Did You Buy Your Judith Butler Baubles To Clandestinely Stick On Your Family's Tree?
Academia -- gender studies departments power grabbing by using the supposedly powerless as tools -- are the source of today's "religion," secular religion doing some of the jobs actual religion has long done (like giving people a thing to belong to).
In case you're new around here, I'm an atheist -- but one who says "Merry Christmas!" Because it's the nice thing to do, and I like to be nice, and I'm old enough and mature enough not to need to believe in Jesus as savior to do it.
Judith Butler-splainer for the uninitiated. (In short, po-mo mumbo jumbo that people in the employ of university departments of po-mo mumbo jumbo pretend to understand.)
Secular fundamentalism has now replaced religion. Actual religion comes with all this cool decor (especially for the Catholics...weeping Madonnas and all...plus Christmas lights), and secular fundamentalists are just dour and angry.
— Amy Alkon (@amyalkon) December 12, 2018








Holy icon Batman, these people speak a language unknown on this planet!
Jay at December 12, 2018 5:54 AM
You, too, can speak or write po-mo. Just put a bunch of words like "hegemony" in a paper bag, shake it up, spill it out, and string them together with connecting words. Be sure your end product makes no fucking sense whatsoever, but sounds important.
Amy Alkon at December 12, 2018 6:15 AM
Made the mistake of following the Butler link. This is clearly a person who firmly believes that words structure reality, and not the other way around. While it may be true that culture shapes the permitted expression of sex (consider Burkas, for example) the innate hormones and desire between the sexes and the hormonal responses of bonding resulting from sex are not "constructed". By her account, animals must have complex societies also with cultural norms and blah blah. Which is crazy. She sounds like an alien with no personal experience of sexual desire (and her photo looks like it also).
cc at December 12, 2018 9:10 AM
I don't think that most Americans realize that 'continental philosophy' (aka post modernism / post structuralism, deconstructionism ) was just a fad in Europe that died out in the 80's. People like Derrida were seen as something akin to intellectual performance artists.
But it became instutionalized in the US and some other Anglo countries, and so persists today as the dominant system in many areas.
People have wondered why, being that it's not cogent or useful for anything.
The best answer I've found is that post structuralism and critical theory provided a sheen of academic respectibility at at time when the various Identity studies areas were emerging. And it allowed those people to justify themselves by arguing that it is impossible to capture their perspective with traditional analysis and criticism - you HAD to use a 'situated and critical' post structuralism and deconstruction to even approach the problem.
norma at December 12, 2018 9:55 AM
"secular fundamentalists are just dour and angry"
you might be interested in this account by a young man who was active in this culture and left once he realized the damaging it was to his relationships and well being.
https://quillette.com/2018/12/11/sad-radicals/
mickd at December 12, 2018 6:16 PM
"The best answer I've found is that post structuralism and critical theory provided a sheen of academic respectibility at at time when the various Identity studies areas were emerging."
I spent some time last summer trying to make an honest effort to discover the philosophical roots of post-modernism. Sufficiently fortified, I read some articles and writings by some post-modernist academics. This was all I could come up with: Post-modernism is a critique of modernism. The critique is: modernism isn't perfect, therefore it is worthless. That's it.
Post-modernism rejects modernism without offering a coherent alternative. As such, it's essentially a nihilistic philosophy. And my critique of nihilism is: By nihilism's own rules, the phrase "nihilism sucks" is irrefutable.
Cousin Dave at December 13, 2018 6:22 AM
Leave a comment