Blister Wonderful
I'm starting to have feelings for this guy friend I've been fooling around with, but I'm worried he isn't feeling the same way. He's stopped short of having full-blown intercourse with me, which I find odd, although I don't want to have sex yet because I have genital herpes and I'm not ready to tell him. (I take an antiviral drug for this daily, and I'd have him wear protection during intercourse.) Do you think he knows I have herpes? Maybe he just isn't interested in me romantically and doesn't want me getting too attached.
--Puzzled
When you start to care about somebody, it's nice to give him little romantic gifts -- flowers, a gourmet cupcake, a sweet card, weeping genital sores.
Surely you'd tell the guy pronto if you had a cold: "Hey, don't get too close, because you could catch this and have an unpleasant few days." But colds go away. Herpes is forever. Yeah, I know, so are diamonds. But, unlike a mammoth rock on a girl's finger, a big genital pustule isn't anything you want to be showing off to the crew at the office: "Look at it gleam under the fluorescents!"
Genital herpes hasn't always been such a big stigmatized deal -- to the point where it's led to the tanking of countless potential relationships. Until the late '70s, it was seen as "cold sores down there" and often not even worthy of a visit to the doctor. Except in rare cases, the physical symptoms are relatively minor. At the first outbreak, especially, it feels a bit like the flu, with fever, headache, and muscle aches. There's also tingling and itching, and there can be pain, burning during urination (and don't forget the yucky sores!).
So, what led to all the stigma? The sexual revolution, for starters. In the mid-'70s, with lots of people having lots of sex, genital herpes spread (as probably did the common cold). In 1979, the CDC, seeing the herpes stats rising, got a little hysterical and announced an "epidemic" (of cold sores!), and the media ran with it. In 1980, Time magazine declared herpes "The New Sexual Leprosy," and in 1982, The Miami Herald called it a "cruel disease." "Cruel disease"? Multiple sclerosis is a cruel disease. But, an infection that gives you the itchies and makes you walk funny for a few days? As herpes simplex expert Dr. Adrian Mindel told The Independent in 1987, "For the majority of people herpes is ... nothing more than an occasional nuisance."
The thing is, if you're having an outbreak of your "occasional nuisance" and your naked parts are rubbing against somebody else's naked parts, you could infect him. The risk of transmission may be reduced by daily antiviral treatment and condom use -- provided there are no contagious areas outside the condom zone. But, you can be in a contagious stage and not know it. Of the approximately 1 in 6 U.S. adults ages 14 to 48 who have genital herpes, 80 percent don't show visible symptoms, says herpes researcher Dr. Anna Wald. Research by Wald and her colleagues found that even when herpes carriers showed no symptoms, they were contagious 10 percent of the time. Of course, that's on average. Wald explained to me that there's a range: "Some people may be contagious 1 percent of the time, and others 30 percent, but we don't have a good way to predict who is who."
Putting this guy at risk for herpes without giving him any choice in the matter was not only unfair but pretty dumb. For many people, the betrayal is the biggest problem. If you tell somebody before he fools around with you and maybe pull a fact sheet off the Internet to allay his fears, he'll be less likely to ditch you, and he won't have the rage he would at being unwittingly exposed. To launch the conversation, maybe say something like "Ever gotten a cold sore? I get them sometimes...but not on my lip!" And then, as DatingWithHerpes.org advises, don't say "I have herpes," which makes you sound like you're having an outbreak right then. Instead, say "I carry the virus for herpes" and explain how often you have outbreaks...which should make it sound more like a manageable annoyance than the guy's ticket to a lifetime of Crusty Pustules Anonymous meetings.
NOTE: There are press reports, tracing back to the respected Herpes Viruses Association of the U.K., that drug company Burroughs Wellcome caused the initial stigmatization of people with herpes by marketing the stigma to sell its drug. The association could provide me no evidence supporting its accusation, nor could I find any in 51 years of newspaper and journal articles (from 1960 to 2011). I'm very much for going after drug companies for malfeasance, but not in the absence of evidence they've committed any.








You are way out of your depth on this one..
From the Mayo Clinic ..
Complications associated with genital herpes may include:
Other sexually transmitted infections. Having genital sores increases your risk of transmitting or contracting other sexually transmitted infections, including the AIDS virus.
Newborn infection. Babies born to infected mothers can be exposed to the virus during the birthing process. This may result in brain damage, blindness or death for the newborn.
Bladder problems. In some cases, the sores associated with genital herpes can cause inflammation around the urethra, the tube that delivers urine from your bladder to the outside world. The swelling can close the urethra for several days, requiring the insertion of a catheter to drain your bladder.
Meningitis. In rare instances, HSV infection leads to inflammation of the membranes and cerebrospinal fluid surrounding your brain and spinal cord.
Rectal inflammation (proctitis). Genital herpes can lead to inflammation of the lining of the rectum, particularly in men who have sex with men.
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/genital-herpes/DS00179/DSECTION=complications
There's also Herpes Encephalitis. Each year in the U.S., herpes accounts for about 2,100 cases of encephalitis, a rare but extremely serious brain disease. Untreated, herpes encephalitis is fatal over 70% of the time. Respiratory arrest can occur within the first 24 - 72 hours. Fortunately, rapid diagnostic tests and treatment with acyclovir have both significantly improved survival rates and reduced complication rates. For those who recover, nearly all suffer some impairment, ranging from very mild neurological changes to paralysis. The best chances for a favorable outcome occur in patients who are treated with acyclovir within 2 days of becoming ill.
More on Meningitis..
Herpes Meningitis. Herpes meningitis, an inflammation of the membranes that line the brain and spinal cord, occurs in up to 10% of cases of primary genital HSV-2. Women are at higher risk than men for herpes meningitis. Symptoms include headache, fever, stiff neck, vomiting, and sensitivity to light. Fortunately, herpes meningitis usually resolves without complications, lasting for up to a week, although recurrences have been reported.
paulo at January 3, 2012 4:54 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2891261">comment from pauloYou're wrong, but I'm in the middle of something. Way out of my depth? Not even. Will respond in a few hours or before if I can. Gotta love the arrogance of a guy who thinks his Google search that took him two minutes trumps my MONTH of reading the full studies on this and communicating with Anna Wald and other top researchers.
Amy Alkon
at January 3, 2012 6:03 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2891277">comment from pauloMothers are tested these days for herpes and babies are delivered by C-section if a mother has herpes to not expose them to the sores in the birth canal.
Herpes is "cold-sores" down there for those who are not immuno-compromised. For those who are (people who've had organ transplants or have HIV), all sorts of precautions should be taken -- in life, and not just in having sex.
Most cases of the RARE disease herpes encephalitis are caused by HSV-1 -- oral herpes.
Again, I spent a month researching this question, poring over countless studies. Note the note at the bottom. I discovered a lie on the part of the Herpes Viruses Association because I TRUST NO ONE and no study. I read through decades of news reports to do what I thought was substantiating their claim -- because I don't print unsubstantiated stuff in my column. What I found was that it could not be substantiated. Disgustingly, Marian Nicholson, at the association, after I hammered her numerous times for substantiation (after poring over decades of news stories), said that they merely "postulate" that Wellcome must have done this nefarious stuff they accuse them of. I wrote back to her (a searing email), and started with "I postulate a lot of things, but I would never write an article on mere speculation. It's highly unethical."
It's a sport on the Internet, to take 10 seconds to Google something and tell somebody you're wiping the floor with their ass. I'm no Amy Dickinson. I wrote this column at rather substantial cost to myself in terms of time and effort because it means everything to me to put out the best science I can get my hands on and to dispel myths.
