Nobody To Codepend On
My boyfriend and I were invited to dinner at our friends' house. An hour after the appointed time, another friend of theirs, a woman who's been single for at least a decade, still hadn't left her house. She called with a crisis about what she was bringing, wearing, etc. (She always seems to have some crisis.) The hostess calmed her down, telling her to just come. Upon hanging up, she said that she thinks marriage both requires sanity and helps keep people sane and that people who are unmarried and living alone for an extended time seem to get increasingly neurotic. That seems a bit unfair, but I can see her point.
--Unhitched
It can be harder to indulge one's eccentricities in a marriage. Before you even turn the front door knob to head off to work in the morning, there's your spouse blurting out, "You know, that tie really clashes with the Kleenex boxes on your feet."
In other words, no, a wedding isn't a rose-petal-scattered transporter beam out of neurosis or more serious psych problems, and we shouldn't be quick to assume people who get married are more well-adjusted than people who don't. Some states require a blood test before you marry; none tests to make sure you aren't cuckoo for more than Cocoa Puffs.
Psychologist Dr. Bella DePaulo, in Singled Out, shows that many studies claiming married people are much better off than singles have serious flaws in methodology, and the modest claims of solid studies are frequently distorted, exaggerated, and turned into media catnip by the agenda-driven. As a result, "single" is so automatically viewed as the companion to "miserable" (and the prelude to getting your face eaten off by your cat) that even respected researcher Dr. E. Mavis Hetherington can't see her faulty reasoning in concluding, "Happily married couples are healthier, happier, wealthier, and sexier than are singles." Note that she's comparing HAPPILY MARRIED people with ALL single people. Yes, shockingly, happily married people are happier than clinically depressed single people and all the married people who just couldn't stand the nonstop joy and are getting divorced.
Your friend makes a mistake in throwing all the single eggs in one basket. Some people are single and living alone because they have unresolved issues, and some are because a whole lot of other people do. Others simply prefer living alone. (Why have a mancave when you can have a manhome?) Studies do show definite benefits to being (happily) married, such as having a sounding board, a ready source of sex and hugs, and someone to help you pick up the pieces when you drop them. If you're single, these benefits aren't unavailable to you; they just take more thought and effort to obtain. For example, you can share a house or duplex with a friend, create a community of friends, and have at least one close friend who knows just about everything about you and is allowed and even encouraged to tell you when you're being an idiot. Whatever you do, don't let that "dying alone!" business get to you. Somebody can tough it out for 30 years with a person and, wouldn't you know it, have that final heart attack just moments after their spouse runs out to the store with a coupon for 40 cents off cottage cheese.








Anxiety like that does not just go away with changed circumstances. If that friend were married, she'd just be married and freaking out about something else, like which random woman he sees on the subway her husband's having an affair with. If she's as desperate as she sounds and marries some guy just so she won't have to be [gasp!] alone, then I'd lay odds she wouldn't be in the "Happily Married" group just because she signed the marriage license.
NumberSix at February 19, 2013 8:58 PM
Rather than singleness explaining why she's insane, maybe the friend's insanity explains why she's single?
NicoleK at February 19, 2013 11:17 PM
NumberSix and NicoleK seem to have hit on a truth here: just because someone gets married is no guarantee that they'll become magically un-neurotic. That shit stays with you until you figure out the cause and do something about it. And I also agree about the "happily marrieds" because if you're already in a marriage and miserable, unless and until you do something about that, you're still going to be miserable, and that can make you neurotic too. Divorce might be part of the answer, but it's not the answer.
Flynne at February 20, 2013 5:15 AM
"Whatever you do, don't let that "dying alone!" business get to you. Somebody can tough it out for 30 years with a person and, wouldn't you know it, have that final heart attack just moments after their spouse runs out to the store with a coupon for 40 cents off cottage cheese."
I don't think people are afraid of being alone in the /room/ at the moment of death. It's more of an end of life, senior years, "who will spoon feed me, hold my hand, build me a fire when the furnace breaks?" kind of thing. You're not likely to find someone new to do that.
Insufficient Poison at February 20, 2013 6:26 AM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2013/02/nobody-to-codep.html#comment-3612977">comment from Insufficient PoisonIf you have rich friendships, as Bella points out in her book, you will not "die alone."
Amy Alkon
at February 20, 2013 6:36 AM
I can see both sides. My boyfriend keeps me sane by telling me point-blank when I'm over-reacting or being neurotic, which I appreciate.
At the same time, I know a married couple who just made each other more neurotic: They have a set schedule of which TV shows must be watched and what type of food eaten on pretty much every night of the week. If you want to go get sushi with them on "Tacos-and-Walking-Dead night," you are out of luck. Same goes for "Soup-and-Madmen" night. If one partner, last-minute, "doesn't feel like" coming to the dinner party you invited them to two weeks ago, both will stay home. If you manage to get one of them to come out without the other, they have designated check-in times, meaning they must call/text the other partner with their whereabouts at regular, predetermined intervals. These check-ins tend to be anything but brief and usually involve a lengthy, detailed phone/text conversations.
