Will People On The Left Rise Up To Put "Woke" To Sleep?
There's all sorts of raging crazy all over the place -- identity politics and progressive puritanism about what can and cannot be said and done...to the point where citing established biological reality is a thought crime worthy of exile:
"When a close friend told her roommates that she believed in biological differences between the sexes, she was forced to change dorms because she had created an uncomfortable environment for one of the students." (!) https://t.co/5746aUOCHX https://t.co/ZDcJtZ4kHJ
— Steve Stewart-Williams (@SteveStuWill) July 7, 2019
However, amidst all the warped "woke"-ness, there are glimmers of sanity. At Spiked, Fraser Myers writes about the "dirtbag left," as one of its members refers to this rather wee (but hopefully growing) movement:
The phrase was coined by Amber A'Lee Frost, a writer, commentator and activist, to describe a loose constellation of American leftists who reject the civility, piety and PC that has come to characterise much of the left.Frost is a co-host of the hugely successful Chapo Trap House, which offers a funny, irony-laden and often downright vulgar take on contemporary politics from the left. She also writes a column for the Baffler and is a trade unionist.
Newer on the scene is the acerbic and wickedly funny Anna Khachiyan, art critic turned cultural commentator, who co-hosts the podcast Red Scare. Red Scare saves its most biting criticism for 'neoliberal' feminism.
Among the most refreshing things about Frost and Khachiyan is that their politics are resolutely not woke. 'You can tell people that I'm trans', says Khachiyan, with characteristic irreverence, as Frost, Khachiyan and myself sit down to talk at Eastwood in the Lower East Side. 'I'm not trans, but you can say that just for fun.' Their reasons for rejecting wokeness are both pragmatic and political. 'The majority of people are not woke', explains Frost: 'Why would we dismiss the majority of people as hopelessly reactionary?'
Not only that, for Frost, identitarian divisions based on gender, race and sexuality are 'a distraction at best, an active detriment at worst'. 'The biggest divide in American society is class and that's it. I'm a class-first person', she tells me. 'You're hearing in the election how much we need to elect a woman or we need to elect a woman of colour. But the most left-wing candidate is an old, white, heterosexual man [Bernie Sanders] and I want him to win... I'm a Bernie bro. I was a Bernie bro in 2016 and I am now.'
...For Khachiyan, 'You can say a lot of bad things about Donald Trump, but you can't say the man is boring'.
'Trump should be an artist, not a politician', she adds. 'He says, "I've never seen a thin person drinking Diet Coke", and he loves Diet Coke, that's his drink of choice. I don't know if he's self-aware or not.'
The problem with liberals, she says, is that 'they can't differentiate between their political critiques of Trump and their aesthetic critiques of him... He really brings to the fore all these inarticulable taboos. But as a politician, he's not very exceptional.' It is not so much Trump's policies that anger the liberals, but his brashness, his demeanour. Frost adds, by way of example, that Obama also 'threw tear gas at the border'.
And so much of woke-ie-ism seems to be about making the personal political. For example, from Fraser's piece, quoting Khachiyan:
'A lot of these people are tyrannical narcissists'....'Antifa have manufactured a threat to have some semblance of an identity. All these people who say they are anti-fascist don't know what it means to be persecuted.'
Meanwhile, another example of where this leads and what's wrong with the thinking (scroll down for the tweet explainer below the attached media):
Esteemed film critic Sasha Stone doesn't like what is happening to film criticism and, as an esteemed film critic, has some thoughts about why. pic.twitter.com/w9yQzkrgRk
— Jesse Crall (@jessecrall) July 6, 2019








While promising I'm not that hopeful.
Ben at July 8, 2019 6:13 AM
Let's see what happens when antifa shows up on their front door step, yelling out to their neighbors and friends that these people are Nazis.
And then "milkshake" them.
I R A Darth Aggie at July 8, 2019 7:05 AM
Chapo Trap House may claim to not be "woke", but they're just as fanatical about wishing death on those they disagree with from the safety of their keyboard. Far from being "glimmers of sanity", these people are one neural impulse away from milkshaking the fash. And by fash, I mean anyone they think disagrees with them.
Dissident White at July 8, 2019 8:26 AM
"Why would we dismiss the majority of people as hopelessly reactionary?"
Because that's a foundational principle of Leftism, which is basically a form of Gnosticism. If the people aren't hopelessly reactionary, then leftists aren't magically special.
Cousin Dave at July 8, 2019 8:33 AM
Anyone who actually supports Bernie has their head up their ass so far that wokeness, or lack there of, is just frosting on the crazy cake.
Isab at July 8, 2019 8:53 AM
Isab: "frosting on the crazy cake." I will have to use that one. hahahahaha
The spiked article is quoting some people who are simply communists who see the world in class conflict terms rather than racism/sexism/ism terms. That doesn't make them better. Their whole premise is that "class" as a permanent condition (you are born into it) actually exists in the US. Yes, in Europe you still have rich people whose ancestors were rich (usually due to land holdings) 200 yrs ago and you can tell someone's class from their accent (looking at you, England) but not so much in the US where people from poor families are now doctors or own a plumbing business, where all the building contractors in my area are Mexican immigrants who came with nothing. The roofers who just did a job across the street were all driving nice SUVs. Please don't call them oppressed. We also have people working as barristas or just scraping by at Spiked(!) who think of themselves as the elite.
cc at July 8, 2019 11:25 AM
As Conan the Grammerian put to me early one recent November morn—
Liberalism —the moistened, smelly & heartfelt kind for which you now so deeply stain your linens— is an essential component of the Postwar American Miracle, including the intellectual firmament. Conservatism may, may have been slightly more principled... But only at its field offices and deeper extensions. The core right-side functionaries were no less abusive of the public trust than the Kamalas and Occasional-Cortex's who wound your comity today.
I listened to this podcast mostly for the gossip implications. Adler is after all the woman who shitkicked Pauline Kael right in the fuzzbeard softyparts… And as she notes in the recording, many were appalled and annoyed, yet no one ever argued that her appraisal was WRONG.
But listen especially to her regard of Daniel Patrick Moynihan. Yes, THAT DP Moynihan, the Pointy-eared Spock of the postwar Left. His enthusiasm for Universal Basic Income seems like an opium daydream of responsible civic stewardship compared to the galactic socialist corruption which you and I, dear older reader (and don't fucking kid yourself, Mr & Mrs Whitepubes) are leaving for youngsters under the Stars and Stripes.
Crid at July 8, 2019 2:05 PM
Good one. You'll be thinking about it when Amy has you fill out your Year's Best ballots in December. Remember the little guy with the shallow beard!
Crid at July 8, 2019 2:09 PM
Leave a comment