No, I wouldn't want herpes, and I wouldn't want any disease, and there are risks every time anybody has sex with anyone else. But, for most people, who are not immuno-compromised, herpes are what they were thought of before the sexual revolution and the CDC-inspired hysteria: Cold sores down there.
Anna Wald emphasized to me that 80 percent of the people who have herpes are asymptomatic! This means every person who has sex has a rather high likelihood of catching herpes. I have to look at my notes -- can't find this bit right now -- and I'm going from memory, but I believe I read (from a good source -- possibly Wald) that by the time people are 50, most of the population of their peers is positive for herpes.
Oh, and also, I've read that HSV1 and HSV2 (oral and genital) do some migrating. And plenty of other details that don't fit in an 800-word column.
Amy Alkon
at January 3, 2012 6:27 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2891281">comment from Amy AlkonOh, and Wald told me about that 80 percent of people, who don't know they have genital herpes, "they are responsible for most transmissions (~85%)."
Amy Alkon
at January 3, 2012 6:29 PM
Wow. Several layers to this letter. Putting aside the medical issue, I find this hilarious:
Do you think he knows I have herpes?
Maybe. Or maybe he's picking up on the fact that you don't want to have sex with him but want him to be pushing to have sex with you.
Maybe he just isn't interested in me romantically and doesn't want me getting too attached.
See above. Nothing like an "I'm totally into having casual sex with my friends, but I can't right now because I have a SECRET" attitude to confuse a guy.
NumberSix at January 3, 2012 9:46 PM
1. 70% of 2100 = 1470
2. there are over 300,000,000 people in the USA
3. 1470/300000000 = 0.0000049 or 0.00049%
Hardy the threat your making it out to be
As for this womans question - did she ever consider that he noticed he unease?
lujlp at January 4, 2012 2:01 AM
Wow. I remember our teachers in health class (late 70s and early 80s) putting herpes up there with syphilis and gonorrhea in terms of awfulness, except that herpes, being viral, wasn't exactly curable. On the other hand, I learned eventually not to take at face value everything the teachers told us.
"Do you think he knows I have herpes?" I'm trying to figure out how he would know that, since herpes doesn't make your ears or nose light up or anything. Perhaps LW told somebody who didn't need to know, who told someone else who didn't need to know, and so on. That's another thing age teaches people eventually: If there's no reason to tell about something so personal, then it's best not to let on about it.
Old RPM Daddy at January 4, 2012 3:47 AM
As regards Paulo's post: Point taken -- complications can arise from genital herpes, as they can with many other illnesses, and I'm not inclined to argue with the Mayo Clinic about that.
The questions I'd be asking at this point would be how frequently do these complications arise, do these complications arise with other illnesses, and would the frequency of complications associated with genital herpes be enough to make it as alarming an illness as it's been made out to be?
Old RPM Daddy at January 4, 2012 4:07 AM
It's always interesting to me that people write advice columnists over something like this rather than ask the one person who could truly know. Why doesn't she simply ask the guy what's going on?
Usually, when we women overanalyze these romantic situations it's because we know, deep down, he's not that into us. But it's easier to sit and ponder the many hypothetical reasons why he hasn't called or jumped our bones instead of facing the hurtful truth.
It's pretty unlikely that this guy is "stopping short" because of the herpes. Possible, but unlikely. She needs to ask him.
LS at January 4, 2012 6:06 AM
Alarming or not, health-risk or not, I don't want it and that's not a choice you get to make for any other person. It may be cold sores down there, but I don't get cold sores anywhere nor do I ever intend to. I have never known that I know anyone with herpes. I do have a friend who gets cold sores "up there" though and it's more than a mild annoyance to her.
Unless it was a kiss at a bar with someone she doesn't know, never to be repeated, she shouldn't be "messing around" with someone before telling them. The heat of the moment right before entry is not the time for discussion.
momof4 at January 4, 2012 6:07 AM
Where to begin with this one? First, a big thank you to Amy for taking the time to research her answer and take this question seriously. I too was raised in the 80's and herpes was a big scare tactic used to keep us from having sex. While I believe Amy is correct, I would still say that this
disease is nothing to laugh at. For those of us who have given birth to children, we know that there is one gift that just keeps on giving even years after the birth. When I have an episode my life becomes very uncomfortable. I can't even take my regular spin class bc of the discomfort, so it really affects the way I live my life. Sounds like herpes (the other H word) has similar effects. If you are going to expose someone to that, you need to get their informed consent. It is the ethical thing to do.
What really gets me, is that she clearly has not learned anything from her past experience. You would think that after getting infected she would be discerning about her sexual partners. But no, obviously random hook up sex is still on the table and she wonders why the guy is reluctant to seal the deal so to speak. This may date me, but frankly, women who engage in this behavior are not desirable as long term partners to men. Men will take what you give them, but they won't commit to it. She thinks she is in love with this guy and yet she hasn't even had an honest conversation with him about herself. She sounds deceitful and immature to me. I'll bet he senses it and that is why he is clearly using her as a booty call.
LW, wake up and have some self respect. Stop giving yourself to every guy who buys you a drink or dinner. Once you value yourself, others will as well. Then, when you find a guy you have an actual connection with, tell him the truth as Amy instructed you too. As she said, it's the cover-up that's the problem, not the disease.
Sheepmommy at January 4, 2012 7:29 AM
I don't give a shit that herpes symptoms are generally minor and non harmful. I Don't Want It. And I expect to be told before I kiss you or we share a dessert fork. Yes, it's a deal breaker. Yes, I'm probably hurting someone's self esteem--I'm sure there are plenty of lovely people out there who are carriers. Still doesn't mean I want to expose myself to a chronic recurring disease.
deathbysnoosnoo at January 4, 2012 8:19 AM
This idiot woman may have already infected him. Infection doesn't require intercourse. Also HSV II isn't simply a cold sore. I find it odd that Amy chose to misrepresent the nature of Herpes , and to attack the first poster for linking to the facts. My guess is that she's got herpes too and that's what she wants to believe. But she shouldn't be representing herself as an authority when she's obviously not.
Merl at January 4, 2012 8:38 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892130">comment from deathbysnoosnooAgain, most people who have it are asymptomatic and don't know. I don't want it either, and expect to be told by somebody if they have it (not that I'm dating anymore). But, most people who pass it on, per Anna Wald, do not know they have it.
Also, in the population of sexually active people, many have herpes.
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 8:40 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892206">comment from MerlI spent a month researching this and have piles and piles of studies I read -- so I actually am an authority on this -- I have become one. I refer to Anna Wald. Is she also a know-nothing.
I do not have herpes. Your assumptions are based on what expertise of your own?
I dug into the myths and the evidence on herpes. Your "expertise" comes from what, discussions with your friends? The occasional story you read.
The first poster did a quick google search. I made quick work of his comment because I know the area so well. Feel free to tell me where I'm wrong in my critique of his comments. Do women with herpes NOT get tested prenatally? Not get C-sections?
I love people who post with clear anger at me but no facts, yet accuse me of not knowing what I'm talking about. Again, I spent a month researching this, and reading a MOUNTAIN of studies. And when I read a study, I don't skim it -- I really, really read it and look for the limitations, the flaws in the methodology, and I try to look for a body of work that supports their finding. Furthermore, many studies say their conclusion is supported when it really is not. I wrote to the epidemiologist who coaches me on how to read studies that, thanks to him, I approach every study with a sort of "irate skepticism."
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 9:56 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892214">comment from Amy AlkonAlso, gotta love when people say I've "misrepresented" the nature of herpes, but don't bother to say how.
