Everything Is Racist
Claudia Schiffer appeared in a number of poses for a fashion spread by Karl Lagerfeld, a secretary, Marie Antoinette, and a disco era black woman with a huge fro. Naturally, as Simon Cable writes in the Daily Mail, somebody popped up to find it racist:
But Shevelle Rhule, fashion editor at black lifestyle magazine Pride, said the images of Miss Schiffer were tasteless.She said: 'It shows poor taste and it's offensive.
'There are not enough women of colour featured in mainstream magazines. This just suggests you can counteract the problem by using white models.
'I don't believe they deliberately set out to offend, they obviously see it as being arty and feel that they are pushing boundaries.
'But clearly no thought has been given to the history behind what they have done and the comparisons it draws with minstrel shows.'
Of course, the assignment here seems to have been "dress up Claudia Schiffer," not model 80s fashion. Would it be "racist" to dress up Naomi Campbell as an Asian woman?
People don't have a responsibility to hire black models any more than they have a responsibility to hire redheaded ones.
On the spotting victimization everywhere front, I had a little back and forth with a woman on Twitter a nasty tweet she'd made about how she couldn't believe any woman would want so and so on the right. I told her I was sick of the low-blow stuff on both sides...couldn't she just attack the guy's ideas?
There was more back and forth, and I mentioned a guy on right and a guy on the left: Thomas Sowell and Josh Micah Marshall.
Weirdly, she accused me of being racist for bringing in "other black people." I didn't quite get that. "Other black people"? Well, Thomas Sowell is black, but I think of him as a thinker, not a black guy. And Josh Micah Marshall, of Talking Points Memo, is about as white as I am.
Then it occurred to me -- I went back and clicked on her Twitter name. Yes! She was black. Well, I'm 46, and I have a hard time seeing those tiny twitter pictures. I told her I didn't know she was black...can't see that small -- just thought she had a pretty smile. But, she immediately went to being victimized, at my mere mention of a thinker who happens to be black.
Enough of this already.







Yes, Count me as another person who is sick of people playing the race card.
David M. at June 4, 2010 7:19 AM
The word "racist" has lost it's meaning due to overuse, in much the same way antibiotics lose their punch when prescribed for every little sniffle. It used to sting when I was accused of racism, but now I simply brush the label off and go on about my business. It's meaningless.
roadgeek at June 4, 2010 7:30 AM
When your only tool is a hammer, everything problem looks like a nail...
When your only defense is to cry racism, every problem looks like racism...
Dwatney at June 4, 2010 7:55 AM
She said "tasteless", not "racist".
Karen at June 4, 2010 8:17 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2010/06/everything-is-r.html#comment-1720947">comment from KarenShe finds it "offensive." Hmmm, I wonder why!
Amy Alkon
at June 4, 2010 8:40 AM
I'm sorry, but what exactly is the "history" of the afro?
lujlp at June 4, 2010 8:56 AM
It's not like Claudia Schiffer was in black-face. Naomi Campell and Opra straighten their hair. Isn't that also racist (or tasteless and offensive) by this definition?
Seriously Amy, you don't look a day over 30.
AllenS at June 4, 2010 9:32 AM
Thanks -- I used to be able to read a matchbook cover across the street. I really miss that.
PS For a cheap remedy, I use eyeglassdirect.com to fill my prescription ($35, I think, plus $4.95 shipping). They have frames, but I sent frames for them to fill -- $14.99 Borghese reading glasses from CVS. I get compliments on them all the time. Oh yeah, and I can see. Especially important while driving.
Amy Alkon at June 4, 2010 10:25 AM
It took me one minute with Google to find this now classic example of the pseudo-intellectual accusation that everyone is prejudiced, but only Whites are Racist. That is the definition!
This is asymmetric, intellectual warfare. The people who want to be good are falling for propaganda designed to control them. Socialists offer to increase the power of the state over them as an expiation of their sins. This only works because they are already good people, with the usual amount of anxiety about the world.
Sorry about the length. This standard argument deserves to be seen in detail to be opposed and laughed at.
By Caleb Rosado, Department of Urban Studies, Eastern University, Philadelphia, PA [edited, emphasis added]
The Undergirding Factor is POWER, Toward an Understanding of Prejudice and Racism
Summary: When a Black man fears a White man for being white, that is prejudice. When a White man fears a Black man for being black, that is Racism (requiring the intervention of the government). This is the accepted Liberal view, enforced by the government and taught at respectable universities.
Andrew_M_Garland at June 4, 2010 11:13 AM
Not being racist is racist.
lsomber at June 4, 2010 11:55 AM
So if a black person calls me a honkey or a cracker, they are not racist? Or if they say that I can't do something because I am "white"? Hypocracy at it's finest.
Sabrina at June 4, 2010 12:30 PM
Wow, I didn't realize that certain hairstyles were reserved for people of certain races. I guess I'd better go brush up on the U.S. Code before my next haircut. I wonder if it's legal for a middle-age white guy to shave his head?
Cousin Dave at June 4, 2010 12:41 PM
Andrew, thanks for that...I think... The problem, of course, is that the oh-so-oppressed minorities are in truth racists against themselves. By attributing every negative outcome, every perceived slight to racism, they effectively repress themselves.
As Jerry Pournelle puts it in his writings: Back in the 1950s he wanted to see a color-blind society, and the whites called him racist. Now, more than 50 years later, he still wants to see a color-blind society, and the blacks call him racist.
bradley13 at June 4, 2010 1:05 PM
I quoted above from this link:
The Undergirding Factor is POWER, Toward an Understanding of Prejudice and Racism
By Caleb Rosado, Department of Urban Studies, Eastern University, Philadelphia, PA
Andrew_M_Garland at June 4, 2010 1:15 PM
The saddest ironies accompany this issue. Black-administered governments are still failures, the crime rate for some categories is ten times that of other ethnic groups...
...and it's always somebody else's fault.
Radwaste at June 4, 2010 2:54 PM
I wonder if it's legal for a middle-age white guy to shave his head?
You must be a skinhead -- why would a balding guy shave his head otherwise. :-p
Jim P. at June 4, 2010 6:19 PM
I'm sorry, but what exactly is the "history" of the afro?
It was the hairstyle of the rebellious youth, just as long hair on boys was for the white kids. Prior to that, it was hours in the salon for relaxed or combed styles. I read an interesting book (whose title escapes me just now) about the origins of the elaborate braided styles ladies wear. In many African tribal communities of earlier centuries, to wear one's hair natural was a sign of a period of grief, or insanity.
This whole Schiffer kerfluffle brings to mind a picture in the Diana Vreeland book Allure. Vreeland got hold of a huge diamond from Winston in between private owners and they photographed it for the magazine. She says they got the best hand in Paris for modeling it (a Swedish girl), only it looked crass, so they painted the model's hand solid black.
I wonder what they'd make of this today.
Vreeland:
Mary Q Contrary at June 4, 2010 7:20 PM
Gah. Can't even claim under-caffeination. "The magazine" was, of course Vogue, under Vreeland's direction back then in 1970.
Mary Q Contrary at June 4, 2010 7:24 PM
I guess Ms. Rhule never saw the 2004 movie "White Chicks" with Shawn and Marlon Wayans? Or the 1986 movie "Soul Man" with C. Thomas Howell?
Willa at June 5, 2010 11:49 AM
They can both attend the next affirmative action/cultural sensitivity seminar in my place. I'm too old to care.
MarkD at June 7, 2010 8:06 AM
Leave a comment