Why Syrian Refugees Are Not Like Jewish Refugees in World War II
Joel B. Pollak writes at Breitbart about the claim that the Syrian refugees are like the Jewish refugees from World War II. He explains why the Jewish and Syrian crises -- and refugees -- have little in common. A few examples:
1. Jews were not a terror threat; there is evidence terrorists are hiding among Syrian refugees. Jewish refugees were not a threat to the countries where they sought asylum. In the early 1920s, fears of communist activism among Jewish immigrants had helped drive restrictive immigration laws, but that threat-and the over-reaction to it-had long passed. In contrast, at least one, and as many as three, of the terrorists in the recent Paris attacks allegedly hid among Syrian refugees, prompting legitimate fears.2. Jews were singled out for persecution by the Nazis, not (initially) fleeing an ongoing war. If anyone has a unique moral claim that parallels the Jews of Europe, it is the Syrian Christians, Iraqi Yazidis, and other minorities being persecuted by radical Islamist forces in the Middle East. But that is not true of the broader wave of Syrian refugees. That is not to blame them for the war, but it does suggest there is a good moral case for distinguishing among refugees, rather than admitting all who wish to come.
3. Jews had nowhere to go; Syrian refugees should have many places to go. When Nazi Germany began persecuting Jews, the Jewish population had few-and dwindling-alternatives. The State of Israel did not exist, and Britain, to appease Arab leaders, tried to keep Jewish refugees out of Palestine. Syrian refugees, however, theoretically have many options. There are 57 member states of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, for example; some, unconscionably, are refusing so far to admit any refugees.
4. Opposition to Jewish refugees was "racial"; opposition to Syrian refugees is based on security concerns. One of the main reasons immigration laws restricted Jewish entry into the U.S. was to promote the racial, i.e. genetic, superiority of the national "stock." (Such eugenicist ideas were widespread, far beyond Nazi Germany.) In contrast, resistance to Syrian refugees has to do with fear of terrorism (see above), and valid concerns about importing radical Islam (a severe problem among Somali refugees).







The Jewish refugees before and during World War II were people schooled in the ways of a modern industrial economy. They were equipped to step immediately into jobs here in the West. Albert Einstein fled Germany by accepting a teaching position at Princeton University.
These refugees were able to assimilate quickly and did not bring with them a medieval culture and worldview.
Jewish refugees fleeing the Nazis included:
The parents of Rachel Weisz, Madeleine Albright, and Jerry Springer also fled the Nazis.
Conan the Grammarian at November 23, 2015 9:37 AM
The main difference would be the left would be up in arms to make sure they didn't come in with their capitalistic ideas and Judeo-Christian views.
Joe J at November 23, 2015 10:39 AM
"The main difference would be the left would be up in arms to make sure they didn't come in with their capitalistic ideas and Judeo-Christian views."
Irrational bullshit.
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at November 23, 2015 4:36 PM
Leave a comment