What this is, from these posters, is the human discomfort at having our closely held beliefs shown to not be correct. I have no horse in this race. I don't have herpes, and I'm not dating. (I have a boyfriend of nine years I love to pieces.) What I love to do is debunk myths and put out good science. That inspired me to put out this column. Actually, I was inspired to put it out when I read a Spiked piece by Nigel Scott of the Herpes Viruses Association, in which he said Burroughs-Wellcome caused the herpes stigma. He was lying, and I've sent the details and backup on that to Brendan O'Neill of Spiked, who's dealing with it.
It was through my meticulous work to dig up facts -- scientific and otherwise -- that got me to that conclusion. And I annoyed the living hell out of Anna Wald, emailing her repeatedly in addition to reading her work. She was good about it -- all the researchers I annoy usually are. I'd rather bug them mercilessly than put out a column that is wrong on science.
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 10:00 AM
I just finished a microbiology course geared for the health care field. What we were taught about herpes 1 and 2 is exactly what Amy has said here.
Lizzie at January 4, 2012 11:57 AM
The problem is that it doesn't really matter if herpes is a horrible disease or not--as long as the general population believes this, there's always going to be a stigma. You might intellectually know it's not a big deal, but you still don't want it because your next partner might feel differently.
It's similar with chlamydia and gonorreah. I had chlamydia once and it was no big deal--I didn't experience any symptoms, and I just took one pill and it went away with no side effects. On the other hand, I've also had the flu, which has no antibiotic cure, put me out of commission for days, and generally made me wish I was dead. In theory, I'd rather have chlamydia again than the flu or even a really bad head cold. But the stigma around STDs makes them disproportionately more undesirable than any other transmittable disease. No one blames you or hates you for giving them the flu.
Anyway, it's great that you're putting this information out there. I still probably wouldn't date someone with herpes, but it's good to know the facts.
Shannon at January 4, 2012 12:06 PM
The first poster did a quick google search. I made quick work of his comment because I know the area so well.
Amy my comment is simply copied from resources provided by the Mayo Clinic along with two descriptions of these complications from a medical reference. The reason that I did this wasn't for 'sport', but because I've butted heads with you before and knew how you'd react to being contradicted. But nothing you've written here contradicts those resources. Your rebuttal actually confirms them.
The prevalence of Herpes isn't relevant to the ethics of knowingly exposing someone to genital Herpes, nor does it diminish the impact of contracting the virus.
If you'd acknowledged the information that you'd posted in response to me in your letter, then I wouldn't have called you on it. But what you'd written in the letter presents a very different picture. You can rail at me and beat you chest as much as you like but the truth of the matter is that your description and characterization of genital Herpes isn't entirely accurate and leaves out some very crucial information. It seems like you were more interested in criticizing what you perceive to be a hysteria surrounding Herpes than in giving the LW sound medical advice.
paulo at January 4, 2012 12:06 PM
I'm in the same boat as number 6, he is probably picking up on something from her saying, I have a secret that I'm not telling you.
If he knew, he would probably asked or avoided her.
We live in a world where some would claim oral sex isn't sex, and the common stupidity/ self denial of people, that VDs can only be spread by full-blown intercourse. So I'm also concerned that she says "He's stopped short of having full-blown intercourse with me" which has me wondering exactly what they were doing and is he now already infected.
She needs to talk with him now, probably should have talked with hima few dates ago.
Joe J at January 4, 2012 12:20 PM
Maybe the guy has an STD and isn't comfortable telling her about it yet, and so isn't ready to have sex. Maybe they both have herpes.
ahw at January 4, 2012 12:28 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892377">comment from pauloI neatly debunked what you wrote.
"Your rebuttal actually confirms them." Um, no. But, keep thinking that if it makes you feel all warm and squishy inside.
Most people who have herpes are asymptomatic and asymptomatic people aren't calling up their doctors to get tested.
"Herpes isn't relevant to the ethics of knowingly exposing someone to genital Herpes,"
They are two separate issues, obviously, and both are addressed in the column. Next non-issue?
FYI, any columnist can tell you -- and would -- as would anybody with the slightest scruples, that you don't get to expose somebody else to a disease without telling them that they will be at risk. I wrote back to this girl immediately to tell her so.
I have the power and knowledge to do research and put out good information, backed by science, on herpes and chose to use this as an opportunity to do this.
You seem to be seizing the opportunity for self-aggrandisement -- through quick Google searches.
Also, FYI, people shouldn't be too impressed by any particular clinic's name on information. This isn't to say Mayo Clinic is a poor source -- I haven't investigated them. But, I just had a woman I know send me information telling me statins are good for people because she goes to a prestigious cardiologist who thinks so. They are anything but, except for a small fraction of people -- men only -- with serious heart disease.
What I've posted is not only accurate, the information was come to in a long process of weeding out information not supported by solid methodology, etc. This is one of the columns I am most proud of ever. Your criticism is about wanting to win against me not about putting out good science, which I do and have done. Meticulously.
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 12:39 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892381">comment from Amy AlkonExactly which of this paragraph (a product of my reading and evaluating numerous studies) is 1. Bad science, or 2. Untrue:
1. You can infect somebody even when you aren't having intercourse, merely rubbing up against their parts or having oral sex.
2. You can be contagious and not know it.
3. Most sufferers do not show visible symptoms.
4. My characterization of Wald's work, which she vetted (several times before I went to press -- I annoyed the hell out of her), or Wald's work itself.
The truth: You just don't like what this column says -- which is far different from what you contend, that it's somehow shoddily written by an ill-informed person. That contention is one of a small man with a grudge. Rather like a pustule!
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 12:44 PM
Paulo - The only person the LW should be getting "sound medical advice" from is a DOCTOR! The LW wrote to Amy in regards to her "guy friend" and why he doesn't seem too gung-ho about sex with her and whether or not he already knows about the herpes. Amy was explaining to her why its not such a big deal to just man up and tell him about it, which is exactly what she needs to do. The advice is spot on.
Chelsey at January 4, 2012 12:51 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892387">comment from ChelseyThanks, Chelsey. I worked so hard on this one (not that I usually schluff off on any of my columns). It's particularly annoying to be accused -- baselessly -- of putting out crap.
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 1:03 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892402">comment from LizzieThank you, Lizzie and Shannon -- been looking at comments through my software, so I missed yours before. Thanks. I work so hard to be accurate -- it's annoying to be accused baselessly of inaccuracy and bad work.
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 1:20 PM
"Newborn infection. Babies born to infected mothers can be exposed to the virus during the birthing process. This may result in brain damage, blindness or death for the newborn."
"Do women with herpes NOT get tested prenatally? Not get C-sections?"
I didn't know this (if it's true). Having to have a C-section is no small thing, which I assume was Paulo's point - that the stigma is warranted. I don't think he should've said you were "out of your depth on this one" because you're clearly not. That was a rude comment. Your research is sound, as always. But I kind of agree with his overall point that herpes isn't some minor nuisance.
Any woman who has had a C-section will tell you that it's a major surgery and recovery. The fact that herpes would require a C-section is just one of the many reasons none of us wants this.
LS at January 4, 2012 1:24 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892418">comment from LSThanks, LS, and I sure wouldn't want herpes. I don't think it's a small thing, exposing somebody even to a cold through knowingly not disclosing it. It's stealing a part of their life and causing them pain and suffering. I dated a guy -- briefly -- who revealed, after I'd slept with him, that he was a carrier of herpes. I was really, really angry and broke it off with him immediately and had to go out to Kaiser in White Plains to be tested (taking a train, etc., because I was going back and forth to California and they were my medical care provider, and their only outlet was in White Plains -- close to NYC). It was a shame -- I really liked the guy. He's a British journalist and I sometimes look up his work, which is very good. He was just an unethical asshole and the first rule of dating me is "Don't be unethical."
