Who'll Stop The Reign
Out of nowhere, a male friend started criticizing me, telling me that I need to change careers to make more money. He does have a successful business (started with seed money from his extremely wealthy family). But I didn't ask for his advice, and besides, I love my job, and I'm working on what I need to do to move forward. So I ended up snapping at him. He got mad and insisted that he just wants the best for me.
--Steamed
Criticizing someone does not make them want to change; it makes them want to google for listicles like "10 Foolproof Tricks For Getting Away with Murder."
To understand your friend's spontaneous outburst of unsolicited advice, consider that human communication is strategic -- just like that of our earth-dwelling colleagues, from apes to insects. Honeybees, for example, do a little dance to tell their fellow bees where the nectar is; they don't just go all twerky for no reason.
Back here in Humanland, evolutionary scientists Vladas Griskevicius and Douglas Kenrick find that seven "deep-seated evolutionary motives" -- emerging from survival and mating challenges our ancestors faced -- "continue to influence much modern behavior." These evolved motivations still driving us today are 1) evading physical harm, 2) avoiding disease, 3) making friends, 4) acquiring a mate, 5) keeping that mate, 6) caring for family, and -- ding-ding-ding! -- 7) attaining status.
Yes, status. There's a good chance that a dispenser of unsolicited advice has the best of intentions -- like "I just want to help you...uh...help you (and others who hear about my help) think more highly of me!" (He then becomes the expert, the career seer, the swami of success.) But whatever this guy's motive, you have no obligation to donate your attention to his cause.
The best time to set boundaries is before they're needed. Or needed again. Gently inform your friend that you truly appreciate his desire to help but the only advice that works for you is the solicited kind. Should he wish to, uh, solicit your solicitation, he can ask: "Would you be open to hearing...?" If you accept, it might help you keep an open mind if you focus on what you two have in common -- for example, a relative who proclaimed, "When I die, all of this will be yours!" Unfortunately, your grandma was making a sweeping gesture toward her salt and pepper shaker collection.
For pages and pages of "science-help" from me, buy my latest book, "Unf*ckology: A Field Guide to Living with Guts and Confidence." It lays out the PROCESS of transforming to live w/confidence.








I usually respond to unsolicited advice is a melodramatic “Thank you for your wise counsel!” To friends, relatives, and ‘splainers of all kinds.
But one follow-up question: Is LW complaining about her job/income to this friend regularly? Because complaining about the same thing repeatedly opens you up to unsolicited advice.
sofar at May 1, 2019 8:19 AM
Criticizing someone does not make them want to change; it makes them want to google for listicles like "10 Foolproof Tricks For Getting Away with Murder."
If only my wife understood this!
Rex Little at May 1, 2019 8:24 PM
In my experience, friends generally avoid criticizing each other and if they do, do so politely. So if a friend feels it's necessary to criticize my behavior, I try to listen.
The exception being people who criticize reflexively, which tends to be a sign of neuroticism.
But I'd be interested to know what the LW's friend said to her. Was it communicated aggressively, or simply an expression of concern? Because I've observed that a lot of people today are hypersensitive to perceived criticism, or anything less that enthusiastic praise and approval. It could be that she's sensitive about her career situation and overreacting.
stephanie at May 4, 2019 3:15 PM
I'm with sofar on this. My guess it was not out of no where, but was after the LW often complaining about money or asking for a loan.
Joe J at May 6, 2019 7:22 PM
Leave a comment