The More Ginormous Government Gets, The Worse It Gets At Protecting Us
As somebody with a libertarian outlook, I see government's job at protecting us from rights violations, not "protecting" us from salty food.
A particularly timely example of the wrongheadedness in our bloated government from Glenn Reynolds at USA Today:
As The Federalist's David Harsanyi writes: "The CDC, an agency whose primary mission was to prevent malaria and then other dangerous communicable diseases, is now spending a lot of time, energy and money worrying about how much salt you put on your steaks, how close you stand to second-hand smoke and how often you do calisthenics."These other tasks may or may not be important, but they're certainly a distraction from what's supposed to be the CDC's "one job" -- protecting America from a deadly epidemic. And to the extent that the CDC's leadership has allowed itself to be distracted, it has paid less attention to the core mission.
In an era where new disease threats look to be growing, the CDC needs to drop the side jobs and focus on its real reason for existence. But, alas, the problem isn't just the CDC. It's everywhere.
It seems that as government has gotten bigger, and accumulated more and more of its own ancillary responsibilities, it has gotten worse at its primary tasks. It can supervise snacks at elementary schools, but not defend the borders; it can tax people to subsidize others' health-care plans but not build roads or bridges; and it can go after football team names but can't seem to deal with the Islamic State terror group.
Multitasking results in poorer performance for individuals. It also hurts the performance of government agencies, and of government itself. You have one job. Try doing it.
Oh, and if you think your Obamacare premium is bad now, wait till you're paying for all the Ebola patients.








I deal with some fed and local agencies, mid-level type stuff. The only reliably useful work done in the buildings is by the janitors. Otherwise it is endless meetings to get the minutia right, and then find a reason not to do the task at all. It is best thought of as a giant looting expedition.
doombuggy at October 11, 2014 1:57 AM
"A government big enough to give you everything you want is big enough to take everything you have." ~ Barry Goldwater
One sentence that encapsulates why limited government is best.
Conan the Grammarian at October 11, 2014 10:33 AM
The CDC, like many bureaucracies, has made "mission creep" moves.
But - perhaps not the salt silliness. It issued a report that almost all in the USA consume the maximum recommended amount - but the report also concluded that at up to three times the accepted maximum no adverse health effect was found for people without a pre-existing condition. It is the FDA which a year later (OK, 364 days) announced it would be looking to decrease salt in the national diet (via "processed" or "pre-prepared" foods) to less than the max recommendation - not updating said recommendation to follow the science.
John A at October 11, 2014 2:12 PM
Leave a comment