The thing is, a lot of people, if they care about a person, and if they don't find out they've been exposed to something without their knowledge and consent, will continue to date a person with herpes.
Also, per what I wrote, people shouldn't think they're safe simply because they're with somebody ethical. Many people who have it have no idea and no symptoms. So some of you railing here at me about herpes may actually have it and have no idea.
I know I don't have it because I've been tested for it countless times (I kind of got around BG -- Before Gregg).
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 1:34 PM
Paulo - The only person the LW should be getting "sound medical advice" from is a DOCTOR!
I think that's his point. My reading of that letter is similar to his. Herpes can have very serious complications. It's not just a blister or a cold sore on your genitals.
Honestly Amy, freaking out and getting so vindictive with people doesn't help your case. Paulo posted information from credible sources. It's either accurate or it isn't.
JJ at January 4, 2012 2:06 PM
I have genital herpes and I have to say that Amy’s analysis is spot on. I haven’t informed any of my partners about my ‘crusty little secret’, and none of them have caught ‘the herp’. I was infected 10 years ago. Since then I’ve only had one mild re-occurrence in 10 years. I haven’t had to deal with any other medical problems because of HVS-2. In my opinion calling that 'a minor annoyance' is overstating it.
In any case herpes is a lot more common then you think. According to the CDC 1 in 5 women (14 to 49 years of age) already have the virus. Many of them don’t know it. Unless this guy is extremely religious or prudish (I know that was redundant) chances are very high that he’s going to sleep with a woman that has herpes anyway. So while philosophically I agree with the idea that the LW should tell him; practically it won’t make a difference. If he’s going to sleep with someone that has herpes anyway there’s no sense in ruining her chances with him.
If the LW ever infects her partner she can always play innocent by pretending to be outraged and blame him on catching herpes before he met her. Which is a very plausible scenario that actually happens frequently.
Many of those decrying herpes should know that you probably already carry the herpes virus. Around 80% of the population has oral herpes, and oral herpes can be spread from the mouth to the genitals or other parts of the body with exactly the same health implications. Is everyone here that is lambasting this woman going to get tested and inform all of their future partners if they have oral herpes? After all they could potentially spread it to their significant others’ naughty parts! If the answer is ‘no’ then you can shut up now.
The Weeping Genital Sore at January 4, 2012 2:10 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892463">comment from JJPaulo posted information from credible sources. It's either accurate or it isn't.
Ah, here we have someone who isn't coached by an epidemiologist lecturing someone who is. I don't care who a "source" is or how "credible." There are numerous respected researchers and facilities that put out shit science. I don't look at the facility when deciding whether information is credible. There are countless doctors and the AMA behind the non-evidence-based notion that one should eat a high-carb, low-fat diet -- precisely the diet that is making the American population fat and diabetic.
Investigative science journalist Gary Taubes and I have something in common, in that we are panic-stricken about telling the evidence-based truth and put far more time into it vis a vis the financial reward for it than a "prudent" person would do.
Herpes RARELY has serious complications and generally only has them for immuno-compromised people. JJ, you make this claim that it "has serious complications" -- but that's not really a fair thing to say as if it applies to the general populace. I've read the research and it does not.
Again, I wouldn't want herpes but a whole lot of you commenting here probably have it and have no idea of it. One in six people of the age of sexual activity. And MOST do not know they have it. Are all of you dropping dead or having your brains explode from "serious complications" of herpes? No, I don't think so. Have you EVER heard of anyone in your life who has? Who isn't suffering from AIDs or has had a liver transplant?
It isn't "freaking out" -- but nice try at demeaning me -- to defend oneself when one is accused of shoddy work. It's necessary.
Paulo is a tiny man who wanted to "get" me based on some previous discussion where his tiny little ego was wounded. It's apparent.
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 2:33 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2892468">comment from JJThe only person the LW should be getting "sound medical advice" from is a DOCTOR!
Also, see above - notion about who you trust. My last doctor at Kaiser, like most doctors, had no idea that there's no evidence for the lipid hypothesis.
This girl is already seeing a doctor -- one who prescribed the antiviral. I'd say my addition to his information is highly necessary. I've also done what I've intended -- performed a public service, at financial cost to myself, to spend a vast amount of time putting out the evidence-based truth about herpes when there's a who lot of misinformation out there.
Amy Alkon
at January 4, 2012 2:39 PM
There is a stigma with any of the STD's. The presumption being if you caught one you must be foolish, careless, promiscuous and/or indiscriminate.
LauraGr at January 4, 2012 3:06 PM
The microbiology course I took was taught by someone with a PhD in microbiology; viruses (along with bacteria, protozoa, and fungi) are his specialty. Amy's response to the letter writer is precisely what he told us.
Lizzie at January 4, 2012 3:19 PM
And now you're attacking me as well!
Are you having a nervous breakdown or something? You'd corroborated the same information in response to Paulo and now you're refuting it - because it's from the Mayo Clinic and you obviously don't know what that is. Because you have no background in science, medicine or research of any kind. Still you're perfectly willing to insult the intelligence and integrity of anyone that you doesn't agree with you.
I'll put this to the other commenters - who thinks that Amy's gone too far this time?
JJ at January 4, 2012 3:20 PM
Everyone agrees that she needs to tell him before exposing him, so I really don't understand the point of debating how serious herpes actually is.
Set aside the whole STD issue: Maybe he stops short of intercourse because he just doesn't want to risk making babies with someone he's not in a relationship with. Is that really so far-fetched?
Lyssa at January 4, 2012 3:26 PM
Paulo is a tiny man who wanted to "get" me based on some previous discussion where his tiny little ego was wounded. It's apparent.
I don't want to 'get' Amy you. I don't even know you. You keep going back to this idea that I'm trying to steal your status. That I'm less significant that you.
That's really not it. I didn't agree with what you wrote and so I posted additional information. That's all. I don't know how anyone can read the two posts that I've made here and come to that conclusion.
You know, if you're going to behave this way, you shouldn't keep implying that Dr. Wald endorses what you're doing. Frankly I think that she'd regret having assisted you if she knew that you were going to use her name to justify berating and humiliating people.
Paulo at January 4, 2012 4:10 PM
Amy rocks!
Ravenna at January 4, 2012 4:13 PM
Actually - the whole STD issue is important because of how we use information in our lives and in how we treat people. I thank Amy for helping to spread the words about Herpes - that is 'Don't Panic'. Excellent job. About 'serious consequences' - dudes have you read the warning labels on everyday medicines. They're enough to scare the pants off you, yet we take them anyway. It's not about what could happen - it's about what's *likely* to happen,
Amy - there was , shall we say, a Herpes situation a while back in my life and at that point you couldn't test if you had it or not if you had HSVI.
That was a moral dilemma, let me tell you. My experience - people actually react kindly when you tell them you've been exposed to genital herpes.
AntoniaB at January 4, 2012 4:22 PM
Paulo I am sorry to say that you started this round of hostilies between you and Amy. Your opening line was hostile and in your face. If you were in a bar in real life, I do believe you would get your ass kicked. You could have been polite in your disagreement, but you weren't. Also as Antonia notes above, if I printed out the worst case scenario for every OTC medication I take, it would pretty much look like your post. The question before us is one of degree. No one doubts that those are possibilities, but they are extreme possibilities. My advice to you for and JJ to let it go.
Sheepmommy at January 4, 2012 4:47 PM
When I was three to four years old, herpes became an extreme worry of mine. I had seen/overheard some tidbits of information, in commercials with dancing viruses on lips, tossed facts between adults, etc. Due to anxiety, I would chew on my lips and insides of my mouth until the point they were chapped and bleeding. I was absolutely terrified I had herpes sores on my mouth. (Making me chew on the sides of my mouths and lips more...a horrible cycle)
It actually completely terrified my young mind that I had some how contracted some strange virus by sharing chapsticks or something that I would then would transfer to anyone I would kiss in the forever future. How would I ever get married to the prince of my imagination, if he knew?
