Freemail Can Be Costly
Farhad Manjoo at Slate luvvvvs Gmail -- and then finds that when he wants to call about a problem, there's no phone number and nobody's home:
I want the standard, universally accepted way to ask for help from our corporate overlords: I want a phone number.And that's the one thing Gmail can't give me. For most people, Gmail is a free service (some businesses pay for Gmail through Google Apps accounts, and Google also lets individuals pay for extra storage--which I do). It's astonishing to think that we get so much from Gmail in return for so little. Google makes money on Gmail--from what I hear, it makes a profit--by running ads around your messages. It's a brilliant business model--until, that is, you encounter a problem, especially one that requires deep technical assistance to solve. Who are you gonna call when something gets screwed up?
The comment I left under Manjoo's piece:
I've had the same AOL email address since the early 90s, and people have been making fun of me for it for about that long. Beyond the fact that I love not having to send out change of email address notes every time Comcast or whomever gets eaten by some other company, I'm a newspaper columnist and I need to have access to my email at all times, no screwups. I pay about $10 a month, which I think of as insurance. And not only can I get somebody on the phone at all times should I have any problem, I actually have the email address and IM address of a guy at AOL that I message when anything seems to be dire (like one week when nobody seemed to have gotten my column email). And then, all the people getting their email hacked and those "I'm in London, send me money" emails are on gmail. If you're paying for your email address, somebody has to answer to you.
By the way, on my personal (non-column AOL address) I'm on AOL's Project Phoenix, which I like a lot -- save for the fact that somebody at AOL with lint for brains figured it was okay to release a program where "Beta" means users have no access to their sent mail. Genius! I try to remember to BCC myself and erase the copy that comes. Hoping they fix this soon, the nimrods.







Darken's replied to your comment; will you be rebuttaling?
Just wondering at May 29, 2011 11:47 PM
Guy seems confused about all sorts of things. He wrote:
I wrote:
Everybody loves to bash AOL. It's remained afloat for 20 years, which is more than I can say for a whole lot of cable companies. I've been with my boyfriend for eight years, and in that time, he's had to change his email address about five times, when this cable company became that cable company...Comcast, Time-Warner, ATT, etc. If you emailed me in 1995 at a certain email address, you can still find me at that email address, which is how Mark Ebner was able to instant-message me around 6 a.m. on 9/11/2001 to tell me to turn on the TV right away.
Amy Alkon at May 29, 2011 11:57 PM
I've been with my boyfriend for eight years, and in that time, he's had to change his email address about five times,
He should just by his own domain name for $10/yr and then point it at whatever provider he is currently using.
Engineer at May 30, 2011 2:20 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/05/freemail-can-be.html#comment-2192853">comment from EngineerI've been with my boyfriend for eight years, and in that time, he's had to change his email address about five times, He should just by his own domain name for $10/yr and then point it at whatever provider he is currently using.
Thanks, he has mac.com now. But, lots and lots and lots of people have had to change their email address loads of times. And gmail, if anything goes wrong, is an exceptionally bad idea.
Amy Alkon
at May 30, 2011 5:40 AM
I'm often amused at the people who complain about issues with Yahoo, Gmail, Facebook, Reddit, web hosting, forums, and the dozens of other free web services. Just like broadcast TV, it's *free*, so you have to expect some issues.
I keep telling my friends that when you start paying a subscription fee, then y'all have a right to complain. But until then, stop complaining about Facebook (or whatever).
Personally, I'm a Google fanboi, so I would be more than willing to pay $50 to $100 a year to make sure I get an answer and some immediate (or at least reasonably quick) problem resolution.
Tom Accuosti at May 30, 2011 6:14 AM
That's not even the worst:
U.S. enables Chinese hacking of Google
http://articles.cnn.com/2010-01-23/opinion/schneier.google.hacking_1_chinese-hackers-access-system-google?_s=PM:OPINION
In order to comply with government search warrants on user data, Google created a backdoor access system into Gmail accounts. This feature is what the Chinese hackers exploited to gain access.
biff at May 30, 2011 6:52 AM
I happen to like Gmail, although I don't completely trust Google. For starters, they are a bunch of fuzzy-headed liberal anti-gun bigots. However, the Gmail service is very useful, primarily as an aggregator for my 100+ email accounts that I can access anywhere I can get to a browser. It's true that there is nothing even resembling customer support, so I back up EVERYTHING in my Gmail account periodically using Thunderbird. If Gmail manages to screw up badly enough, I can redirect everything to one of my other accounts, which would take me a couple of hours.
The lack of customer support is what keeps me from using Google Voice. I pay about $20/month for VoIP service in order to get support. While losing my email aggregator would be inconvenient (I can get my email through my own domains), losing my phone service (again -- I once made the mistake of relying on Google Voice) is not something I will tolerate. $20/month is cheap insurance.
Howard at May 30, 2011 7:35 AM
To be fair, in the distant past AOL did in fact do a lot of things that deserved bashing. I won't bore everyone with the details, most of which are rather inside-baseball to Internet veterans. But the significant one was their role in trying to build an old-media concept of the Internet, where there would be a handful of content providers and everyone else would be passive consumers. Plus, AOL went through a period during the Time-Warner years where the quality of the service was poor, even though the price was high by comparison to other ISPs of the time.
