UC Santa Cruz's Official Tattletale Channel: College Is Now Nursery School With Beer
College is supposed to prepare students for adult life, but it's now just an extension of Miss Tibbett's preschool, with measures set up -- in this case, by the UC Santa Cruz Dean of Students' office -- for students to tattle on people who say mean things to them.
Students are now filing "Hate-Or-Bias Incident Reports." These are from 2014:
While walking to my car, I passed a Caucasian male going in the other direction who commented on my appearance. He said "You're a guy. Dress like a guy." I stopped, turned around and asked "Do you have something to say to me?" We stood looking at each other silently for a moment and then continued walking on. He then shouted "Yeah, you better keep walking."Incident Report Received: 4/18/2014
Confirmation Email Sent: 4/18/2014
Bias Category Reported: Sexual Identity
Action Requested: Information only, no action requested
Some people from my hall have been bothering me. They talk badly behind my back and text other people mean things about me. It has gotten to the point were my door remains closed and I don't feel comfortable in my own hall. They are 3 males and one female. The girl is named "female student", and the others are named "2 male students." The third student I don't know, but he's friends with them and he's like 5'8 or 5'9. I have felt bullied and feel that I am not safe because of the constant laughter and the constant glares.Incident Report Received: 5/23/2014
Confirmation Email Sent: 5/23/2014
Bias Category Reported: Creed, Socio-Economic Status
Action Requested: Review of possibly disciplinary action
Recently there was an SUA meeting that was discussing the Resolution to divest from companies that were violating the human rights of Palestinians by Israel. It was a very sensitive issue, and as a representative in the space, I felt very disrespected by the audience that was there. Earlier in the meeting we had discussed community agreements, and some of those were no snapping and clapping in respect. The Chair Shaz Umer had to remind people multiple times not to do this, but people continued to do this anyway. After we had voted and the resolution passed, there was celebration from the audience, but they did not respect the fact that SUA was still having the meeting and the fact that there were people hurt by the resolution.Incident Report Received: 5/30/2014
Confirmation Email Sent: 5/30/2014
Bias Category Reported: Campus Climate Issue
Action Requested: Have the DOS contact me
My dad, as a young man, enlisted in the army to go fight the Korean War. He never got sent over -- spent his whole time in the US -- but he did sign up for it.
Consider the difference between my dad and these crypussies.
There are still "a few good men" left in this country, but there are also an increasing number of younger people who, if attacked by a foreign power, or if simply called upon to do something borderline brave, would crawl under the bed and suck their thumb.
Also, I spent much of my life, into my 20s, socially excluded (with the exception being my time in my temple youth group as a teen). The answer wasn't to tattle on the perpetrators -- which would only have perpetuated the behavior that led to my exclusion. The answer -- the subject of my next book -- was to transform myself into somebody who had friends, wasn't a suckup, and could even stand up for herself (to the point where I will say something to rude bullies when everybody else is afraid to.)
For an adult way to take back the power when somebody tosses a cutting remark your way, here's an excerpt from my book "Good Manners for Nice People Who Sometimes Say F*ck":
Fighting ugly with pity: An all-purpose comeback for cutting remarks. You're in some social situation when somebody says something seriously rude about your looks or maybe your intelligence, right to your face. Of course, you come up with the perfect comeback-- two days later while sitting on the toilet.The truth is, even professional comedians can find it hard to have a good comeback in a social situation. They're ready for the occasional heckler when they're onstage (and often have a fistful of preplanned comebacks, since how they'll be heckled is pretty predictable). But when they're standing in a group of people at a party and somebody puts them down, shock and anger can take hold, shutting down the smartass remark-building parts of the brain. (It's that "emotional hijacking" Daniel Goleman talks about in re-sponse to dignity violations.)
Sure, when you're loose from a few beers, maybe your wit will sometimes come through for you, but it's safest to assume that it will instead scurry off and hide behind a large piece of furniture. In other words, you should dispense with the notion that a winning reply to a rude remark involves a response so witty that it incinerates the rudester right where they're standing. Rather, keep in mind that there's a reason somebody is being so ugly and cutting. Happy people tend to be kind or, at least, uninterested in tearing other people down. Miserable people often want to lash out at the world--and there you are, so conveniently located as a target for their hate.