(Of course, it was all in my head. I didn't have herpes)
I wish in this column that Amy would have included a paragraph going into more detail about how likely her secret is probably why she's feeling uncomfortable and likely the reason he's uncomfortable.
But her research on herpes is sound. And I applaud her ability to state facts and statistics without attempting to scare the bejeezus out of anyone with an ingrown hair on their genitals.
Cat at January 4, 2012 5:49 PM
JJ.
If you had done the research Amy has - and I don't question that at all - you'd not back a cut/paste job as superior.
"Do you think he knows I have herpes?"
Sure, it's on the bathroom wall. It's on Facebook. They're talking about it on The View (Guinan is on your side). Castle and Beckett are trying to find out where you got it, and Beckett's sure it's Castle. Inigo Montoya is remembering disturbing things about his father as he seeks revenge. But get this: no matter what someone has heard or read about you, it doesn't beat your own story. Figure out what you want to say and then say it when you think it's going to be OK. If it's not, then fight through the hurt long enough to figure what to do next, differently.
There are enough timid people. Don't be one.
Radwaste at January 4, 2012 6:03 PM
I have herpes...the face kind, not the 'down there' kind. The first breakout I got was on the side of my face, when I was a baby. No, I wasn't a slutty ass baby. What happened was, somebody with a cold sore gave the cute baby a kiss. My mom thinks it was my grandma.
That's right. I got herpes from my grandma.
I agree with the others who point out that STDs carry stigma and we love to judge and hate on those who are so 'careless' as to catch them. Our parents were also 'careless' enough to get pregnant and give birth to many of us.
So everybody chill the f out. It's not that bad. It's not a death sentence. The antiviral drugs work really well, too, so even though it is, it doesn't even really feel like forever!
The worst part is waiting an hour in the dermatologists office while he gives the rich ladies their botox just so you can get the damn prescription.
As for the LW, the issue is that she's not taking the right steps to get into a real relationship with this guy. Also, if it is the case that the dude knows she has herpes and that's why he's not going 'all the way' with her, then his science isn't exactly sound, because I'd bet dollars to donuts that he's got his mouth, hands, etc. all over her jams.
All it takes is a kiss on the cheek. Just ask grandma.
lori m. at January 4, 2012 6:30 PM
Paolo speaks first in the conference room...
Radwaste at January 4, 2012 6:43 PM
"I haven’t informed any of my partners about my ‘crusty little secret’,"
Then you are a shitty piece of humanity.
momof4 at January 4, 2012 7:21 PM
I have herpes. Big deal. I got it when I was 20, and haven't had an outbreak in years.
I got it from an asymptomatic person who didn't know he had it...pretty classic.
I have also told every prospective partner that I had it before we got naked, and it was never a big deal. We just used protection, and they appreciated the honesty.
I have a daughter, and my doctor said that herpes is so common, and that a C-section carries risks, too, so they only recommend a C-section if the mother is having an active infection when in labor. I wasn't so I had her normally, and we were all fine.
Once I was able to get past the stigma and realize that I am still me, and that sex isn't over, I started to forget I even have it. Most of the time I don't even think of it.
Micki at January 4, 2012 7:25 PM
A guy in Mass died from a rabid bat bite.
I'm saving my angst for the serious things in life. Rabid bats.
MarkD at January 4, 2012 7:26 PM
Amy kicks ass.
You don't have to agree with her; don't come on here just to be a bitch.
What Radwaste said, also.
Rachel Flax at January 4, 2012 7:30 PM
"According to the CDC 1 in 5 women (14 to 49 years of age) already have the virus..." and... "Around 80% of the population has oral herpes". So what you're saying, assuming that women are 50% of the population, is that 140% of the male population has herpes. Bitter much, or just bad at math?
Cousin Dave at January 4, 2012 7:38 PM
"If the LW ever infects her partner she can always play innocent by pretending to be outraged and blame him on catching herpes before he met her. Which is a very plausible scenario that actually happens frequently."
Wow. I agree with momof4. Not only does this immoral person not tell, she/he even suggests turning it around, acting all outraged, and making their partner believe THEY were the herpes carrier. What an asshole!
LS at January 5, 2012 4:51 AM
Kudos to Amy for so well balanced piece on herpes.
To Paolo and JJ:
It never helps to express to a goddess even a hint of doubt in her wisdom.
To LW:
Does it make sense to hate men so much? --- that's the question you need to ponder first.
Mere Mortal at January 5, 2012 8:20 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2893486">comment from Mere MortalOh, get real. I'm 47. I don't need to be right all the time, or seem like I know it all, which is why I posted this piece yesterday -- because I had no idea about it and I thought people would tell me what's up:
http://www.advicegoddess.com/archives/2012/01/04/fraud_an_email.html
Mere Mortal is another mature one like paulo -- evidenced on other threads here.
Similarly, he attacks me rather than showing exactly what I've gotten wrong in this column -- which no one here has yet been able to do...because I did meticulous research and didn't get things wrong, and wrote a balanced and even important column.
Amy Alkon
at January 5, 2012 8:31 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2893494">comment from Amy AlkonOh, and you'll note that Mere Mortal accuses this woman of being a man-hater, when there's no evidence of that -- she's merely an unethical jerk. A certain kind of man likes to see that everywhere -- typically out of his own woundedness and the poor partner choice or choices it led to. (It's easier to accuse all women of being awful than to take responsibility for ending up with one who screwed him -- usually through low self-esteem of lack of critical thinking in partner choices. The low self-esteem and unfixed psychology cause these guys to get screwed over and over, and to hate women rather than looking at themselves.)
Dr. Robert Glover leads men to a healthier approach. Had him on my radio show recently:
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/amyalkon/2011/12/12/advice-goddess-radio-amy-alkon
Amy Alkon
at January 5, 2012 8:39 AM
Ahh, it is the 21st century ---
47 years olds rage like they are 15.
Mere Mortal at January 5, 2012 8:54 AM
Are you having a nervous breakdown or something? You'd corroborated the same information in response to Paulo and now you're refuting it - because it's from the Mayo Clinic and you obviously don't know what that is. Because you have no background in science, medicine or research of any kind. Still you're perfectly willing to insult the intelligence and integrity of anyone that you doesn't agree with you.
Amy clearly knows what the Mayo Clinic is. What she said was that she hadn't researched how reliable it was for its online information, which is a wise point of view to anyone who isn't inclined to blindly accept appeals to authority.
This reminds me of the debate about the number of Iraqis killed in the war published in Lancet. "But it's Lancet" or "But it's peer-reviewed" was raised as a defense of the study. This is hilarious to anyone who knows how much crap gets through peer review into highly respected journals every day. Either the work is good or flawed on direct evaluation of its merits, which is exactly what Amy does.
Astra at January 5, 2012 10:41 AM
Ok- My bf (of 10 years) has herpes- he got it about 20 years ago from his first girlfriend (I dont know how she got it) I dont have it even after 10 years because he was honest and we use PROTECTION -he takes the drugs we use condoms and I'm fine! And yes I have been tested!! What Amy wrote is spot on- I did the research too! Now Mere Mortal didnt I mention once in a previous colomn that you needed therapy?? Yes the letter writer is unethical- If he hadnt told me and I had contracted it I would have been irate because he made a CHOICE not to tell me- which takes away MY CHOICE to protect myself. LW he deserves to know! Now in response to her question- why do you care that he hasnt pushed for sex if you are not ready to have sex with him????
his princess at January 5, 2012 10:57 AM
To further explain myself, and to also sort of do a 180 from my previous comment, "sound medical advice" changes ALL THE TIME! One year something is perfectly safe and maybe even good for you, the next year all the "respected authorities" who told us that say "oops, it actually gives you cancer, my bad". Do be careful where you get any of your information. But the LW didn't write for medical advice, she wrote to ask why the dude doesn't want to bang her. So yeah, paulo, JJ, and mere mortal can suck it. Amy is right. And for some reason that hurts their feelings.
