decibel cell phone conversations. It's for them I'm having this card printed:

IF YOU CAN READ THIS CARD YOU ARE TOO LOUD
Just because you have a self doesn't mean you should express it. Apparently, you are under the impression that the world will be a better place once you broadcast the news that you've changed laxatives or forgotten to floss. Perhaps you call this "freedom of speech." I call it "bad breeding." Kindly save your loud, dull conversations for the privacy of your home. Thank you! --AmyAlkon@aol.com

A few restaurants and coffee bars responded to the cellular din by putting up "no cell phones" signs. Can't people mind their manners without printed instruction? Most people in public places do manage "no nose-picking," "no toenail clipping," and "please don't urinate on the foyer rug." With cellular rudeness, it has to be intentional disregard. I mean, come on: Unless they've got one hand on their Leader Dog and the other on their cell, they can see all those other people around -- people who would surely prefer to have their thoughts go unpierced by the shrill and uninteresting.

I do make exceptions for emergencies. Gotta tell the babysitter that Johnny isn't allowed to smoke crack before dinner, or warn the fire department that something's burning? Well, I'm a big girl -- I'll deal. In all other cases, here are my personal guidelines for cell phoning etiquette:

1. Calls are fine as long as one is talking at a decibel level just this side of a whisper.
2. Otherwise, one shouldn't use a cell phone anywhere one wouldn't feel perfectly comfortable passing a big cloud of gas.

One day, I was in a coffee bar where just about every table was occupied by somebody reading, writing, or talking quietly. A woman -- she looked like a young grandmother -- burst into the place with a swarm of (you guessed it -- loud) children. They all ended up at a small table across the coffee bar from me. I was wearing headphones with Aimee Mann up full blast as I wrote -- no impediment whatsoever to my hearing every word Granny shouted into her phone. She made five calls -- each the same as the last -- giving detailed directions to a birthday party at her house, as well as the time, and her home phone number. At the call number four mark, customers started spilling out of the place, glaring at her as they left. I was too far behind in my writing to leave or even to get up and say something to her (as I often do, as a small-time vigilante), but I scribbled her number down and called her when I got home:

"Carol, Carol, Carol...the microphone on a cell phone is actually quite sensitive. There's no need to yell. You look like a nice woman. You probably didn't realize that your repeated shouting into your cell phone drove a number of people out of the coffee bar today. Beyond that, you might consider that I'm just one of about 20 people who know that you live at "555 Ferngrove" Street, a half-block off Sunset, three houses from the end on the right side, and that you're having a bunch of six-year-olds over at 3 p.m. on Saturday. Now, I'm just a newspaper columnist, not a pedophile, but it's kind of an unnecessary security risk you're taking, huh? Just a little something to think about the next time you're shouting on your cell phone in a coffee bar. Bye!"

It's time for more people to speak up to those who force their dull lives on the rest of us. But how? Do you get right in the cellular narcissist's face and shout disparaging remarks into your own cell phone about those who lack consideration for others' right to peace, quiet, and ignorance of the icky medical issues of strangers? That seems rather hypocritical. Plus, there's that wise notion that a whisper makes a much bigger impact on an audience than a shout -- which leads me to a socially unacceptable but extremely tempting solution: Back up really close to the offender and set a strong but silent example -- the kind eighth graders refer to as "silent but deadly." Although your "You have some nerve!" gas probably won't physically incapacitate them, showing these screaming bores the stinking error of their ways should at least make them tremble a little before dialing in the future.

For anyone who isn't the flatulent sort -- you have my permission to print up my anti-cell phone card, complete with my email address, and dispense it to any high-volume banal person on a cell phone way too near you.

(c)2003, Amy Alkon, all rights reserved. Reprint rights available. Contact adviceamy@aol.com

Posted by aalkon at August 5, 2004 8:58 AM

Comments

My personal favorites are the ones who are in the grocery store and have to call home at every department, give their family the low-down on what's available and decide on what's for dinner. How on earth did these people grocery shop before the advent of cell phones? Amazing.

I hope these play by players don't stop in the restroom on the way.

"Okay, now I'm dropping my pants. Okay, now I'm sitting on the toilet. Ugh... Okay, I'm about to drop one. Hear it?"

Posted by: Patrick at August 5, 2004 11:21 AM

What about the obnoxious bizarros who commit their telephonic exhibitionist acts while wearing those nearly invisible headsets? They should have your cards tossed at them and be reprimanded for slandering schizophrenics as well!

Posted by: Doug at August 5, 2004 7:56 PM

I hate the headsets too, especially when homos wear them. Someone is trying way too hard to be in Madonna's Blonde Ambition tour.

Posted by: Lena at August 5, 2004 9:49 PM

Lena: hee hee.

Amy: I loved your creative way of dealing to "Carol." Well done. I'm sorry, however, that you're regularly exposed to such trying behaviour.

Posted by: M at August 5, 2004 10:25 PM

Amy-- Slightly off-topic, but which Aimee Mann album were you listening to? I just had the "Magnolia" soundtrack on this morning.

Posted by: Chris at August 6, 2004 6:29 AM

Actualy, because I'm on a Mac, I was listening to a whole bunch of her stuff, thanks to iTunes' "shuffle" and playlists features.

Posted by: Amy Alkon at August 6, 2004 6:42 AM

Come to my shul for morning prayers. Every five seconds a cell phone is beeping and men who are supposed to be speaking to God are going on like a bunch of yentas from the old country: "Yes, yes, Ruchie, I won't forget to pick up the brisket." "I don't have time to get the car washed, you do it." "He said that about me at the board meeting? I'll crush the little pisher."
And I'm not even taking into account the doctors and their emergencies. Which, at least, are sort of exciting.

Posted by: Robert at August 6, 2004 9:26 AM

I may betray my goy-ish ignorance here, but isn't there someone in charge of the morning prayers who can tell everyone to shut the phones off?

Posted by: Sister Lena of the Most Holy Assumption at August 6, 2004 1:08 PM