Smart School Superintendent: No Homework For Elementary School Kids; Just Read Nightly
Kids today get more homework in elementary school -- in a single week -- than I did throughout most of high school. (I was learning -- it was just learning of my choice and not the school's, in the countless books I read that were not assigned to me.)
From what I see, kids' homework often gets done in concert with the parents. So, a parent works all day, does stuff around the home, and then...homework time! What gets lost is outside time and free time to develop independence and the resilience that a lot of kids in colleges now seem to lack.
About the reading thing, Valerie Straus writes in the WaPo:
Elementary school students in one Florida school district are going to find a welcome new -- but controversial -- policy when they return to school for the 2017-2018 school year next month: no traditional homework.They are being asked to do one thing to help them academically: Read for 20 minutes a night.
Heidi Maier, the new superintendent of the 42,000-student Marion County public school district in Florida, said in an interview that she made the decision based on solid research about what works best in improving academic achievement in students.
(That may seem like something of a no-brainer, but in the world of education, policymakers are notorious for making a great deal of policy without knowing and/or caring about what the best research shows.)
The policy will apply to all elementary school students in the district -- about 20,000 -- but not to middle or high school students. Maier, an expert on reading acquisition who started running Marion schools in November after serving as lead professor of teacher education at the College of Central Florida, said she is basing her decision on research showing that traditional homework in the early years does not boost academic performance but reading -- and reading aloud -- does.
There's another problem -- one I suspect is partly due to Common Core:
Maier cited the work of Richard Allington, an expert on reading acquisition, who has researched and written extensively on how to teach students to read."The quality of homework assigned is so poor that simply getting kids to read replacing homework with self-selected reading was a more powerful alternative," Allington said in an email. "Maybe some kinds of homework might raise achievement but if so that type of homework is uncommon in U.S. schools."
Here's a fourth-grader sounding off in the stupid government-mandated testing:
I do see a problem of reading assigned as homework -- psychologically, does it turn it into a grind? There's some research I read that suggests that -- can't remember what it is at the moment.
Also, 20 minutes? Maybe they wanted a standard that they thought everybody could meet. My mom read to me constantly when I was a kid, and as soon as I could read, I was rarely not reading -- even when I was riding my bike. (That didn't end well -- early reading-while-driving accident.)
via @AdamMGrant








I think I crashed my bike four or five times before I stopped reading a cycling
lujlp at July 23, 2017 11:49 PM
How do they plan to enforce this?
Ben at July 24, 2017 5:34 AM
Love that, luj. I somehow learned the first time.
And Ben, no idea.
Amy Alkon at July 24, 2017 6:04 AM
The only way to enforce it is when their grades suffer and they fall behind. Sorry Mom, or Dad or whomever, your darling child may have to repeat a year.
Imagine the shouting and screaming.
I R A Darth Aggie at July 24, 2017 7:41 AM
"Also, 20 minutes?"
and believe me, they have a count-down timer set on their iPhones. They're back on xbox at 20:05, not outside throwing dirt clods at trees and frtying yellow jackets with a magnifying glass (ah - science).
Ben - parents sign a log, students write short summaries
smurfy at July 24, 2017 8:33 AM
So once again this is irrelevant. Parents who value education are already doing this. No change there. Parents who don't value education will just sign off on it. No change there. As for grades suffering, with no way to verify if the 'work' was done there is little reason for the grades to either improve or worsen. As for book reports, if the teacher hasn't read the book how would they know what is in it? Writing a few paragraphs on something neither of you have read isn't that hard. Heck, just copy one from the internet.
Mind, I'm not saying this is a bad thing. There is a lot of wasted time in our education system. I just doubt this will make a difference either positive or negative.
Ben at July 24, 2017 12:06 PM
There are quite a few "reading timers" on the market to help kids with their assigned reading time.
Usually, it is signed off by a parent, but sometimes a teacher will ask kids/parents to log what the child is reading and page numbers weekly.
My experience with two kids who are really readers... the one who likes reading, but isn't quite addiction-level into it read LESS when there was a time limit. One year I told the teacher he read more when it wasn't timed and he had the option to NOT read some days, and she said "that's fine, don't worry about the reading log." Another year we just agreed I would sign in no matter what so long as he was generally reading most days. When there was no timer, it would usually be 60 minutes of reading or so.
For kids who are learning to read, 20 minutes is a LOT (like in kindergarten when many are still sounding out the word "cat"). But then being read TO should count (again, that's homework for mom & dad... or big siblings).
Shannon at July 24, 2017 3:15 PM
Why don't they just beat the kids until they learn?
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at July 24, 2017 4:44 PM
Because then you have blood stains in the carpet Gog. Do you want to come clean my carpet?
Ben at July 24, 2017 8:14 PM
Leave a comment