So, These "Triggered" Students Never Watch TV? The Ruin Of A Piece Of Art At Pitzer College
One way to get attention is to earn it -- do something worthy of attention.
But that takes work.
The other way to get attention is to mewl about being "triggered" -- psychologically debilitated by some word or picture.
In previous decades, somebody would have said, "Oh, grow the fuck up," or something like that to somebody who said something like this.
Now, people all bend over backwards to accommodate these "victims" -- and really, those doing the mewling are anything but victims. In fact, through claiming to be victimized, they have power they would otherwise have to work to earn.
Take a recent situation at Claremont's Pitzer college.
Selena Spier (PZ '19), painted a mural there. It's a handgun with flowers coming out of the end, and it was approved by the "Pitzer College aesthetics committee." (Who knew there was such a thing?)
*larger photo below
Well, Steven Glick reports at at the Claremont Independent that "Early Monday morning, Gregory Ochiagha (PZ '18), a Student Senator at Pitzer College, sent out an email to the student body" criticizing the mural:
"It's truly in bad taste to have a large depiction of a gun in a dorm space--especially when students of color also reside there," states Ochiagha. "Now let's imagine there were countless videos of white teenagers, white teenagers that look like you, or your brother or your sister, get shot to death by police officers. Imagine scrolling down Facebook everyday and seeing a new video of the same thing, over and over again. Really put yourself in that headspace. Then ask yourself whether it's the brightest idea to have white teenagers, who have a very real fear of getting shot, see a large gun every time they want to get food from the dinning [sic] hall."...Ochiagha continues, "My Black Mental and Emotional Health Matters. I shouldn't be reminded every time I leave my dorm room of how easy my life can be taken away, or how many Black lives have been taken away because of police brutality. This is emotionally triggering for very obvious reasons. And if you want to belittle or invalidate by [sic] black experience, I live in Atherton, come thru, let's have that idiotic conversation."
...Jessica Folsom (PZ '19) responded by providing additional background on the mural. "Just to preface this, I am not trying to dismiss how you feel or belittle your experience as a student of color," she states. "This mural is actually representative of a nonviolence movement to protest the Vietnam War in the 60s. There's a famous photo of a protester putting flowers in the barrel of a National Guardsman's rifle and everything." Folsom continues, "I thought it might be an important distinction to make between what the mural actually represents and perhaps the romanticized aesthetic of a gun which someone (maybe you?) could potentially mistake this for. I hope this helps."
Sadly -- sadly for free speech and the increasing chills on it that come when they are shown to work -- Spier said she "plans to modify" her mural -- and has (photo below). Glick continues, quoting Spier:
"I spoke with Gregory earlier and we agreed on a modification that preserves the integrity of the original piece while avoiding any potentially triggering content--it's a change I was absolutely happy to make in the interest of creating a safe and inclusive environment for everyone in my community," Spier told the Claremont Independent. "I have absolutely no right to decide whether or not my artwork is offensive to marginalized communities--nor does anyone else in a position of privilege, racial or otherwise."
Oh, hurl.
Like this Ochiagha guy never turns on TV -- even just "Law & Order" -- and never goes to the movies, or reads the newspaper, so as to avoid this supposedly debilitating experience of seeing a gun.
This is just such bullshit. As I keep noting, proclaiming yourself a victim over what would, at any other time, be seen as a triviality or just a normal part of life to deal with, is a way to have unearned power over others.
I have met people and known people who are Holocaust survivors -- who had babies ripped away from them and watched their entire families be marched into the gas chambers or be shot into mass graves. Knowing this and reading about this (and being kicked around by anti-Semites myself as a kid) doesn't make me feel fragile; it makes me realize I need to fight back.
And guess what: Art is sometimes about disturbing people. Well, that is when you aren't creating art for toddlers. Which, on campus, I suppose is what's being done.
Well, what disturbs me now -- deeply -- is what's been done to this art piece.
Once again, here's the original, in progress:
And now -- disgustingly denuded -- after newly-minted censor Ochiaga's power play (from a @HannahOh16 tweet):
And last but not least, that Hannah Oh tweet says it so perfectly:
@hannahoh16
This painting about peace triggered SJWs, who now decide what art is allowed. Kind of like Hitler & Mao but whiny.








I will never stop pointing this out, but triggers are identified in PTSD patients only. These special snowflakes are not "triggered"; they are annoyed by something.
Actually, that's not right either. They aren't "triggered"; they see an opportunity to bully someone else by feigning annoyance.
Medically-diagnosed (as opposed to self-diagnosed) PTSD patients (the only individuals who have the right to claim to be triggered by anything), do not use triggers as a means to control other people -- "Oh, professor! You have to take this out of your curriculum because it triggers me." They use triggers to identify potential stressors and to deploy coping skills to prevent an influx of anxiety and negative feelings/symptoms associated with the traumatic event.
In other words, triggers aren't of controlling other people; they're identified in PTSD patients to help them better control themselves.
These trigger-tyrants (or does "trigger-fascists" sound better?) need to be shamed and ridiculed at every opportunity. They are co-opting medical terminology that is intended to help people who need it, and using it a control mechanism. There are no words to describe just how disgusting that is. It's insulting to war vets and others who have endured real trauma in their lives.
And one more point:
This may come as a shock to him, but someone who actually did the necessary math and weighed the necessary variables, determined that you are 1.7 times more likely to die in a police encounter (in which there is a reasonable possibility of a cop having to use his gun) if you are white.
