When Life Is No Longer Worth Living
A man and his Alzheimer's-stricken wife apparently made a death pact due to her disease, report Dana Hedgpeth and Lori Aratani in the WaPo:
Three years ago, Adrienne Snelling wrote letters to her children and grandchildren explaining how she and her husband, Charles D. Snelling, decided to cope with her Alzheimer's disease.Adrienne was 79 then and had been battling the illness for about four years. Charles, her husband of nearly 60 years, was her primary caretaker at their home in Fogelsville, Pa. She was an accomplished fine arts photographer; he was prominent in Republican circles and had recently stepped down as chairman of the authority overseeing Reagan and Dulles airports and the construction of Metro's new $6 billion Silver Line.
"As you know I have Alzheimer's. It is not a nice disease. So far I have held up pretty well. Dad and I are still having a pretty good life. There is no doubt where my sickness will end up for me," Adrienne wrote in the Nov. 22, 2009, letter.
She went on: "All of our lives, Dad and I have talked over our end of life beliefs. We are both in agreement that neither one of us wants to live after all reasonable hope for a good life is over. . . . We have had such a great life together and with all of you."
On Thursday, just over a week after their 61st wedding anniversary, Charles took his own life and his wife's in their home, police and airport authority officials said. He shot himself, authorities said. They have not said how she died.
One of the couple's children, Marjorie Snelling, 56, of Philadelphia, said Friday that she knew her parents had talked about a plan to end their lives but that she and her siblings were stunned that it actually happened. There had not been "any specific signs."
Still, she said, her family believes the pair "were deliberate and thoughtful."
"They had a plan, and they were going to execute that plan without people knowing," Marjorie said. "They've seen their peers and friends languish. . . . They had really been thinking about this for some time and keeping it a secret."
More here, reported by Dana Hedgpeth:
"Together they struggled greatly to manage the effects of this devastating disease," said a statement provided on behalf of the family by the airports authority. "After apparently reaching the point where he could no longer bear to see the love of his life deteriorate further, our father ended our mother's life and then took his own life as well.
I think the way Adrienne Snelling did: I've had a wonderful life so far and I have no desire to live as some human turnip. The sad thing is, there are no legal measures in place to help a sick person end their life when if they so desire -- without the helper going to prison.
If you have Alzheimer's, and you don't want to live with it, you're either forced to kill yourself before your brain is entirely gone or chance living as a large, delusional adult infant.







For me the thing that bothers me most is if I'm severely ill, with no chance of recovery I get to be a burden to my children/husband/caretaker. Think about that, it's not a pleasant experience to devote yourself to someone who has zero chance of recovery, is an adult infant (with poopy mistakes). It means a healthy, vibrant person who is supposed to have quality of life just is not going to have it because someone else is sick.
Now if I had robots taking care of me it'd be a different matter,..
Purplepen at April 3, 2012 12:51 AM
And this of course relates to another popular topic on this blog: the cost of healthcare. And while I certainly don't think we should be carting off old people against their will, a la Monty Python ("I feel happy!"), we should also not spend money keeping people "alive" who would rather not be.
clinky at April 3, 2012 1:59 AM
I understand what he did, but I wish it hadn't been necessary, in part because it's like kicking the survivors in the head. Their family and friends lost both of them very suddenly because they couldn't be part of the process.
Ideally, Adrienne could have been surrounded by loved ones as she died, and Charles Snelling would have had the support and comfort of people who loved him.
MonicaP at April 3, 2012 6:06 AM
I agree that this disease is devastating to the whole family and it saddens me that they felt like this was their only option. I wonder, did he kill himself to avoid prosecution or was it out of loyalty to his wife? While I wouldn't want to live like that, I also wouldn't want my husband to kill himself when he has years of quality life left or go to prison. There needs to be a change in the law, so that we can avoid putting otherwise good people into the position of becoming murderers in order to bring peace to their loved ones.
Sheepmommy at April 3, 2012 7:30 AM
Charles and Adreinne were old enough to make their own choices. When Alzheimer's shadow looms over me, then out of courtesy you will never find my body. I clean up my own messes.
Storm Saxon's Gall Bladder at April 3, 2012 7:37 AM
I watched my Dad die of colon cancer over the course of three years. I've seen my Mom vegetate with Alzheimer's over the last 5 years. Cancer is far more merciful.
Eric at April 3, 2012 8:37 AM
Selfish man. Not for killing himself-that's his right as far as I'm concerned. Ditto helping his wife if that's what she wanted, and it seems that was well documented. He's selfish for using a gun. Someone has to clean that shit up, you know. Ambien can be had easily over the internet, a pill grinder and a beer to wash it down and he was good to go with much less mess.
momof4 at April 3, 2012 8:59 AM
If the best think you can do for your mate of sixty years is to kill her, and then to avoid the risk of spending the rest of your life in prison you need to kill yourself, I'd say you have the right to make a little mess.
Steve Daniels at April 3, 2012 9:36 AM
Insulin is the best answer for not leaving a mess. OTC in most states.
I never want to be a turnip. I don't want the government to suck out hundreds of thousands from my estate, before give the residue to my sister and nephews.
Jim P. at April 3, 2012 8:14 PM
Leave a comment