Welcome To Female Competition: Find A Reason The Pretty Girls Should Cover Up
Jennifer Lawrence was criticized by feminists -- as if she were some actressbot with zero agency -- for posing outside in what must have been cold weather in a fabulous and revealing dress.
I'd have done it, too in a -- heh -- hot second, and for the same reasons Lawrence did. (More on that below.)
I once joined two very smart (and hot) guy friends for drinks at the bar by my house. I wore a vintage full-length Halston evening dress -- at about 5 o'clock on a weekday afternoon.
There were people in the place in sweats, sure, and my guy friends were dressed as I knew they'd be -- in everyday guy clothes.
My feeling: Life is short. Fashion's fun. Why dress like you're about to clean out the garage?
In The Telegraph/UK, Helena Horton reports that Lawrence gave the feminist sneerers both barrels, calling them "ridiculous".
The actress defended her right to wear a skimpy Versace dress during a promotional event for the film Red Sparrow earlier this week.While Lawrence wore the strappy gown, which featured a thigh-high split, male co-stars Joel Edgerton, Jeremy Irons, Matthias Schoenaerts and director Francis Lawrence were all in multiple layers of clothing, and many pointed out the contrast.
Writer Helen Lewis attracted thousands of retweets when she wrote: "This is such a quietly depressing (and revealing) image. Not least because I've been outside today and it's b----- FREEZING."
Peep Show's Robert Webb tweeted: "To all those saying JL 'chose' to wear that dress: fine but that choice has a context. She could have made a different decision but we can agree on one thing: it's not a decision to which the blokes had to give the slightest thought."
...Lawrence responded to critics in an impassioned Facebook post, writing: "This is not only utterly ridiculous, I am extremely offended. That Versace dress was fabulous, you think I'm going to cover that gorgeous dress up with a coat and a scarf? I was outside for 5 minutes. I would have stood in the snow for that dress because I love fashion and that was my choice.
"This is sexist, this is ridiculous, this is not feminism. Over- reacting about everything someone says or does, creating controversy over silly innocuous things such as what I choose to wear or not wear, is not moving us forward. It's creating silly distractions from real issues. Get a grip people. Everything you see me wear is my choice. And if I want to be cold THATS MY CHOICE TOO
This might seem like these feminists care about Lawrence and whether she has goosebumps. However, it's really classic female competition. I write about that in this column:
While men will sock each other in the bar parking lot (and can sometimes go back in and have a beer), women engage in what anthropologists call "covert aggression" -- attacks that are hard to pinpoint as attacks, like gossip, social exclusion, and stabbing another woman in the self-worth. ("Stabracadabra!" -- you're bleeding out, but nobody but you can tell!)Psychologist Anne Campbell, like others who study female competition, explains that women seem to have evolved to avoid physical confrontation, which would endanger their ability to have children or fulfill their role as an infant's principal caregiver. (Ancestral Daddy couldn't exactly run up to the store for baby formula.) So while guys will engage in put-down fests as a normal part of guy-ness, even women's verbal aggression is usually sneaky and often comes Halloween-costumed as compliments or concern: "Ooh, honey, do you need some Clearasil for those bumps on your chest?"
The tarted-up put-down is a form of psychological manipulation -- a sly way of making a woman feel bad about herself so she'll self-locate lower on the totem pole. And because men have visually driven sexuality, women specialize in knocking other women where it really hurts -- their looks. Like those supposedly minuscule boobs of yours. (Right...you'll have a latte, and she'll just have another mug of your tears.)








The topic of female competition always reminds me of a few lines from Ani Difranco's "32 Flavors"
"God help you if you are an ugly girl
Of course, too pretty is also your doom
Cause everyone harbors a secret hatred
For the prettiest girl in the room"
"I'll never try to give my life meaning
by demeaning you"
Just thought I'd mention that. I always take the opportunity to mention Ani. She's ace. :)
...and good on Laurence for facing down the girl police. This puritan/modesty nonsense is getting out of hand. No wonder these types see the burka as a positive.
Steven Williamson at February 23, 2018 1:36 AM
I saw on Twitter that she, Lawrence, had called someone "sexist". It took several seconds to process what she might have meant. This is just a weird time in our social understanding of such matters, as news of Weinstein's prosecution and defense are showing up in the feeds as well. It's hard to know what's worth taking offense over.
Crid at February 23, 2018 2:01 AM
Every guy who has ever been asked to settle an argument between two women knows that it's a lose-lose deal: no matter what you do, you will end up with both women angry at you. If you choose a side, the one you don't choose will be angry with you, and the one you do choose will instantly go all sisterhood and be angry with you because you hurt the other woman's feelings. If you try to find a middle ground, they will both be angry with you for not manning up and choosing a side.
Cousin Dave at February 23, 2018 6:23 AM
Well, so much for "her body, her choice".
I R A Darth Aggie at February 23, 2018 6:40 AM
CD, that's the case were you don't say nothin', and go back to your meal/drink/beer.
I had that happen to me once, and that's what I did. As you imply, I got a question for which there is no right answer.
I R A Darth Aggie at February 23, 2018 6:44 AM
On the one hand, she can wear whatever she wants to - anyone can.
OTOH, she has a history of forcing herself into the spotlight, especially trying to give her "informed and enlightened opinion" on things that she knows nothing about while ridiculing others for having different opinions.
For example, she said on British TV in September 2017 that the hurricanes in Florida and Texas "were signs of Mother Nature’s rage and wrath at America for electing Donald Trump."
She has every right to speak up on any topic she wants. But if you do that as a public figure, you'd better be prepared for the backlash.
rick at February 23, 2018 7:16 AM
When I was still in my 20’s, I’d run around half naked in the cold, too... not because of “sexism,” but because I looked good, and I knew it. Now that I’m in my late 30’s, I generally only raise an eyebrow when someone is dressed inappropriately in an office setting (or church). (We did have a “skintern” last year that who though that “business casual” meant skintight mini dresses.) But for social events? Look as hot as you want.
ahw at February 23, 2018 9:13 AM
In a small village or tribe, it makes sense that you can raise your status by pulling others down, and people do that. But in a country of 370,000,000 that makes no sense at all. No one around you will promote your status because you discouraged some hot girl from wearing sexy clothes. No one around you will even notice such a thing unless it is in a small social circle, in which case the rep as a mean girl wipes out any advantage.
cc at February 23, 2018 11:32 AM
if a girl doesn't suck up to other girls and apologize for looking good too, she will be utterly vilified. the level of fear and loathing is terribly high among women. sad to not love who you are and can be.
vicki chang at February 23, 2018 4:28 PM
But in a country of 370,000,000 that makes no sense at all.
It does if you can get her to apologize for such an infraction in public. Shows that you have lots of power because you're able to pretend you speak for all women. With your numbers, thats ballpark 185 million women.
But when your target tells you and your fellow crones to go suck an egg, not so much power.
I R A Darth Aggie at February 23, 2018 7:08 PM
While men will sock each other in the bar parking lot (and can sometimes go back in and have a beer),
And, in those cases, their choice is typically Miller Fite.
JD at February 24, 2018 1:16 PM
Leave a comment