Anything Is "Feminist" If You Say It Is
Women in academia discover some 10-step Korean beauty routine and then do intellectual contortions to deem it "feminist" so they can use it.
Oh, and this stuff is pricey as fuck.
Rebecca Schuman writes at Slate:
What I didn't realize until recently, however, is that K-beauty is also popular with self-identified feminist academics and scholars, several of whom told me that they view the elaborate routine not as vanity but rather as an act of radical feminist self-care.* Indeed, Stockton University English and digital humanities professor and Web designer Adeline Koh published an entire blog post on the subject. She wrote:I've started to view beauty as a form of self-care, instead of a patriarchal trap. One of my deepest inspirations, the writer and activist Audre Lorde, famously declared that "Caring for myself is not self-indulgence, it is self-preservation, and that is an act of political warfare." For many women, especially women of color, we're often told that we are only useful, only valuable when we devote ourselves to others; that caring for ourselves in the last thing that we should consider.Kim agrees. "Self-care, especially for a woman of color, is radical," she tells me. Korean beauty "is a little breath of relaxing joy and feminist community." She explains that this may also stem from the centuries-old tradition of spa and self-care in Korean culture. Kim emphasizes that "the Korean spa is also primarily about relaxing with other women and hanging out, rather than just 'go to the spa, get these things done to you, leave.' It's frequently a family affair. I remember going to the Korean spa with my cousins and aunts in Korea when I used to visit."
Schuman winds up with this:
So if you're a college student and you happen to surprise your ethics professor in her office and she's decked out like Jason, don't be alarmed--and don't dismiss her as vain. She's engaged in a political act of self-care and/or unwinding from the day's "bullshit." She might even be keeping her mental health intact while giving your latest essay precisely the correct amount of grading time.
A commenter on the article nutshells it well -- how pathetic this is:
PPBCKWRITER
How insecure and a slave to the opinions of others are you if you have to justify wanting to look and feel pretty as a radical feminist act? Also, how nutty has feminism gotten when you can blithely rationalize pole-dancing and prostitution as female empowerment but have to tie yourself in knots, do backflips through hoops and fabricate content in order to twist your skincare routine into some big, brave act of reclaiming one's power? So sad.
Another:
Anna Lebasce
Oh come ON. Just admit that you are as vain and concerned about aging gracefully as the women who make monthly facial appointments and buy $200 moisturizer, just with less means. It has to be radical feminism because as academics, you are too deep and insightful (and too broke) to follow all of the latest "innovations" in the snake oil (sorry, beauty) industry. Shame on Slate for publishing such a biased nonsense piece puffing up yet another poorly researched, unscientific "beauty regime."
Whoopsy, and the real reason for the piece:
thegraterpotato
I'm incredibly disappointed in Slate's decision to dedicate space to a poorly written article like this. You have chosen to give airtime to a columnist who spends a third of the article promoting a company without disclosing that she has a close personal relationship with the founder of the company. This same columnist then fabricates positions and opinions from prominent K-beauty bloggers that support her thesis, without even contacting them, let alone asking for their views. When she finally posts a retraction, she doesn't have the courtesy to apologize on the Slate website or admit that she made a mistake. She also deletes entire paragraphs without mentioning that she has done so.The result is an article that reflects the niche views of the columnist's tiny sample size - her self-selected group of friends - rather than an actual trend or phenomenon among female academics. There is no attempt to solicit a diversity of views, perhaps even a few dissenting ones, or apply any sort of journalistic rigour. Which is a pity, because this could have been a really interesting, thought-provoking discussion about how beauty standards, skincare regimens, and feminism can intersect.
Instead, we get a puff piece to hawk the wares of her friend's company (I quickly skimmed the Sabbatical Beauty site and realized that the founder doesn't have any sort of background in cosmetics or chemistry, which is another worrying tangent for another day - I would be nervous about putting that stuff on my face). I am sympathetic to Slate's business considerations of page views and ad revenue, but I promise there are better writers out there who would love to contribute. Ones who might even talk to the sources that they quote in their articles.
And my absolutely favorite comment:
Jack Strawb
I would have thought "a radical act of feminist self-care" involved masturbating with a crucifix while screaming "dead white men, DEAD WHITE MEN!!!"Was I wrong?
People are frequently amazed that I'm 51, going on 52.
There's only one thing that really matters for your skin, and it's sunscreen. For years, I've worn the best one out there, which is French: La Roche-Posay Anthelios
Otherwise, I do almost nothing. I wash my face with St Ives Scrub, for about $3.50. And I put on cheap-ass eye cream -- Burt's Bees
-- for about $11.
Oh, and I suspect this "must wash your face daily" and "must do all this crap to it" is likely bullshit. Are you mud-wrestling? Probably not. If you aren't wearing a bunch of makeup, on days you aren't all sweaty from exercise or sex, do you really need to wash your face?







I'm...well, well past the carding stage of life, but I still get frequently carded. It's HUGE compliment, even though I know it's for the "if you look under 30 we card" rule and not the "you don't look 21" rule.
Though last week, one lady not only carded me buying a bottle of wine, but scanned it to make sure it wasn't fake, so maybe....:)
Sun is not your friend. If you didn't know that when you were younger, IPL photofacials can be your friend now.
momof4 at January 21, 2016 6:06 AM
If you paint up your face like a rodeo clown you do need to wash your face every night. Unfortunately this is a common southern tradition.
