SOPA Is On The Shelf!
Steven Benen writes at Washington Monthly that SOPA has been shelved (but not killed):
Misguided efforts to combat online privacy have been threatening to stifle innovation, suppress free speech, and even, in some cases, undermine national security. As of yesterday, though, there's a lot less to worry about.At issue are two related bills: the Senate's Protect IP Act and the even more offensive Stop Online Piracy Act in the House, both of which are generated intense opposition from tech giants and First Amendment advocates. The first sign that the bills' prospects were dwindling came Friday, when SOPA sponsors agreed to drop a key provision that would have required service providers to block access to international sites accused of piracy.
The legislation ran into an even more significant problem yesterday when the White House announced its opposition to the bills. Though the administration's chief technology officials officials acknowledged the problem of online privacy, the White House statement presented a fairly detailed critique of the measures and concluded, "We will not support legislation that reduces freedom of expression, increases cybersecurity risk or undermines the dynamic, innovative global Internet." It added that any proposed legislation "must not tamper with the technical architecture of the Internet."
I'm on deadline, so for anyone who doesn't know what SOPA is, check out this Wikipedia link.
And this is the main point, from a Reuters story by Sarah McBride:
"Like many other tech companies, we believe that there are smart, targeted ways to shut down foreign rogue websites without asking U.S. companies to censor the Internet," a Google spokeswoman told Reuters on Monday.In addition to concerns about the technical ramifications of DNS blocking and the practical issues associated with disabling services to individual websites, many in the Internet business fear the bills create far too much leeway to shut down websites without sufficient due process.
Note that PIPA still lives. Cory Doctorow blogs on BoingBoing:
House Majority Leader Eric Cantor has killed SOPA, stopping all action on it. He didn't say why he killed it, but the overwhelming, widespread unpopularity of the bill and the threat of a presidential veto probably had something to do with it.Before you get too excited, remember that the PROTECT IP Act (PIPA), the extremely similar Senate version of SOPA, is still steaming forward, and has to be stopped.







The vote is scheduled for January 24. Start writing and calling your senators now. Don't let the movie and music industry destroy the internet.
Elle at January 16, 2012 5:16 PM
Democrats and Republicans are both lining up to oppose this. Yay for bipartisanship! (Okay, that was snarky, but only a little.)
Cousin Dave at January 16, 2012 6:35 PM
While its all well and good the the white house is 'offically' opposed to these bills, let us not forget Obama seems to do a lot of shit he promised he wouldnt
lujlp at January 16, 2012 7:41 PM
To me luj, the conclusion of the White House statement smacks of "you didn't hide it well enough, when you can we'll support it"
Ltw at January 16, 2012 8:47 PM
I Sent this second e-mail to my senator:
After his carefully crafted reply of "I'll think about it." I sent this back.
The good thing is that he no longer has a district because of the census, effective November 2012. I won't say what I really feel but it involves burning and very specific locations. That would be hate speech. ;-)
Jim P. at January 16, 2012 9:42 PM
Leave a comment