Why Is "Poor Taste" Inappropriate -- And To The Point That Colleges "Investigate"?
I become more and more convinced: College is now nursery school with beer.
If you, back when I went to University of Michigan in 80s, told me that college students would be "investigated" for going to costumes dressed up in "bad taste," I think I would have just stood there and gaped at you.
Isn't that the point? Costume party...dressing up in bad taste?
Now, keep in mind these are Canadians we're talking about -- Canada being the North American capital of niceness, politeness, smiling mooses, and Dudley DoRight -- so the "bad taste" is rather decaf compared to what you'd see here, down-country.
From CBC Ottawa, Queen's University is "investigating after photos appeared online showing white people dressed as Buddhist monks, Middle Eastern sheiks, Mexicans and Viet Cong fighters in rice hats during an off-campus student party in Kingston, Ont":
Partygoers wore "inappropriate costumes" at the event Saturday in the university district, the Alma Mater Society said in a statement on Tuesday. The district is a residential area surrounding the campus."These events undermine Queen's ability to provide a welcoming and respectful campus environment," said the society's vice-president, Carolyn Thompson.
What happens when you start walling off certain people as too precious to joke about? They become less human -- too dangerous to engage with.
The quadriplegic cartoonist John Callahan sought to change this for the "permanently seated," as he called himself, and for other disabled people, by joking about them same as we joke about everybody else. Or used to, anyway.
As I put it in a column:
How dare I joke about a disability?! Truth be told, I can't really take credit for this approach. I call it "The Callahan," after my late quadriplegic cartoonist friend, John Callahan, who buzzed around Portland in a motorized wheelchair, cracking jokes like, "See my new shoes? I hear they're very comfortable."Callahan understood that a person's disability often becomes a big wall between them and the rest of us because we're afraid of doing or saying the wrong thing. But through his refusal to, uh, pussychair around the subject, Callahan told people how the disabled want to be treated, which is "just like everyone else." And because the rest of us get poked fun of, Callahan did cartoons featuring disabled people. One of these has a posse on horseback in the desert looking down at an empty wheelchair. The posse leader reassures the others, "Don't worry, he won't get far on foot" -- which became the title of Callahan's autobiography.
Getting back to the costume party, get this -- from a comment on another CBC post about this:
Jimmy Jones
This is NOT racist. The theme of the party was "countries".How does one interpret a country in costume form? By using an iconic dress from that nation maybe? Google Saudi Arabia you get images like https://imgur.com/a/uY3kl - Vietnam, you get people in straw hats - Mexico sombreros & Lucha libre masks. They weren't being racist, they were being Canadian. Remember Canada? Where we're taught to celebrate diversity & other cultures, even if they aren't our own.
This was apparently started by a "comedian," according to a column by Robyn Urback at the above link:
Lucky us: we didn't have to wait until next October. On Tuesday, comedian Celeste Yim came across photos on her Facebook of a party attended by Queen's University students who dressed up as monks, Viet Cong guerrillas, Mexicans in prison garb and Middle Eastern sheiks in accordance with the "countries" theme. Yim posted the photos on Twitter, where she decried the event as "shockingly racist," and the story was picked up by nearly every mainstream media organization, including this one.
Yim, with a whole 1,806 followers on Twitter (as of Wednesday night, 9:51 p.m. PT), tweet-complained about this party -- leading to the University to announce that administrative panties there were collectively bunched.
As a commenter put it:
Johnny Wilkes
Odd that this becomes a national media headline based on one complaint in the form of a tweet by a 20 year old. Any outrage from this is solely media-created.Here's more prose from Ms. Yim.
And from Yim's piece, there's this:
In conclusion, it's a dog-eat-dog world out there, but for Angelina, it's a sister-devours-brother's-face world. The bottom line is: Angelina made out with her brother at a public, glamourous event at which there were many cameras. Look it up! And I promise, as soon as I have that sweet, celebrity incest cash, my first course of action will be the thing about firing all the white people.
So, wait -- it's okay in Yim-land to say stuff like that about white people, but racist to dress up for a "countries"-themed costume party as somebody from another country. Got it.
Outrage culture: Nothing like it to get a girl some unearned power and attention.
via @JordanBPeterson







"Canada being the North American capital of niceness, politeness, smiling moose . . ."