Chelsey at January 5, 2012 11:32 AM
His princess, have you ever considered not using protection and just getting it? I ask that because I think if I was in a stable relationship of 10+ years with a man I loved - and wasn't planning on being out there single again - I'd probably chuck the condoms and just risk contracting herpes. I can't imagine having to always use protection in a long-term relationship.
To me, the real stigma of herpes is when you're single because people do judge, or reject those who have it.
How do other women feel? If it was your husband of many years, would you risk herpes so you could enjoy unprotected sex?
LS at January 5, 2012 11:45 AM
Mere Mortal is another mature one like paulo -- evidenced on other threads here.
..and yet again.
@Chelsey what is it that I should be sucking??
I have the sense that some of the ladies here are being blinded by their allegiance to the sisterhood. You're all free to Google my past posts ( site:advicegoddess.com paulo ). You'll see that Amy's conviction that I'm a worthless POS derives from nothing that would warrant that assessment.
The reason that I don't take any of this personally is that it's evident that her behavior is reflexive. She's like a cat with a ball.
A striking example of this is in her responses to the reviewers of her book on Amazon.com. She has berated anyone who has raised any criticism of her methods or conclusions and accuses them of engaging in a conspiracy against her ( yes really! ). That sort of behavior is almost unprecedented for writers on Amazon. It's likely that she has severely damaged sales of her book because she can't seem to restrain herself from vindictively lashing out at critics.
Amy is your classic wounded narcissist. She sees every disagreement as a status competition and so attempts to degrade people rather than engage them. This why she assumes that I am motivated by the same status anxiety, when in reality I simply don't like bullies. But if she'll leave me alone, then I'll stop responding to her. Let's see if she can do that.
paulo at January 5, 2012 2:02 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2893745">comment from pauloI have the sense that some of the ladies here are being blinded by their allegiance to the sisterhood.
Yep, all man-hating -- oops, except for the fact that luj and Radwaste are men.
Feel free to do what you have yet to do -- show me that your rude accusation at the top of this thread is correct in any way.
And somebody brought this up -- your initial rudeness was the problem. I get emails from people questioning stuff in my column. I respond to them, no problem, no stress. They just don't understand.
Your contention that I have done shit work has been substantiated in no way.
What went on at Amazon was not about people "reviewing" my book in any legitimate way. This was a campaign by people who had not read my book to hurt my ability to earn a living because they didn't like a blog item I'd posted several years before. There's a site that goes after me in the ugliest ways and I just ignore them -- except when they go after my livelihood. Here's the story on that, which I did not want to dredge up, but for paulo, whose tiny little self seems to need to attack me in whatever way it can.
http://patterico.com/2010/02/18/help-amy-alkon-beat-the-scum-at-sadly-no/
Amy Alkon
at January 5, 2012 2:09 PM
First: Yes! The LW has a moral (and in some states a LEGAL) obligation to tell this guy she has an STD before they have sex... As we say Down South: well, duh-huh!
Second: If she's putting it out there, and he ain't taking it, then he's either a closet gay, a eunuch, or a neurotic - or a combination of the three. I'm an old fart (50+). In my relatively long life, I have known a few (make that, exactly 2!) straight guys with low sex drives, who really didn't care about getting laid all that often. But most average guys will go for it if there is a > 0.1% probability of getting laid. Serve it up on a silver platter, and it's an offer he won't refuse!
Finally: Check out his arms... if one bicep is 3X larger than the other, then he is too happy playing The Lone Ranger / Hand Solo for a healthy adult sexual relationship. Guys will play the organ grinder during a dry spell, but only nutjobs spank the monkey by choice.
bbonw3 at January 5, 2012 2:41 PM
Amy,
I only recently discovered your blog (lucky you!), thanks to Glen Reynolds @ InstaPundit, so I don't know the "history" of your "regular" commenters. But, I see nothing factually incorrect in your posts about herpes, so ignore the barbarians at the gates. Some pathetic people live to stir up shit on the Internet...
bbonw3 at January 5, 2012 2:46 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2893771">comment from bbonw3Thanks so much, bbonw3!
And yes, you're absolutely right.
Amy Alkon
at January 5, 2012 3:00 PM
Hi LS, I wanted to comment on the chucking of condoms idea. I have herpes, and have for 15 years. I have been honest with every partner since then. My first husband did opt to throw away condoms, and he did get herpes from me after about a year. However, after the first outbreak, he considered it no big deal. He passed away about a year later (unrelated causes, lol).
I am now remarried, and my current husband has also opted to throw away condoms and take his chances. After 3+ years, he is still herpes free.
The attitude of both of them is - It is no big deal, and I would rather risk a minor annoyance for better sex....typical guys. ;P
Micki at January 5, 2012 3:00 PM
Micki: I am now remarried, and my current husband has also opted to throw away condoms and take his chances. After 3+ years, he is still herpes free.
My Wife found out last year that she has HPV - probably from her EX, who was a big-time lying adulterer. We've been together 7+ years, no condoms, and I'm still disease-free. IME, the hysteria is far worse than the condition...
It is no big deal, and I would rather risk a minor annoyance for better sex....typical guys.
Ahhhh... y'all love us for it, and you know it!
bbonw3 at January 5, 2012 3:10 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2893804">comment from bbonw3We do! Well, I do! I never understand the man-haters, actually. I held out for a great guy (a really ethical and sweet guy) and I'm sweet to him and he's wonderful to me.
Amy Alkon
at January 5, 2012 3:12 PM
Amy: I held out for a great guy (a really ethical and sweet guy) and I'm sweet to him and he's wonderful to me.
Congratulations!! Some things are worth waiting for.
I married young - right out of college. We tried to make it work, but were fundamentally incompatible.
I was much more careful, the second time around!
bbonw3 at January 5, 2012 3:31 PM
"If it was your husband of many years, would you risk herpes so you could enjoy unprotected sex?"
I can't see a lot more enjoyment in unprotected sex. Condoms ahve never bothered me. My hubby and I don't use them anymore as I've been fixed, but I rather wish we did. I don't enjoy oozing his leavings for a day or two afterwards every time. So no, if I were with a man and not trying to get preggers from him and he was infected, I would not toss the condoms. Plus, divorces and breakups happen.
""According to the CDC 1 in 5 women (14 to 49 years of age) already have the virus..." and... "Around 80% of the population has oral herpes". So what you're saying, assuming that women are 50% of the population, is that 140% of the male population has herpes. Bitter much, or just bad at math?"
I think she's saying the first stat is for herpes (genital) and the second stat is for oral herpes. So, no 140% of men needed.
momof4 at January 5, 2012 4:03 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2893864">comment from bbonw3Hey, at least you learned and got it right the second time. I'm always sort of amazed by people who write me (and some I talk to) who are in pain from making the same mistake over and over and still never take steps to change.
Amy Alkon
at January 5, 2012 4:53 PM
Amy, I want you to know that I love your column and appreciate your hard work in providing the kick in the ass people need at times. Also, I did buy your book and several copies to give to friends and family. They all loved it.
Jamie at January 5, 2012 5:35 PM
Thanks for sharing your story, Micki. Do you think the difference in your first husband getting it so quickly and your second not getting it yet at all could be due to improved medications? I assume if you rarely have an outbreak the chances are much lower?
