Achievement Envy
I sent this bit from a Classically Liberal blog item to a classy friend who's being attacked by a small and malicious person:
I recently wrote a one line comment accompanying a video, "When life seems like a load of crap, when the world seems inside-out, when justice is nowhere to be found, I take refuge in the talent of others."...One thing an old friend, Bob Sheaffer, taught me in his book Resentment Against Achievement, was that any achievement big enough to be noticed will be big enough to fuel resentment and envy. Envy is a pernicious and evil emotion. It isn't what many now think it is, it isn't admiration for something, but hatred of it. It is a hatred based on someone else having what you desire. Ayn Rand was spot-on when she said envy was hatred of the good for being the good. She said: "It means hatred of a person for possessing a value or virtue that one regards as desirable." It is a wholly negative emotion.
Aesop once told a tale of two neighbors, one filled with avarice, the other with envy. The gods decided to punish them and so promised that whatever the one wished for, the other would receive doubly. The avaricious man want a room full of gold. But seeing his neighbor with twice that turned him bitter and angry. The envious man, after thinking about it, decided he wanted to be made blind in one eye, thus knowing his neighbor would be made blind in both. Envy doesn't lift the envious, it tears down others instead.







Amy:
George Gilder describes this as the Israel Test:
http://www.nypost.com/p/news/opinion/books/item_Jp0DFeUq67yKCycahDkKiN
AB at June 8, 2011 12:03 PM
Unless the person is a total creep (in which case they're not actually excelling) I love watching people excel. I always figure it's one more body of work to entertain, inspire, inform or challenge me if not improve the world in some way. So I'm selfish.
mcquaidla at June 8, 2011 1:19 PM
I wish the gods would curse me like that. I'd work it out with the other person so we wished for good stuff.
NicoleK at June 10, 2011 6:03 AM
Leave a comment