Ah, Canada - America's hat. That niceness you mention is really an arrogance. Too many (although, certainly, not all) Canadians will remind everyone how "nice" they are while in the same breath remind you how ignorant, selfish, and rude Americans are.
Sort of like Democrats; but, a whole country with too many of those passive-aggressive bullies.
Happy belated Canadian Thanksgiving! (hey, didn't the Canucks culturally appropriate that holiday from the US?)
charles at November 24, 2016 5:00 AM
I like all the Canadians I know. There is a decency to Canadians, generally speaking, and the ones I know don't remind you of it -- or tell you how rude Americans are? Who does that?
I spent a good bit of time in Canada growing up, and I was just in Vancouver this summer for an ev psych conference. People I encountered there were pretty lovely.
Amy Alkon at November 24, 2016 6:42 AM
Interesting post by Brian Boutwell and a colleague on the racial "no-fly zone" -- the thinking and behavior that will automatically get you called a racist:
http://quillette.com/2016/11/21/what-is-a-racist-why-moral-progress-hinges-on-getting-the-answer-right/
Amy Alkon at November 24, 2016 7:10 AM
I have an American friend who lives and works in the Vancouver area. More than a few of his Canadian coworkers never miss an opportunity to slag on the USofA.
I R A Darth Aggie at November 24, 2016 7:36 AM
I drink and take my clothes off and foam up in the shower and dream of Trump making Ottawa pay for a wall on our shared border, the world's longest.
Crid at November 24, 2016 7:53 AM
The Celeste Yim piece at the link is just a 20 year-old working on her comedy chops. She has a long way to go, but seems harmless enough. A lot of comics start out using race as comedy material.
Taking her post seriously is a Canadian oddity. They're like that. Even Salon magazine has noticed. Glenn Greenwald writes about a threat to jail Ann Coulter and barring a leftist British MP from entering the country. http://www.salon.com/2010/03/22/canada_5/
In fact Yim may be prosecutable under Section 319 (2) of Canada's criminal code:
"Every one who, by communicating statements, other than in private conversation, wilfully promotes hatred against any identifiable group is guilty of
(a) an indictable offence and is liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years; or
(b) an offence punishable on summary conviction."
Canada is still a constitutional monarchy under Queen Elizabeth. British weenie wankerdom must be a communicable disease.
Canvasback at November 24, 2016 9:14 AM
John Waters must be jealous. In his heyday, you used to have to put some effort into bad taste (I still remember Divine shoplifting raw meat by slipping it between "her" thighs). Now you just have to put on a sombrero.
Kevin at November 24, 2016 10:45 AM
So just to be clear, a private business (college) is investigating its customers (students) for something they did outside of company property?
Would we stand for Wal Mart snooping on its customers Facebook feeds to find justification to refuse them service?
If a college wants to do this, I wouldnt have a problem so long as they issued a full refund. But I get the feeling that these activities arent so much about moral superiority as they are about kicking out student who have paid to bolster their bottom line.
lujlp at November 24, 2016 2:40 PM
FYI I LOVE Canadians with their smug attitudes
This story is going on my list
No in addition to pointing out how the Canadian government has ruled it a civil rights "violation" to requires food handlers to wash their hands after taking a shit, we can add educators spying on students every moment of their lives
lujlp at November 24, 2016 2:45 PM
And speaking of inappropriate
I was watching some clip show and the guest was one of the people with down syndrome who had achieved somewhat of a celebrity status, the host asked if he had ever gone swimming with alligators as a lead in to a bunch of clips where people get attacked by animals.
The guest said "No, do I look that retarded to you"
Only a small portion of the audience laughed, you could tell they wanted to be outraged, but had no one politically acceptable to brow beat with their superior ways
lujlp at November 24, 2016 2:50 PM
Crid:
Crid, don't be gross. People are trying to feast today.
Patrick at November 24, 2016 4:21 PM
Hey, chicks dig him. That's one reason why.
Hey, he might be hot. You dunno. Neither do I.
Radwaste at November 25, 2016 4:02 AM
I'm not a chick Rad. And all men are inherently ugly (to me at least).
Ben at November 25, 2016 4:56 AM
Leave a comment