I think they both had control/neediness issues before marriage...but they kept it under cover pretty well when they were single. I'm close to both and didn't notice it until after they started living together.
sofar at February 20, 2013 8:29 AM
There is always the chance that marriage is what causes you to go crazy......
wtf at February 20, 2013 1:42 PM
I've come to the conclusion that marriage (or at least cohabitation) would drive me insane. I need my alone time, and lots of it. I enjoy my writing and my individual pursuits. And I love the freedom I have that being a writer gives me. If I find I can't sleep at two in the morning, I get up and write, and I don't have to worry about being tired at work the next day because I can sleep when I want to.
Patrick at February 20, 2013 3:51 PM
Amy Alkon
https://www.advicegoddess.com/ag-column-archives/2013/02/nobody-to-codep.html#comment-3615279">comment from PatrickCohabitation seems very uncivilized.
Amy Alkon
at February 20, 2013 4:23 PM
The married couple that sofar describes reminds me of the marriage of Victorian essayist/historian Thomas Carlyle and his wife Jane. A friend of theirs once commented that it was fortunate they had married each other, "thereby making only two people miserable rather than four."
Lucy B at February 21, 2013 10:05 AM
What is so terrible about "dying alone"? Ultimately, we all do. Those at our beside aren't coming with us. I've never heard a corpse complain, "Gee, I wish I hadn't died alone."
Patrick at February 21, 2013 2:19 PM
Ah, marriage. That exalted state that allows you to look down your nose at your single acquaintances and sneer "Loser!".
I could write a dozen anecdotes about why I don't hang with married people any more, but suffice it to say too many marrieds live in a cloud of smug and like it.
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at February 21, 2013 4:05 PM
I don't worry about dying alone. But I like not living alone. I like my husband, and I like knowing he's nearby. We don't have to be talking all the time. We share an office, and we frequently go hours without speaking because we both need to carve psychological space for ourselves, but I still like that he's only a few feet away.
Now that we have a baby, I can't imagine doing this alone. The other day, he said that fathers exist to keep mothers from smothering their newborns. There's probably more truth there than a lot of people are comfortable with.
MonicaP at February 21, 2013 4:06 PM
I've done both. I was married for seventeen years and have been divorced for seven. Jesus, is living alone better for me. I couldn't imagine getting married again. That's not at all a slam on my ex-wife. I just can't imagine being happier than I am now and I'm not going to screw around with that kind of perfection.
whistleDick at February 21, 2013 9:15 PM
Truth be told, a lot of unmarried women are koo-koo. It is both the reason they are unmarried, and the cause of them being koo-koo.
LIke alcohol: The cause of, yet the solution to, all of our problems.
Bertram Buttlesworth at February 22, 2013 2:08 AM
I think all of the above depends on the person and a lot of other variables. I think one thing the "ruins" the thought of cohabitating and/or marriage for some (that might otherwise try it) is, honestly, waiting so long. I married at 20 and lived on my own or with girlfriends for a whopping 2 years before marrying. I really can't imagine living alone. It sounds awful to me but I can totally see what someone who is in their 30's or 40's thinks living with someone else sounds awful. You are so set in your life and the way it runs and so used to your alone time. I miss my husband SO much when he is gone on a business trip for 5 days. We actually skype while he's gone. We're weird, I know, but I've been around him almost every day for 12 years and couldn't imagine it any other way!
CW at February 22, 2013 11:40 AM
Author Robert B. Parker and his wife, Joan, found they couldn't live together. So they split a townhouse.
Conan the Grammarian at February 22, 2013 12:07 PM
I can't speak for anyone but myself, but once between marriages I was crazy. I had no human contact except at work, store clerks, and TV. I had several crazy ideas that I thankfully could not act on because I was too drunk to get out of my recliner. One of my ideas was that ammunition was a lot cheaper than paying alimony. Luckily, I got over that stage.
I have been happily married now for 28 years.
Ken_in_SC (@Ken_in_SC) at February 23, 2013 9:14 AM
I remember a study several years ago where 40% of the married women claimed/admitted to adultery.
But none of them admitted to getting a frontloader full of manure dumped into their convertible when they got caught.
http://screen.yahoo.com/husband-gets-revenge-084500815.html
Gog_Magog_Carpet_Reclaimers at February 23, 2013 5:18 PM
Rich friendships are great if you end up in the same nursing home.
My grandmother's best friend lives an hour away and she never sees her. If she didn't have her family around she would be very alone, because her friends have died or are not easily accessible. It's very sad.
NicoleK at February 24, 2013 1:08 AM
I think these types are a sad and sympathetic case, as to be fair, modern society does not well lend itself to the humane accommodation or care of such people.
Lobster at February 25, 2013 1:42 AM
Leave a comment