When one of these spitebags hurls a put-down at you, they expect that you'll either try to fight back or just stand there blinking and wishing you could disappear. Instead, you should do the last thing they'd expect: Look straight at them for a moment, and coolly call them on their rottenness with a remark like "Clearly, you must have had a pretty bad day to feel the need to say some- thing so nasty to me. I hope you feel better." (Sincerity is not required here--just believability--so say it devoid of anger, and sound like you mean it.) By expressing sympathy for them, you've accomplished three things:
1. You've refused to accept their turning you into their victim.2. You've come off classy and bigger than they are.
3. You still managed to stick it to them, sending the message, "Sorry your life is such a suckhole that your lone path to happiness is trying to make other people feel like shit."








Unfortunately this all comes down to having simple easy to understand rules/standards (no butt pinching) and enforcing them.
This is counter to the "do not be judgmental" and "culture" PC mantra. Additionally for this crowd enforcing ("We said no __________ so refrain or leave now." is just too dang hard. (Send hunger strikers home for Mommy to handle.)
Bob in Texas at January 5, 2016 5:17 AM
I'll be judgmental and a bully here by betting that most of these are made up crap by folks who want more drama in their lives.
Seriously, what bully has ever has said "you're a guy, dress like a guy"?
I'm not even sure just what kind of put down that is. Just what does that even mean?
charles at January 5, 2016 6:15 AM
Oh my god, I want to bitch slap all of them. Every last one.
My 6 year old can handle shit better than these people.
momof4 at January 5, 2016 9:04 AM
I remember when being a Banana Slug was something to be proud of.
Canvasback at January 5, 2016 9:11 AM
There are always people like this. I worked with a woman who if you didn't hear her say 'Hi' or couldn't respond for some reason went paranoid and became convinced you were out to get her. She would then 'fight back' even though there was nothing to fight back against. At another office the rumor mill would make up all kinds of crazy stories about people. Often ignoring the even crazier reality. You see the same thing in politics. People make up all kinds of weird things Bush or Obama did ignoring the even worse things that actually were true.
The only difference here is you've given the loons a way to seek revenge for the figments in their imagination.
Ben at January 5, 2016 9:16 AM
What is it with California colleges with Santa in their names? Santa Clara University in the Bay Area instructed its students to ALWAYS CALL 911 IMMEDIATELY if they heard anyone say anything offensive:
http://campusreform.org/?ID=6766
Martin at January 5, 2016 9:51 AM
Do you really want to report the people in your dorm to the police? The police come and someone gets beaten or shot or arrested. You want people gossiping about you arrested? And what would they be charged with? In grad school in my research group there was bad gossip going around. I finally went to a couple of them and said "you can do whatever you want but don't tell me about it". Somehow this shut them all up.
And let's say you are walking down the street in Chicago and someone tells you to "dress like a man"--answer back and you may get shot.
The fundamental problem is that people are often jerks. You can choose a nicer group of people to hang out with or find ways of dealing with jerks, but you can't MAKE people be nice and you can't MAKE people not have prejudices, even if we send them all to reeducation camps. Are we going to MAKE people date those they find unattractive also? This is even more so when perfectly innocent words are deemed offensive--no one can know what will offend a random person.
Craig Loehle at January 5, 2016 10:00 AM
Dear Amy,
Factsarefacts has successfully hurt my head on too many occasions after I slammed it into my desk over and over again. Not since Crid has there been someone who manipulated the entire days' posts, but at least he was fun to read. Please, please, please slap them on the wrist with your ruler!!!
Incident Report Received: 1/05/2016
Confirmation Email Sent: 1/05/2016
Bias Category Reported: Rude, inconsiderate posters who hijack posts because they are narcissists who can't stand to be ignored on their own thread.
Action Requested: Ban for 30 days until they decide to play by the board rules along with everyone else.
gooseegg at January 5, 2016 11:19 AM
Well done Goose.
Canvasback at January 5, 2016 2:22 PM
"Do you really want to report the people in your dorm to the police? "
Yeah, they do, actually.
Cousin Dave at January 6, 2016 1:06 PM
Another astounding example of a generation of people governed by hurt feelings! Right on as always Amy, I for one cannot wait for your next book.
Chris at January 6, 2016 1:15 PM
Leave a comment