Apt. 201B Or Not To Be
My boyfriend and I have been together for two years, and my lease is up in a few months. I was thinking about asking him if he wants to live together. When is the right time to move in with someone, and how do you know whether that's even a good idea?
--Housing Crisis
There are people you can share a home with who do not do a slew of annoying things, and they're those who are continuing their tenure on our planet in an urn.
As a failed romantic (aka human-nature realist), I think there's a right time to move in with another person, such as my boyfriend of 18 years, and it's never. That said, in my financial dream world, I'd be into our buying houses next door to each other. Of course, this sort of thing is less practical for a couple with kids because a substantial part of parenting involves finding your children so annoying in the moment that you take steps to civilize them. And let's be honest, all children are irritating (loud, sticky, and often unbelievably tedious), save for those frozen in mute adorableness in photographs, my favorite kind.
There's often financial pressure to live together, especially in urban elitevilles where a grim little closet pretending to be an apartment rents for the price of a gleaming penthouse in any city in the Midwest. Unfortunately, though sharing an apartment saves big on rent, it can cost a couple their relationship if they end up going at each other like rats in an undersized cage.
As for what makes a relationship work, cohabitational or otherwise, there's this notion that couples who have happy, lasting partnerships love each other more than those who break up. Sorry, romantics! Sure, when a relationship is brand-new, affection and lust make for a big heart-shaped airbag against annoyance and resentment. However, in "The Power of Bad," science journalist John Tierney and social psychologist Roy Baumeister explain that, over time, the sweet, tender things each partner says and does matter far less than how a couple deals with "the negative stuff -- their doubts, their frustrations, their problems."
Their book centers on what researchers call the "negativity bias": how we pay far more attention to negative information, emotions, and experiences than positive and give the negative stuff far more weight. The negativity bias is especially toxic in heterosexual relationships, due to some general sex differences in personality and emotional orientation, summed up by researchers as "female demand/male withdrawal."
"Female demand" is driven by how women tend to be higher in the personality trait of "neuroticism," which involves a tendency to react with negative emotions. People high in neuroticism see the world through mud-covered glasses: They're anxious, moody, easily irritated, and perceive intentional slights in incidents others shrug off as the small frustrations of life. Basically, high neuroticism is the personality trait of picky complainers: "You loaded the dishwasher all wrong!" "You're feeding the baby all wrong!" And then the inevitable, "You're climbing out the window and running down the street screaming all wrong!"
Regarding "male withdrawal" (lest you dudes start feeling all smugly superior), men tend to respond to relationship conflicts by going emotionally comatose, experiencing an emotional systems overload that clinical psychologist Robert Levenson and other researchers call "flooding." In short, men are more likely to get overwhelmed by emotion and simply shut down. Not surprisingly, same-sex couples are less predisposed to plunge into a negativity spiral. Tierney and Baumeister explain, "If it's two men, they're less likely to initiate a complaint; if it's two women, they're less likely to withdraw after being criticized."
That said, simply being human -- in a job, a friendship, or a relationship -- makes us prone to go negative. That's important to understand in light of research by psychologist John Gottman surveying couples who'd just gotten married and looking at which couples were divorced six years later. What mattered were not the positive, loving sentiments couples expressed but how they responded to conflict. Citing this research, Tierney and Baumeister explain: "Being able to hold your tongue rather than say something nasty or spiteful will do much more for your relationship than a good word or deed." (Love is not blind, but love can choose to throw on a blindfold.)
When I got together with my boyfriend, I made a pact with myself to never speak to him like I've forgotten I love him. This has helped me avoid going ugly over the years, but I have to give living apart a good bit of the credit. Psychologist Erich Fromm wrote, "Mature love says: 'I need you because I love you.'" Cohabiting love says: "I need you to take out the trash because I'll get 20-to-life for electrocuting you in the bathtub."
For pages and pages of "science-help" from me, buy my latest book, "Unf*ckology: A Field Guide to Living with Guts and Confidence." It lays out the PROCESS of transforming to live w/confidence.








One of the things you have to watch for, is developing bad diet habits. I do really well with not eating stuff I shouldn’t when I am on my own.
My husband spent several years working abroad, and I did really well cooking and shopping for myself when I was here alone. Then he retired, and this covid thing hit. Kind of a double whammy. I am struggling not to eat or fix a meal just because I am trying to take care of him.
Really easy to sabotage myself.
My daughter fights the same thing.
Isab at January 5, 2021 3:14 PM
Hmmm... Insightful response from Amy. Gonna have to think about it for a while.
doobiedoo at January 6, 2021 5:15 AM
Did read some time back that matching OCD tendencies is useful.
"good enough" should be about the same in each party.
Hospital corners are important to an individual or they are not. But if you are the one who doesn't care, the rational view of why they are important is hard to figure.
Personally, I figure if there's no big shot with captain's bars inspecting the barracks, hospital corners don't interest me. YMMV.
The above is a metaphor.
Richard Aubrey at January 6, 2021 1:49 PM
"Cohabiting love says: "I need you to take out the trash because I'll get 20-to-life for electrocuting you in the bathtub.""
This is 100% true lol. My husband has calendar reminders on his phone about taking out the trash.
LW, you probably won't know if it's a "good time" to move in together, unless you do it. Even if you make plans about chores and speak open and honestly about the level of "clean" you need to not go insane, there's no guarantee it'll work out.
So my 2 cents is that you save a nice pile of "eff off" money, in case it doesn't work out. Enough to break the lease or (depending on the circumstances) pay your half of the rent for a month AND for a new place for yourself so he can find a new roommate or move out. Or maybe that money ends up being for YOU, if he wants out and screws you over.
Oh, and I'd highly recommend NOT getting a pet together or buying expensive furniture together for the first year at LEAST.
I've seen too many of my friends become homeless (we've got one crashing with us right now) because they moved in with a romantic partner, enjoyed the "sharing the rent" thing, didn't save for the worst-case scenario, and then things went sour. And, as an animal shelter volunteer, I've seen too many dogs and cats end up homeless because their owners' cohabitation fell apart. Do everything you can to NOT be that person.
sofar at January 7, 2021 8:43 AM
At the risk of sounding unromantic, I think practicality offers a good opening to bring things up.
Your lease is up? Now's a good time to consider moving together. Might as well bring it up. If you want to play coy, you can hint and see if he says something, "My lease is up, and I'm trying to figure out where I want to go". See what he says.
Practicality drove me and my husband to get married in'07... his job was done and he was moving, our options were long distance, or move together, and I wasn't moving to a new state with no job, family or friends without being married. So we got married. And we're very happy!
A lot of relationship stuff IS the practical crap... who's gonna do what, where should we live, what should we do.
NicoleK at January 7, 2021 9:02 AM
Wait, though... something to think about... are you effectively living together anyways? Because my husband was pretty much always at my place anyways. he rarely slept at his. I mean sometimes we went there... but he was almost always at my place anyhow. Unofficially.
NicoleK at January 7, 2021 9:03 AM
Ehhh dangerous water here.
Many women will ask this with wedding rings in mind. Most men will interpret it as such.
A few things to ask yourself:
1. How often do you "live together" anyway?
2. Is it a move in to his place, or is it get a new place together?
3. Covid. Adds an extra complexity, since people are indoors much more often, it will compound the problems a lot.
4. How will you handle a no? How will you handle a yes that should have been a no?
Joe J at January 10, 2021 4:08 PM
Leave a comment