Defending Free Expression -- In The Slightest -- Is Now "Hate Speech" On Campus
Precisely the sort of scholarly leaders you want at a university -- those who encourage students to think for themselves, express themselves freely, and be open to ideas and experience -- are now gone from Yale.
Zachary Young, a Yale student, writes in the WSJ:
Nicholas Christakis and his wife, Erika, came to Yale University in 2013 with high expectations. At Harvard, the couple had held prominent teaching and administrative roles. At Yale, Dr. Christakis, a sociologist and physician, received a laboratory directorship and four appointments; Ms. Christakis, an expert in early-childhood education, became a seminar instructor. Two years after their arrival at Yale, Dr. Christakis and Ms. Christakis were awarded positions as master and associate master of Silliman College, Yale's largest residential college. (I attend the university and reside at Silliman).Last week, the Christakises resigned those posts.
Their departure comes as no surprise. For seven months, the couple has been subject to bullying, harassment and intimidation. They inadvertently became a national media story last fall and catalyzed a month of campus protests, prompting Yale President Peter Salovey to tell minority students: "We failed you."
No, Yale is failing the student body at large.
Here's the incident:
The Christakises encountered a witch-hunt mentality on a contemporary college campus. It began fittingly on the day before Halloween, when Ms. Christakis questioned guidelines from Yale's Intercultural Affairs Committee warning against "culturally unaware or insensitive" costumes. Ms. Christakis reasoned, in an email to Silliman residents, that students should decide for themselves how to dress for Halloween, without the administration's involvement.Student radicals of the 1960s might have recognized her note as a defense of free expression, but those days are long gone. Instead, Ms. Christakis was denounced as a proponent of cultural insensitivity. Irate students circulated petitions, wrote editorials and posted social-media tirades. They scribbled criticisms in chalk outside the Christakises' home and posted degrading images of them online. Two student groups demanded their removal from Silliman.
Oh, and what sort of people are the Christakises?
The Christakises made remarkably unlikely targets for purging by student activists. The couple has a long record of advocating for minority students, and the Christakises have devoted much of their academic work to highlighting health and development problems facing underserved communities.
In announcing their resignation, Nicolas Christakis wrote:
"We remain hopeful that students at Yale can express themselves and engage complex ideas within an intellectually plural community."
I think there's less and less reason to think that will be the case at Yale and other universities.








Odds are as sociology and education degree holders they are liberals themselves
So . . . .
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6CVvNRQcvE
lujlp at June 4, 2016 8:10 AM
Good riddance. They might have been on the right side of the argument, but they are cowards, plain and simple.
Erika Christakis resigned from teaching in December because of the fallout from her comments on the Halloween costume. They capitulated to bullies. I have no use for them. Fuck them.
Patrick at June 4, 2016 8:28 AM
Wow -- I think that's wildly unfair. These people were under tremendous pressure, and I'm sure it got in the way of their work.
We can't make a decision what other people "should" be able to stand; you can only make those decisions for yourself.
Here's Nicholas Christakis being screamed at by a student.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZRl2_ibd_WA
Is this an atmosphere that is psychologically healthy to stick around in?
I tend to stand up for things other people never would -- to my detriment (like when a TSA worker got a lawyer and tried to get $500K out of me). However, I realize that not everyone has my fortitude, and I accept that, and don't react with a "Fuck them!" when people don't act as I am able to or would.
Amy Alkon at June 4, 2016 10:05 AM
I can kinda see Patrick's point, even in quitting they didnt have the fortitude to tell people to fuck off on their way out the door. This couple basically thanked the people who ran them out of town and asked for the forgiveness of the mob for 'forcing' the students to treat them like shit
lujlp at June 4, 2016 10:34 AM
They didn't even get to wear costumes!
Bob in Texas at June 4, 2016 10:41 AM
No, Amy, it's completely fair. Let me remind you that their stance was supposedly for free speech? Yet here they are, voluntarily walking out the door, not even forced out by the college, not taking a single step toward defending their own rights to speak their mind.
I saw again, "They are cowards, plain and simple. Fuck 'em."
That's how the crybullies are going to win. Determination to silence our free speech, and cowards like the Christakises who let them.
If free speech isn't the hill you want to die on, then what, pray tell, are you willing to take a stand for?
Getting rid of the TSA?
Patrick at June 4, 2016 11:36 AM
They came for all the x, they came for all the y, yada yada, and now they came for the Christakis.
Like Patrick and Lujlp I can't have much sympathy. They did nothing when the rest of us were run out of town. Now was just their turn.
Ben at June 4, 2016 2:30 PM
> We can't make a decision what
> other people "should" be able
> to stand; you can only make those
> decisions for yourself.
Exactly: Hence the hair-removal flaming received by KJT for this https://twitter.com/KJTorrance/status/738601959624609796tweet.
Been thinking about it for a day or so now, and I don't think I'll ever understand exactly what she was getting at. Not a crime, perhaps not even especially insensitive... But WTF?
Crid at June 4, 2016 4:10 PM
This tweet yonder, I meant: https://twitter.com/KJTorrance/status/738601959624609796
Sorry.
Crid at June 4, 2016 4:16 PM
Let's be charitable Crid and assume she meant the lady showed "grace under fire" (not the TV show).
Bob in Texas at June 4, 2016 4:38 PM
Bobster, the Bobifier, the Prehistoric Flying Bobasaures...
You are a remarkably 'charitable' man.
Crid at June 5, 2016 4:13 AM
Leave a comment