Sure I'm Annoying, But I Bet You're Thinner And Healthier
A regular commenter sent this note -- a note that's actually like a good many I get -- thanking me for turning her on to sources of good dietary science like Dr. Michael Eades and Dr. Mary Dan Eades and Gary Taubes:
Dear Amy,I wanted to thank you for your part in my recent healthfulness. I have been obese--no, I have been horribly, morbidly FAT--my entire life. My BMI at its highest was about 72 (currently 55). I have gone on diet after with no success. The bit of progress I made was when I dropped white flour and sugar from my diet, but I had given up, certain that I was destined to be fat forever.
I learned about this low-carb thing, Gary Taubes, and The Eades Doctors through your advice columns and blog. Two months ago, teetering on the brink of Type II Diabetes and with no options left and a doctor that told me my problem was that I have no self-control, I put what I'd learned into practice and my blood glucose normalized (on the low-side, even!) and the benefits have been astonishing.
I've lost 20+ pounds of fat while gaining muscle mass. The arthritis in my knees and back have gone from crippling agony to occasional, minor discomfort. I went from being unable to walk in the grocery store to trotting around with a 40-lbs. bag of pet food on my shoulder without so much as a twinge. The rashes and chronic acne I've had since puberty have all-but vanished. I started taking body measurements to track my progress, and found that I lost 4 inches on my waist in a week! Just so I'm very, very clear: today is the 14th of September. I started this one the 7th of August, and I have lost 25 lbs and more that 10 inches off my middle! Nothing, not even bariatric surgery, has that kind of success rate!
I have a long way to go before I am anywhere near normal-sized, but the information I have learned from sources you helped me find have given me what no doctor in the 30 years I've been alive could: hope.
Thanks again,
"The Original Kit"
Another amazing weight loss story that started here, chronicled on Free The Animal.
We just spent a day and a half up in Santa Barbara with the Eades, where Gregg trained the three of us on an amazing Mac-based writing program called Scrivener, and I have to say, every moment I spend with the Eades is a moment I'm more impressed by them, both as people and as purveyors of good science.
Also, Mary Dan makes a mean plate of bacon for breakfast -- a skill not to be minimized -- and they're both from the south (Arkansas -- though Mike was born and raised in Missouri) and have that Southern warmth and charm thing going.







In addition to Scrivener - get a second monitor.
Nothing beats a second monitor for holding references while you work on output. Since I work on Word documents, editing them for design changes, I have an NEC EA190M in Portrait orientation for a whole-page view.
In some cases, we have 40+page instructions for equipment calibration which require the completion of a 12+page data sheet, and these must match. This setup is far faster than others.
We don't get to use the software tools I'd like (BBEdit has Synchroscroll, we MUST use Word, etc.) so the workarounds are important.
Radwaste at September 18, 2011 5:25 AM
I'm eighteen months into a low carb (Atkins diet) and have lost 145 pounds. I was always skeptical of the low carb approach, but it has worked for me. I would encourage anyone who would like to lose weight and has read this blog to try a low carb diet.
I never would have tried a low carb diet if not for reading Amy's posts about low carb, Gary Taubes, and the Eades.
Amy, I could never thank you enough for helping me get on the right track!
JFP at September 18, 2011 7:08 AM
JFP, congratulations!
The Original Kit at September 18, 2011 7:57 AM
I second the "second monitor" recommendation. I'm in software development, which requires much dragging, copying, pasting, blahblahblah, and it makes a huge difference. On the rare occasion I work from home, I feel like I have my right hand tied behind my back.
This Scrivener program is only $45.00 (Mac)? That's a steal if it does half of what it says it will do. I downloaded the Windows beta, but am planning to buy the Mac version. Wonder if I can switch from one to the other OS with the same document.....guess that's something to find out.