Ben at January 21, 2016 6:39 AM
I love prescription strength Retin A, BHAs and AHAs. I think they're one of the few scientifically proven skin care products, while the rest is mumbo jumbo.
A good BHA is $5 or $25 for high end, AHA is $40, and Retin A cream is usually covered by insurance, if it isn't for you it's $40. They last months and months for me.
Koreans are obsessed with skin. Americans spend more on makeup while Asians more on skincare. Personally aside from Asian sunblock I haven't really found their skincare to be "better" but a lot of people swear by it.
I'll stick to my chemicals thnx. Oh and Trader Joes has some surprisingly good face washes and serums.
Ppen at January 21, 2016 7:56 AM
I think Rebecca Schuman is so isolated in her little safe-space academic world that she doesn't even understand that she comes across as an idiot. This is someone who thinks it's cute to take selfies where she's flipping off her infant. This is someone whose self-identity as an academic and a feminist dictates everything she writes. She's a walking stereotype of a female academic: bad hair, no makeup, obsessed with shit that only matters inside the university. Feminism says you can't look good for a man, or just for the sake of looking good- it has to be "radical," it has to be an act of rebellion. So stupid.
I hate the current overuse of the term "self care." It's such a stupid smug liberal bullshit term.
Ahw at January 21, 2016 9:05 AM
momof4: sorry to burst your bubble, but lots of places card everyone so they don't get in trouble with people who look older than they are etc.
I've seen them card people with totally white hair.
Craig Loehle at January 21, 2016 9:09 AM
I like Paula Begoun aka cosmetics cop She has her own products but also reviews many products based on science not the mumbo-jumbo that usually passes for science in the beauty industry. She'd agree on the sunscreen, retin-a (or retinol for nonprescription strength), AHA, and BHA. Plus she'd add vitamin c. What I found most interesting was how poorly packaged some of these products are which ruins the effectiveness of it.
N at January 21, 2016 9:26 AM
My recent discovery is that conditioner that has silicone seems to muck up hair.
I get the generic for the pricier Biolage stuff from Sally's. Just $5.99 with the Sally's discount card for a big-ass bottle.
http://www.sallybeauty.com/gvp-conditioning-balm/SBS-264074,default,pd.html
Amy Alkon at January 21, 2016 9:56 AM
I like some of the K-beauty stuff (and it's only pricey at Sephora, because it's Sephora). I've never felt a need to justify it as a feminist indulgence though.
Ppen is right: a good retinol and a chemical exfoliant are miracle workers.
Astra at January 21, 2016 10:04 AM
Those of you who use Retin-A, is there some horrible peeling period you go through when you start using it?
Amy Alkon at January 21, 2016 10:07 AM
I haven't (when I used it), but know plenty who have. It's certainly not unusual.
N at January 21, 2016 10:18 AM
(Whispering: Ah, you ladies know us guys will jump your bones regardless of what you do to your skin, right? I mean, to us you are HOT!))
Bob in Texas at January 21, 2016 10:43 AM
There is some peeling w/ Retin-a but it doesn't last that long, and it's worth it. You can minimize the peeling by starting w/a lower concentration of the product and also only applying it a couple days a week. Also, you really do have to wait until your face is completely dry (like 20 minutes after you wash it) to apply.
Ahw at January 21, 2016 10:45 AM
I get carded a decent amount still, and my husband almost never does. He only gets carded when they card everyone. We are over 40.
I always say thank you.
I was 34-ish and got carded to buy a video game at Toys-R-Us. I was caught completely off guard and said, "What, really?"
I always say thank you now when it happens.
I'm very low maintenance...but I'm pale so I've been pretty good at avoiding sun.
Though I may try some of the above suggestions to keep it that way.
I wash my face twice a day (with regular drugstore products) otherwise I get acne.
Does anyone have effective suggestions for rosacea?
My cheeks are always red. I'm trying a moisturizer with a green tint and Eucerin Redness Relief Soothing Night Creme. Doesn't help much.
Katrina at January 21, 2016 11:43 AM
Have you tried Dermarest? (Don't know what its current reputation is.)
lenona at January 21, 2016 2:01 PM
No.
Not sure I want to put hydrocortisone creme on my face.
It isn't horribly bad. I mentioned to a friend at work...and she said she hasn't consciously noticed. Though it was clear when I pointed it out.
I think years ago a doc gave tetracycline which did clear it up (or maybe I'm remembering wrong and it only cleared up the acne at the time). But I do not want to be on antibiotics more than necessary. Risk/reward ratio didn't seem to be in my favor.
Katrina at January 21, 2016 5:27 PM
"Feminism says you can't look good for a man, or just for the sake of looking good- it has to be "radical," it has to be an act of rebellion."
By this measure, Goth chicks are feminists. Win!
Radwaste at January 21, 2016 5:43 PM
Some products help a little, but in general, healthy skin comes from within.
It's a lifestyle thing.
No amount of skin care, can reverse the effects of poor diet, starting in childhood, heavy drinking, smoking, massive sun damage.... And a sedentary life style.
The bad news is, a lot of women have been so obsessed about their skin, and their weight, that they are also horribly vitamin D and other micro nutrient deficient which leads to a number of debilitating, and fatal diseases.
The older I get, the less makeup I wear. I see these old biddies, with the permed up hair, tattooed eyebrows, and caked on powder base. Frankly, I would rather look old, than look desperate.
I gauge my health by how many things, I am still able to do, that most women my age, cannot.
Isab at January 22, 2016 8:19 AM
Leave a comment