"I don't enjoy oozing his leavings for a day or two afterwards every time."
A day or two? That's impressive! No wonder you have 4 kids (sorry, couldn't resist). But seriously, I've never oozed more than an hour or two, and I think my guy has some pretty abundant leavins' (it really needs to be "leavins'" for full effect, at least for us southern folk).
LS at January 5, 2012 5:45 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2012/01/blister-wonderf.html#comment-2893950">comment from JamieThank you so much, Jamie...means a lot -- both what you wrote above and that you bought my book. It helps me sell the next one, which I hope will happen very soon! My agent just had her baby and is taking out the next one at the end of March (my book, not a baby) and I'm trying to get as many sold as possible by then.
Amy Alkon
at January 5, 2012 6:33 PM
I was given oral herpes on a date with a man who went out with me because he wanted to get closer to my friend whom he was actually interested in. He knew he had an active outbreak and kissed me anyway. I missed three weeks of work and at one point I had over a hundred cold sores on my face and was told that it looked like I was melting. If someone ever gives me the other kind, I will kill them. Literally.
Razor at January 5, 2012 7:42 PM
I was infected my my ex husband when I was pregnant with my first child. They were careful to examine me during labor to be sure I did not have an outbreak. I did not so I did not have a C section. I did not have one with my second child either.
I am not at all thrilled to have herpes but it is what it is. I have had it for 2 decades and there have never been any serious problems and I have not had an outbreak for over 10 years.
When I was dating I had always disclosed, always. I got reactions from a man literally jumping back wards and almost running out the door. He had to come back for his coat which I was holding by the door. I have also had men say, oh no big deal so do I. When I ask when they were going to tell me it becomes clear they were not going to tell me. There is verbal stumbling around, some time things like - I was going to tell you tonight after a few false starts.
Then there is my current man who looked me in the eye and said I don't care that you have herpes, I do not have it so I need to look into it to find out how to protect myself. We had a discussion because I have educated myself on the subject over the years. I let him know if we became intimate I would need a couple of weeks for the virus suppression drugs to be at full force. We talked about how you can still shed virus when you are not having an outbreak. We talked about condoms and oral sex and everything. He went to his doctor and talked to him about it. We are together and it looks like this one is a keeper.
BTW- from my research and my doctor's research I would say what AMY has posted is correct. There are always rare secondary things that can come up. But they are rare.
The letter writer is a thoughtless little twit. She should not be playing around to the point where they do everything but intercourse without disclosing she has Herpes. That conversation should have happened a long time ago.
infected at January 6, 2012 12:48 AM
"The letter writer is a thoughtless little twit. She should not be playing around to the point where they do everything but intercourse without disclosing she has Herpes. That conversation should have happened a long time ago. "
This.
LauraGr at January 6, 2012 6:48 AM
We use condoms for a variety of reasons- one being that i had a pour reaction to birth control and well...but even though most people dont have serious side effects I really cant say as I want to have it. And unlike some men condoms dont bother him so he would rather keep me from having the inconveniance.
hisprincess at January 6, 2012 10:17 AM
Do any of your mutual friends know you have herpes? If so, he knows because they told him. I certainly would.
NicoleK at January 6, 2012 6:28 PM
I'd go condom-free for a husband in that situation, but not for a boyfriend, no matter how long we were together.
NicoleK at January 6, 2012 6:33 PM
He's stopped short of having full-blown intercourse with me, which I find odd, although I don't want to have sex yet . . . Maybe he just isn't interested in me romantically and doesn't want me getting too attached.
Or maybe he's stopped short of intercourse with you because he's picking up on the fact that you don't want to have sex (yet) with him.
Jim at January 7, 2012 3:47 PM
Thank you NicoleK
hisprincess at January 9, 2012 9:16 AM
test
gregg at January 9, 2012 9:38 AM
test
gregg at January 9, 2012 9:45 AM
testing comments module
Amy Alkon at January 9, 2012 10:21 AM
testing testing help me
Amy Alkon at January 9, 2012 10:22 AM
My best friend (now deceased) contracted herpes from a long-term boyfriend who lied and told her a sore was an ingrown hair, which she chose to believe. Fortunately, med kept her outbreaks well-controlled, and she was able to give birth twice without transmitting the virus to either child or her (now ex) husband.
Interesting how the information changes over time. When I was in high school and they were attempting to terrorize us into abstinence, it was taught that those with herpes could not transmit the virus unless they were actively outbroken.
Meloni at January 9, 2012 1:34 PM
I think the bigger issue is the betrayal. Not telling someone you have a disease that can be transmitted to them is horrible in my book.
The complications from herpes for one person may not be another person's experience but that really is moot because if a person knowingly has a disease and spreads it to me that relationship would be over. It is huge thing to not disclose.
Wanda at January 9, 2012 3:23 PM
lm,
gregg at January 9, 2012 3:24 PM
I once got a genital wart on my lip. I knew where it came from. I lived in the Philippines for two years. I had a lot of fun in the Philippines. An anti-viral cream cleared it up. That was 30 years ago. Actually, the newer creams don't work like the old ones did.
ken at January 10, 2012 3:57 PM
The old formula for Blistex has been discontinued.
ken at January 10, 2012 5:47 PM
@Amy .. don't let the idiots get to you. Internet's full of them. Never wrestle with a pig, as they say; you just get dirty, and besides, the pig likes it.
Lobster at January 11, 2012 1:56 AM
I have genital herpes contracted over 15 years ago from my then girlfriend now wife. When it was time to bring it up (pre-skin on skin foreplay) and in fact she educated me well on the issue. I did not care at the time and still do not. We used condoms, dental dams, etc etc but somewhere along I picked it up. I have many more outbreaks than her (stress I think) but choose not to medicate.
Bigger fish to fry in the world, I think.
