Win-Win, For Students Needing Housing And Elderly With Extra Room
I wish someone had thought of this -- or I had -- when I was attending NYU and living in awful and expensive places, like an 8x10 "apartment," sans kitchen, in a converted SRO hotel (flophouse).
I paid $900-some dollars to live in that shoe closet of a place, while my movie sound dude boyfriend paid $400-some for an eight-room pre-ward apartment on the Upper West Side.
At Yahoo/AP, Karen Matthews writes that NYU is starting a program next fall to help students save money on housing by putting them up in elderly people's spare bedrooms:
The program, to be operated in conjunction with the University Settlement social service organization, will start with 10 to 15 students bunking in senior citizens' spare bedrooms.Neither the students nor their elder hosts have been selected yet, but the basics of the program are in place: Participating students will pay $5,000 a year, thousands of dollars less than the cheapest on-campus housing option.
Almost all of the money will go to their senior hosts, said Ellen Schall, a professor of health policy and management who chairs NYU's affordability steering committee. The initiative will be expanded if it's popular.
"This is a win-win for both the seniors and the young adults," said University Settlement CEO Eric Weingartner.
Living in an older person's spare room wouldn't be for everyone.
NYU history major Brendan Gutenschwager, 19, said the option doesn't appeal to him, but might attract serious-minded older students. He envisioned that might be students who think, "You know what? I just want to get through my classes and have a good place to study where I'm not surrounded by a bunch of loud college students."
As Barnard student Toni Airaksinen points out, some students end up homeless.
This NYU program helps both the elderly and the students -- and may be the source of a wonderful relationship.
The students will not be caregivers for their hosts, but may pitch in on small chores like changing a lightbulb or carrying laundry from one room to another."We're trying to identify buildings where the financial contribution from students will be meaningful to the seniors," Weingartner said. "The part that's more nuanced is the impact of having companionship for both the senior and the students."
In the Chicago version of this, students do about 20 hours a week of chores.
This helps older people "age in place," which is very important for their health and well-being, as I've learned from my wonderful younger sister, who works in this area. (She works to help the elderly feel valued -- which is the essence of dignity -- and to have a good quality of life at the end of their lives.)
via @freerangekids








This reminds me of that Dutch program that allowed students to live in nursing homes for a break on rent: http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/dutch-retirement-home-offers-rent-free-housing-students-one-condition/
When I was in grad school, a friend of mine stumbled upon a Craigslist ad that basically said, "Hey, I have to move cross-country for a job, but you can live in a room in my mom's house [in desirable neighborhood] for $300/month if you do some chores." That's a STEAL in D.C. He took the offer and ended up offering mostly tech support to this woman as she learned the art of digital photography. Win-win.
Also: It's a travesty how we treat the elderly in our culture (as nuisances, basically, to be kept "out of the way").
sofar at December 16, 2016 8:10 AM
Just wait until that senior citizen says something that offends the pwecious snowflake.
Sixclaws at December 16, 2016 8:44 AM
Just wait until the pwecious snowflake takes advantage of their elderly host.
"Privilege" and all that.
I R A Darth Aggie at December 16, 2016 10:28 AM
This might work with a graduate student but in general I'd be watchful of 19 -22 yo just away from home for the first time.
A "teenager" does not have the maturity to deal with school, peer pressure, and dating and live w/a senior citizen. That's the same as living at home.
Bob in Texas at December 16, 2016 10:51 AM
I see many benefits, not the least of which the snowflakes getting a reality check on how tough older people are and what they went through: wars depressions, and all without a safe space.
But I also see some conflicts, i.e. being a night owl for the senior, means going to bed by 11 PM for the student, by 5 AM.
Joe J at December 16, 2016 10:58 AM
Just wait until that senior citizen says something that offends the pwecious snowflake.
The parents will get involved, just wait.
Pirate Jo at December 16, 2016 11:00 AM
"Almost all of the money will go to their senior hosts . . ."
Notice the "almost"? Why not ALL of it will go to the seniors?
Folks don't need a "program" to do this. When I was in college (back in the stone ages) folks, both students and seniors, did this through the "rooms listings" at the school. There was no need for the school to get involved and take a portion of the rent money.
charles at December 16, 2016 1:06 PM
Leave a comment