Cops are more likely to shoot a white suspect than a black one.
Patrick at April 27, 2016 12:00 AM
"My Black Mental and Emotional Health Matters. ..."
Actually cupcake it does not matter to anyone other than yourself.
I can be forced to "care" if the angry mob descends upon me but in reality kittens matter more than your emotional health because you have the ability to reason and have chosen not to.
(Longer version of Amy's GTFU.)
Bob in Texas at April 27, 2016 7:28 AM
Patrick is correct on PTSD. I wrote about this in a column:
http://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2015/12/the-hurt-and-co.html
Amy Alkon at April 27, 2016 7:34 AM
Let's turn to Fredrick Douglass for a comment:
So this student is so emotionally stunted as to voluntarily give up one of those boxes?
I R A Darth Aggie at April 27, 2016 7:38 AM
Based on the data given in the article, one cannot definitively conclude that a white person is more or less likely to get shot by the police, only that the police are more likely to shoot a white person.
The white population is 63% of the total and 49% of police shootings and the black population is 12% of the total and 30% of police shootings.
What is also missing from the data are how many police stops/encounters involve white men and black men. It's from the stops/encounters that shootings flow.
Another factor is what the person is up to when stopped and/or shot. Micheal Brown was not gunned down by the police on his way to church. He was shot in self-defense while charging an officer he had assaulted earlier that day. This was after beating up a shop owner and robbing him.
Black males make up a higher percentage of people who commit criminal acts than white males. It only follows then that they would have more encounters with the police and, even if a lower percentage of those encounters result in shootings than white encounters, a higher percentage of police-involved shootings.
None of this is evidence of an institutional police bias against black males. The roots of the problem run deeper than that.
Conan the Grammarian at April 27, 2016 7:47 AM
I have to agree with Patrick that the term "PTSD" gets bandied around a little too much these days, both in self-diagnosis and therapy.
I have childhood friend who told me his therapist told him he suffers from PTSD for a difficult childhood with a borderline abusive parent. I was there for most of his childhood and his difficulties are due more to himself than to his parent. Even back then, he was neurotic and made bad decisions.
It's like when therapists told their patients that their difficulties stemmed from their parents not showing them enough affection and they went away saying their problems were the fault of their parents; blaming Mom and Dad for every bad decision Junior had ever made.
PTSD is a diagnosis that people can latch onto and inexperienced therapists can convince their patients of without too much actual effort. Easier to convince a person he has PTSD than that he's been an idiot for most of his life.
This "black mental and emotional health" idiot is not being "triggered" by a badly drawn pistol in a hippie flower-power mural. He's trying to make his issues into the major focus of entire university. He's coopting (and stealing) other people's time and effort for power, the power to make others jump and do his bidding.
Conan the Grammarian at April 27, 2016 8:58 AM
Disappointed that Folsom agreed to bowdlerize the mural; it's now unrecognizable. But I understand why. She was doubtless told by the school, maybe not in so many words, "Do this or you don't graduate". Whether the original version was good art is a matter for debate, but being an art critic does not give me the right to demand that art works I don't like be destroyed.
And yes, Ochiagha appears to lack both the historical context and any basic understanding of art. Of course, that wasn't where here line of thinking was. Her line of thinking was, "Gun image, I can exploit that politically". Her examination of the artwork stopped there. Nothing else about it matters.
Cousin Dave at April 27, 2016 9:24 AM
My Uncle was killed by a handgun loaded with petunia petals. It was a horrifying yet oddly beautiful tragedy.
Shtetl G at April 27, 2016 9:39 AM
"This mural is actually representative of a nonviolence movement to protest the Vietnam War in the 60s. There's a famous photo of a protester putting flowers in the barrel of a National Guardsman's rifle and everything."
I served on the USS James Madison with that very protester. The picture is visible here.
-----
If you want to whine about being unsafe because you're black, the cops pick on you, etc., it's best to deny reality. Here's a quote: "The most dangerous misconception about our criminal justice system is that it is pervaded by racial bias. For decades, criminologists have tried to find evidence proving that the overrepresentation of blacks in prison is due to systemic racial inequity. That effort has always come up short. In fact, racial differences in offending account for the disproportionate representation of blacks in prison. A 1994 Justice Department survey of felony cases from the country’s 75 largest urban areas found that blacks actually had a lower chance of prosecution following a felony than whites. Following conviction, blacks were more likely to be sentenced to prison, however, due to their more extensive criminal histories and the gravity of their current offense."
Radwaste at April 27, 2016 10:34 AM
This mural offends me because the slide is way *way* out of proportion to the frame. An actual gun that ugly shouldn't see the light of day.
Steve Daniels at April 27, 2016 4:59 PM
This mural offends me because the slide is way *way* out of proportion to the frame. An actual gun that ugly shouldn't see the light of day.
Steve Daniels at April 27, 2016 4:59
Looks like a Desert Eagle slide on top of Glock 19 frame.
Probably copied from a bad Manga.
Isab at April 27, 2016 5:36 PM
☑ Shtetl G at April 27, 2016 9:39 AM
Comment of the Month, April 2016
(Also, weirdly enough, June 1967.)
Amy's gonna send you out a windbreaker. Try not to get any stains on it before summertime.
Crid at April 28, 2016 1:45 AM
Gregory Ochiagha: do you realize you just got pwned by a college girl painting?
Yeah, I'm kewl, I used "pwned".
Radwaste at April 29, 2016 2:27 PM
Leave a comment