And Original Kit & JFP -- congrats! It just gets better, once you change from being a MO person to a 'normal-sized' person. I would encourage all of you who are aware of and follow this amazing way of eating to be sure to resist **any** discussion of it as a "fad." Fad, it ain't.
gharkness at September 18, 2011 10:10 AM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/09/18/sure_im_annoyin.html#comment-2488959">comment from gharknessScrivener allows you this "compare" feature to split the screen right within the program and run through text in your document in the split.
Amy Alkon
at September 18, 2011 10:13 AM
Amy, I'd be interested in your thoughts on Scrivener as a writing tool. Also, what tools do you find useful for writing your blog and tracking interesting articles on the internet?
LauraB at September 18, 2011 1:02 PM
What an awesome success story! You're an inspiration, Amy. Would you ever consider posting a week-long food blog for those of us looking for a healthy example of a low-no carb diet? I've been consuming fewer carbs, but have been slipping up with pasta (my weakness) and the occasional latte.
Kyrstin V. at September 18, 2011 1:14 PM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/09/18/sure_im_annoyin.html#comment-2489357">comment from LauraBLauraB, I have been using Scrivener mainly for storage for my new book but it is an amazing writing resource. You could use the tutorial yourself (the video one) to learn to use it. We (the Eades and I) had just been planning to get together and do this, and I guess we're just big babies, the three of us, who wanted to be spoonfed by my man of technology, who makes all tech use more fun and much easier.
I use NetNewswire to read some blogs, but I basically just remember to hop around to places I like and then follow noteworthy thinkers on Twitter and find links that way. People also send me things of interest, which I really appreciate when they see stuff before I do or see stuff I might not have seen, and which I appreciate the thought behind when they send me a news story that has been out for weeks and all over the Internet. (Sometimes, it doesn't occur to people that I'm a blogger and spend my days and nights on a computer, and probably read the story about so-and-so being rude on their cell phone five minutes after it broke.) But, again, I always appreciate good intentions. I just am sometimes smothered by the weight of my email deluge!
Amy Alkon
at September 18, 2011 1:22 PM
OK, can you help me out, Amy (when convenient)? How is this Scrivener pronounced? With a long "i" or a short "i"?
Stuff like that just drives me crazy. Once I find out, I can settle down and go through the tutorial.
gharkness at September 18, 2011 1:23 PM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/09/18/sure_im_annoyin.html#comment-2489369">comment from Kyrstin V.Hmm, interesting idea Kyrstin V., the food blog. I think I'd just take notes on what I eat and post it in a list one day.
There really isn't a lot of variation in my diet, both because I don't cook (I heat) and because I love steak, buttered thin French green beans that I cook till they're wilted and dead, salad with caesar or ranch dressing, bacon, cheese omelets with bacon, cheese, dry Italian sausage, tuna with loads of mayo, dry white wine, and dark chocolate gelato. That's pretty much what I eat.
Oh, and I eat braunschweiger liverwurst because liver's good for you, and I make parsley in the bacon grease (reduce it until it's crunchy -- a big clump of it) for the potassium and Vitamin K.
Amy Alkon
at September 18, 2011 1:25 PM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/09/18/sure_im_annoyin.html#comment-2489401">comment from gharknessShort "i." From my built-in dictionary on my Mac:
scrivener |ˈskriv(ə)nər|
noun historical
a clerk, scribe, or notary.
Amy Alkon
at September 18, 2011 1:36 PM
Ooh, I love liver! That and bacon and chicken thighs are my favorite. I cook my cilantro like you cook your parsley. I have some gorgeous t-bone steaks calling my name in the fridge, too :) I would actually love to see notes about all you eat in a day. It would be interesting and I think helpful to me, in particular.
Kyrstin V. at September 18, 2011 2:13 PM
Another vote for Scrivener. love it, love it, love it, have been using it to write long-form for years.
DG at September 18, 2011 6:43 PM
scrivener |ˈskriv(ə)nər|
noun historical
a clerk, scribe, or notary.
Well, that's embarrassing. Thank you for looking it up (which I could have/should have done myself). In my ignorance, I didn't realize it was a real word.
So now, I can take down my "Notary" sign and put up one that says "Scrivener." That should confuse the hell out of my coworkers!
