She's Right -- But About *All* The Racial Pigeonholes
Judging people by their skin color is both ugly and sloppy. White people, black people, Asians, and whatever we now are supposed to call Latino people (Latinx?!) and...well...see her tweet below.
People are individuals and hugely varied. I'm an Ashkenazi Jew who had more in common with a black female colleague I volunteered with at City Hall than anybody else there -- including another Ashkenazi Jew. This black colleague and I are two smart, tough, take-no-crap women over 50. Like meets like, and I respected the hell out of her, and I got the sense she felt similarly.
Skin color, again, is reductive. It's a way for people to stake a claim to victim status or to tell other people they're racist abusers -- without knowing the first thing about those they've accused. Short and sweet: This is racism.
Again, MLK had it down. Really no need to stray from that.
Whites, likewise, & blacks, likewise, are not monolithic. Same goes for Asians.
— Amy Alkon (@amyalkon) November 4, 2020
Here's a thought! We should all be taken as individuals &, per MLK, be judged by the content of our character - that is, our repeated actions over time - which we can control, unlike our skin color https://t.co/rpfN43fKQU








At the same time, though...
I'm more racist than I'd like to admit. If I walked into a cafeteria where everyone was black except for one white person, I'd probably sit next to them.
Or if I walked into one where everyone was male except for one woman, I'd sit next to her.
Kind of like how I run into an American here, and I automatically kind of like them and feel a bond of solidarity.
NicoleK at November 3, 2020 10:12 PM
"One day after this election is over I am going to write a piece about how Latino is a contrived ethnic category [... blah blah blah]"
Breaking news bulletin: All ethnic categories are contrived. All of them. That's the nature of categorizing.
Old RPM Daddy (OldRPMDaddy at GMail dot com) at November 4, 2020 4:28 AM
"One day after this election is over I am going to write a piece about how Latino is a contrived ethnic category [... & blah blah blah]"
Breaking news bulletin: All ethnic categories are contrived. All of them. That's the nature of categorizing.
Old RPM Daddy (OldRPMDaddy at GMail dot com) at November 4, 2020 4:40 AM
Sorry about the double-post; wonkiness at my end, I think.
Old RPM Daddy (OldRPMDaddy at GMail dot com) at November 4, 2020 4:49 AM
Naw, its the hosting service (somewhar in Detroit IIRC)
Crid at November 4, 2020 5:40 AM
The term "Latinx" -- coined by virtue-signalling White wokesters -- is an insult to all Spanish speakers. Spanish, like French, etc., is a gendered language. If you don't want to respect the Spanish language and use the word "Latino", we already have gender-neutral English terms for people from the Spanish-speaking world: "Latin" and "Hispanic."
Jay R at November 4, 2020 11:36 AM
I remember a common argument made by feminists was that each of us is so much more similar (or dissimilar) to each other as human beings than we are dissimilar to each other as men and women. That the difference was only a small part of who we were.
I more or less agree with that. This is even more true, of course, regarding racial differences. We have an irreducible physical difference as women or men; "race" is mainly a category of social meaning that has no absolutes. Thomas Chatterton Williams, a bi-racial/black man who has centered much of his life around that fact that he is black, has recently re-thought his entire worldview. His biological children have white skin, blonde hair, and blue eyes. They are in no ways "black." Suddenly the importance--even the feasibility--of passing on a "black" identity to them has been revealed. Maybe we're all just people and our racial categories are something to be perhaps acknowledged, but marginalized?
RigelDog at November 4, 2020 11:45 AM
I have sat and talked with and been friends with a dark latino truck driver, a billionaire jew, a persian social group, a black pharma rep, professors, artists, you name it. If you aren't a jerk you can find the deep commonalities with most everyone. If you are looking to be insulted you can find it everywhere.
cc at November 4, 2020 3:56 PM
Whaddyoo mean, "aren't a jerk," CC?
WHAT ARE YOU GETTING AT, EXACTLY?? This is all part and parcel of your white supremacist heritage!
(Sorry, just wanted to try it out. It won't happen again.)
(It'll probably happen again.)
Crid at November 4, 2020 8:08 PM
Leave a comment