Positive at January 13, 2012 1:12 PM
people said there is no cure on GENITAL WARST, but today many people have now believe that there is a cure FOR WARST/ IT can be cured through Africans root and harms,and days our great doctors have finally found the cure of GENITAL WASRT, many have get cured with the help of a great spell caster known as Dr.ODUDU he's the one of the great spell herbal doctor in Africa and he has the cure on this disease called GENITAL WASRT/ H.PV TYPE 1 TYPE 2 TYPE 3 AND TYPE 4. TYPE 5, HUMAN PAPAILOMAVIRUS, , HERPES, SYPHILIS, CANCER, HEPATITIS A B and C. HIRE BLOOD PRESSURES, BODY DISEASE, DIABETICS, ENPILENCIN, GENPILENCIN, HIV AIDS, PREGNANCY, and many difference kinds of diseases, last month he share is Herbal medicine in some medical hospital and now he is well recognize as one of the best spell caster in Africa, you don't have to be sad any more or share your tears any more on this disease when the cure have already be found. in 2015 the total number of people living with GENITAL WARST was 3.7 million but today the total number is now 1.9 million, if you want to get in touch with him in private contact him on this e-mail below: dr.oduduherbalhome@hotmail.com
dr.oduduherbalhome@gmail.com dr.oduduherbalhome@yahoo.com cell phone contact +2348101571054 his whatsapp contact is +2348137162683
sarah davise at October 11, 2015 7:09 AM
people said there is no cure on GENITAL WARTS, but today many people have now believe that there is a cure FOR WARTS/ IT can be cured through Africans root and harms,and days our great doctors have finally found the cure of GENITAL WARTS, many have get cured with the help of a great spell caster known as Dr.ODUDU he's the one of the great spell herbal doctor in Africa and he has the cure on this disease called GENITAL WARTS/ H.P.V TYPE 1 TYPE 2 TYPE 3 AND TYPE 4. TYPE 5, HUMAN PAPAILOMAVIRUS, , HERPES, SYPHILIS, CANCER, HEPATITIS A B and C. HIRE BLOOD PRESSURES, BODY DISEASE, DIABETICS, ENPILENCIN, GENPILENCIN, HIV AIDS, PREGNANCY, and many difference kinds of diseases, last month he share is Herbal medicine in some medical hospital and now he is well recognize as one of the best spell caster in Africa, you don't have to be sad any more or share your tears any more on this disease when the cure have already be found. in 2015 the total number of people living with GENITAL WARTS was 3.7 million but today the total number is now 1.9 million, if you want to get in touch with him in private contact him on this e-mail below: dr.oduduherbalhome@hotmail.com
dr.oduduherbalhome@gmail.com dr.oduduherbalhome@yahoo.com cell phone contact +2348101571054 his whatsapp contact is +2348137162683
sarah davise at October 11, 2015 7:11 AM
I Never believed i was ever going to be HSV2 Negative again, Dr. Silver has given me reasons to be happy, i was HSV2 positive for 2years and all the means i tried for treatment was not helpful to me, but when i came on the Internet i saw great testimony about Dr Silver on how he was able to cure someone from HIV, this person said great things about this man, and advice, i decided to give him a try, he requested for my information which i sent to him, and he told me he was going to prepare for me a healing portion, which he wanted me to take for 7days, and after which i should go back to the hospital for check up, well after taking all the treatment sent to me, i went back to the Hospital for check up, and now i have been confirmed HSV2 Negative, friends if you have anything disease contact Dr Silver on any treatment for any Disease he is the one only i can show you all up to, reach him on: drsilverhealingtemple@gmail.com
emilia whyte at August 9, 2016 4:32 AM
I am Gilbert from Nairobi Kenya, I want to testify of how i got cured from HIV, I got infected with HIV
AIDS disease in the year 2012 and I have visited several herbalists, spiritualists and pastors for cure
but all to no avail, my world was gradually coming to an end until i saw a post in a health
forum about a herbal spell caster from Africa who casts herbal spells to cure all kind of
deadly diseases including HIV AIDS, ALS, MND, Epilepsy, Leukemia, Asthma, Cancer, Gonorrhea, at first i doubted if it was real but decided to give it a try, when i contact this
herbal spell caster via his email, he prepared a herbal spell portion and sent it to me via
courier service, when i received this herbal spell portion, he gave me some
instructions on how to apply it, when i applied it as instructed,then after 7 days, then i went to the hospital for a test and to my greatest surprise i was tested negative, I am now HIV Negative (-) all thanks to Dr.princearata .you can Contact this great
herbal spell caster via his Email: dr.princearataabraham@gmail.com you can also call or whatsapp him on +2348163241499.
GILBERT UHURU at September 12, 2016 1:43 PM
God bless Dr Osas from Ghana for his marvelous work in my life, I was diagnosed of HERPES since 2014 and I was taking my medications, I wasn’t satisfied i needed to get the HERPES out of my system. When i contacted a herbal Dr in Nigeria, he scammed me of my money and he never sent me any herbal cure. I searched about some possible cure for HERPES and I saw a comment about Dr. Osas from Ghana and how he cured HERPES with his herbal medicine, I contacted him and he guided me. I asked for solutions, he started the remedy for my health, he sent me the medicine through courier delivery. I took the medicine as prescribed by him and 14 days, later i was cured from HERPES with the help of Dr Osas herbal medicine, DR.OSAS truly you are great, do you need his help also? Why not contact him on doctorosasherbalhome@gmail.com his web site http://osasherbalhome.ucoz.org
Anita Lawrence at November 26, 2016 11:21 AM
I am here to give a testimony about Dr. Uyi regarding HPV who cure me from it, i want to inform the general public how i was cured from (HUMAN PAPILLOMA VIRUS) by Dr. Uyi, i visited different hospital but they gave me different type of drugs but never cured me. I was browsing through the Internet searching for remedy on HPV and i saw comment of people talking about how Dr. Uyi cure herpes virus. When i contacted him he gave me hope and said not to worry that he can totally cure me, after little discussion he proceed with the preparation of the medicine and send it to me. Today, I am so happy as i am sharing this testimony. My advice to you all who thinks that there is no cure for HPV/HSV that is Not true just contact him and get cure by Dr. Uyi, He has different type of cure to so many disease/virus. You can contact him on his Email: uyiherbalmedicationcenter@gmail.com or WhatsApp him on +2348077199766.
Milad Koehler at March 21, 2018 5:50 AM
My names is Sandra I was diagnosed of Herpes disease 2017, I was told by my doctor that there’s no cure. I was so worried anytime i think about it,i was spending alot on medication,and i was sacked from work,because i was always sick,infact my life was a mess..i was just researching online I saw a lot of testimonials about Dr Odila on how he uses herbal medicine to cure so many deadly disease …. I contacted him via email: drodilaherbalhome@gmail.com and told him my problems, then he said i will be totally cured within 14days,my heart was full on joy when he said that i will be totally cured within 14days ,i just had faith and believe,then i purchased the herbal medicine and sent him my details such as NAME,HOME ADDRESS,PHONE NUMBER ,Then Dr Odila sent me the herbal medicine to me through courier service and I used the herbal medicine for good 14days, then I went for check-up and my doctor confirmed thats am totally free from Herpes it work like a miracle to me ,please viewers out there this is real am so happy to share this testimony .thanks to perfect health GOD WILL BLESS U . contact him through drodilaherbalhome@gmail.com or whatsapp +2348159047935. view his website https://drodilaherbalhome.weebly.com here is my private email sandraprecious100@gmail.com
sandra at March 4, 2019 12:13 PM
My names is Sandra I was diagnosed of Herpes disease 2017, I was told by my doctor that there’s no cure. I was so worried anytime i think about it,i was spending alot on medication,and i was sacked from work,because i was always sick,infact my life was a mess..i was just researching online I saw a lot of testimonials about Dr Odila on how he uses herbal medicine to cure so many deadly disease …. I contacted him via email: drodilaherbalhome@gmail.com and told him my problems, then he said i will be totally cured within 14days,my heart was full on joy when he said that i will be totally cured within 14days ,i just had faith and believe,then i purchased the herbal medicine and sent him my details such as NAME,HOME ADDRESS,PHONE NUMBER ,Then Dr Odila sent me the herbal medicine to me through courier service and I used the herbal medicine for good 14days, then I went for check-up and my doctor confirmed thats am totally free from Herpes it work like a miracle to me ,please viewers out there this is real am so happy to share this testimony .thanks to perfect health GOD WILL BLESS U . contact him through drodilaherbalhome@gmail.com or whatsapp +2348159047935. view his website https://drodilaherbalhome.weebly.com here is my private email sandraprecious100@gmail.com
sandra at March 5, 2019 2:53 AM
Some days, things do not happen the way you want them to be. They fall
apart, and you start to worry. Worse, you feel discouraged and lonely,
thinking that there is no other way to straighten things up Natural herbs
have cured so many illness that drugs and injection can't cure I've seen
the great importance of natural herbs and the wonderful work natural herbs
have done in people's lives. i read a lot of people's testimonies online on
how they were cured of Herpes, HIV, Diabetics, Lymphoma, Fibroid, Cancer
etc by Dr voodoo herbal medicine, so i decided to contact the doctor Dr
voodoo also cured me from HIV I will recommend Dr. voodoo to everyone
reading this article because this herbal healer is capable to heal anything
email Dr voodoo at: voodoospelltemple66@gmail.com also his whatsApp
+2348140120719
MICHELLE HUFF at June 12, 2020 6:59 AM
Leave a comment