Kirstin V.: sometimes it helps to think of pasta as a "carrier" for the really tasty stuff. If you try pasta all by itself it doesn't really have that much flavor anyway. So maybe you could use something else (like cauliflower, for example) as the carrier for the sauces and veggies. When you think that pasta is literally just flour and water mixed together and dried into shapes (yes I know you can put other stuff in it, but the basics are flour and water), it might help you get over your desire for it.
Also, if you Google "Paleo foods," you will find dozens of menus and recipes (lots of blogs) that leave out some of the more problematic "low carb" foods that really aren't good for you anyway (like soy and peanuts). What you do have to watch out for in paleo recipes are potatoes, especially sweet potatoes, and honey. They tend to show up in some of the more liberal Paleo recipes.
gharkness at September 19, 2011 2:19 AM
I'm another formerly fat, hypertensive, hyperlipidemic, pre-diabetic person who almost two years ago was persuaded by an Amy Alkon column to learn more about low carbohydrate diet. I read the books she recommended by Taubes and Eades, as well as the chapters in my old college human physiology textbook on nutrient metabolism, energy balance and the role of insulin, quit eating carbohydrates, and easily lost 45 pounds. I've regained my strength and stamina, and I feel better than I felt for 10 years.
To Amy Alkon: Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! I really, really appreciate you talking about this.
Ken.
Ken R at September 19, 2011 3:15 AM
Amy Alkon
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2011/09/18/sure_im_annoyin.html#comment-2491595">comment from gharknessDon't be embarrassed, gharkness. There are a lot of words out there. As a newspaper columnist and one who tries to be meticulous about using the right word, I often look words up to see if they mean what I think, and I find that I sometimes am wrong. My wonderful copyeditor, SuperDave (my name for him) also has made me a better writer in small ways, by correcting me on commonly made errors (like how I have misused since, if you're being very technical about it). I will usually err (literally) on the side of writing colloquially (sometimes using "if" when I know "whether" is correct), but I like to know the rule before I break it.
Amy Alkon
at September 19, 2011 5:22 AM
I've tried a modification of low-carb eating. Mainly, I eat low-carb on most days. I still drink beer and eat bread and pasta, but if I have one carb-heavy thing in a day, that's it. Others might want to try that if going full boat isn't practical or possible.
I have noticed that if I eat an omelette and bacon at around 11 am, I'm not hungry again until about 6 pm.
I won't go full low-carb, since I'm a foodie and there are just too many good things to cook and eat, but even eating low-carb on most days has helped me lose 15 pounds without being hungry.
MonicaP at September 19, 2011 11:09 AM
I, too, have gone low carb since May and have lost 43 lbs to date. When my friends ask me where I heard about this "diet", I tell them I read about it in Amy' column. I believe that if I can do it, ANYBODY can, as I am (was?) addicted to all things carb. I eat scrambled eggs with cheese and 2 slices of bacon every weekday for breakfast and a chicken caesar salad every weekday for lunch. Dinner is is usually steak and mushrooms, BBQ chicken legs, or those pre-made chicken cordon bleu (10g carbs). My sweet fix is sugar-free jello frozen into popsicles.
My heartfelt thanks to Amy!!
Just Sayin' at September 19, 2011 1:34 PM
Forgot to add my other "regular": taco salad. Lettuce, taco meat, cheddar cheee, and salsa. Delicious and filling. I hardly miss the chips.
Just Sayin' at September 19, 2011 1:36 PM
Thanks for posting that, thank goodness for "Original" that the answer was revealed.
Seems silly that anyone's "fighting" over whether or not the carbohydrate hypothesis, in the nuances of which hormone is to blame, is or is not "true." Sure, it's important to get to the bottom of it so that we can keep learning how to better help those who are sick from the neolithic deit. Low carb is saving lives and perhaps more importantly optimizing lives - knowing exactly why shouldn't keep anyone up at night.
Apolloswabbie at September 21, 2011 12:45 PM
Leave a comment