There was one other bit that was not entirely AOL's fault. When the service first tied itself into the Internet in the mid-'90s, they flooded Usenet with a hoarde of Internet newbies who didn't know, or much care, about the conventions that made Usenet work (that is, to the extent that Usenet ever worked). An email address ending with "aol.com" became synonymous with "tyro". This was mostly not AOL's fault, but it nonetheless gave the service a bad rep among Internet veterans.
This was all years ago, though. AOL does seem to have found its purpose, after all of the uproar of the Time-Warner years.
I've had an account with a regional ISP for nearly 20 years now, and one of the reasons I maintain it is so that I can keep my email address. It's short and easily remembered by my friends and associates who live in my area.
Cousin Dave at May 30, 2011 7:56 AM
The funny thing is that an aol address have become kind of cool, because it's so totally anti-cool.
Also Cousin Dave is right. AOL did much to warrant their poor rep. They have a history of bad practices, both towards their customers and the broader internet. But that's caught up with them and now the company lives in purgatory.
pupup at May 30, 2011 11:15 AM
As others have said above, you get what you pay for. I'd never dream of expecting customer service for something I was getting free.
My GMail account was hacked once; someone set up the vacation reply to send out a spam message to everyone who emailed me. All I had to do was go in to the settings, remove the spam, and change my password to something less guessable. Haven't had a problem since.
Rex Little at May 30, 2011 1:04 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/05/freemail-can-be.html#comment-2193886">comment from Rex LittleAll I had to do was go in to the settings, remove the spam, and change my password to something less guessable. Haven't had a problem since.
You were lucky. These days, the hacker changes your secret code, etc., so you can't get back in, and there's nobody at Google to help you. It happened to a good friend of mine.
Amy Alkon
at May 30, 2011 2:15 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/05/freemail-can-be.html#comment-2193890">comment from Amy AlkonI pay about $120 a year for AOL. My friend would have paid $1,200 to not go through the hell he did:
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2010/09/29/fraud_spam.html
Amy Alkon
at May 30, 2011 2:16 PM
Gmail is so superior to other mail services in its features that the lack of service isn't enough of an issue to make me want to use something else. We also use Google apps for company email. All of my various email accounts all funnel to Gmail, and I'm able to send as each of them from it.
I would encourage anyone using Gmail to make sure to use SSL encryption (an easy setting change), and consider the 2-step authorization process:
http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2011/02/advanced-sign-in-security-for-your.html
Christopher at May 30, 2011 6:44 PM
I just had to give up my aol email address after nearly 15 years of having it. ( I just turned 30). It got hacked somehow and it was spamming everyone in my address book. After numerous attempts to fix it, and apparently wasting money on anti viral software, and having a tech person look at my computer to make sure it wasn't my computer and not my email that was infected, I finally had to suck it up and switch to gmail. Aol wouldn't even let me deactivate my account so technically I still have it although I haven't logged in in three months. Hopefully they will deactivate it from lack of use.I just erased all of my contacts from it so it couldn't spam my friends and professional contacts anymore.
The sucky part was that every account I have and every contact was attached to my aol account. Luckily, I was able to set my gmail to funnel all my aol emails to my gmail inbox until everyone got used to the transitions and all of my accounts had been changed over. But of course, I get gmail for free too so I dont really know what I will expect to get from them in terms of support if something happens to that account too.
Sabrina at May 31, 2011 4:49 AM
I have had an AOL address since 94. Two years ago, I switched from paid AOL to free AOL and email still seems to be working just fine. I use Thunderbird to manage email. I have had a Netzero and Hotmail address for the same length of time. I use Netzero for family, AOL for commerce, and Hotmail for anyone I'm not sure of--Hotmail's spam filter is the strongest I have seen.
ken in sc at May 31, 2011 9:05 AM
Never had AOL, too many of those old bad business practices. (I'd never considered myself an Internet Veteran before, thanks Cousin Dave)
I like Google's attempts to make an integrated system, computer to phone, etc. I also like their ability to provide me services without costing me. I don't pay for any of the apps on my phone, because of their free market.
I have zero spam on Gmail, much better than Gawab. I have practically unlimited storage. I have had my Google account hacked, but it was by someone I knew. I was able to contact Google Support and they had me a new secret code, password, etc., in a few days time.
Cat at May 31, 2011 1:20 PM
"I see, AOL is some magic entity immune from hackers and ponzi scheme spam. Its called a spam filter. Its free. And what a laborious process clicking delete when one somehow gets through once a month. And I'm going to make a wild prediction and say that Google will be around for a bit longer than the hemorrhaging hemophiliac that is AOL."
Wow, what a tool.
Lobster at May 31, 2011 10:39 PM
You guys really help me out . I really need this information.
Dayle at November 6, 2019 3:40 AM
You guys really help me out . I really need this information.
Wilson at November 6, 2019 3:41 AM
Leave a comment