The Arf Of Reading People
I'm a woman who judges potential boyfriends by whether dogs like them. My friends think I'm crazy, but I'm convinced that my dog picks up on who a person really is. Is there any research on whom animals are drawn to?
--Muttperson
Dogs have proved useful for sniffing out drug stashes, dead bodies, and IEDs. How great would it be if you could dispatch your German shepherd Tinker Bell into a bar or party to sniff out the human minefields? "Naw...skip this dude. Serious intimacy issues."
People will swear that their dog is a great judge of character -- focusing on the, oh, two times he growled at someone they despise but conveniently forgetting all the times he snuggled up to their sociopathic ex. The reality is, research does not support dogs (or even chimps) having what they'd need to assess a person's character -- a sophisticated cognitive ability humans have called "theory of mind."
Theory of mind describes being able to guess the mental states of others -- to infer what they're thinking or intending. For example, when you see a man across the street get down on one knee in front of a woman, theory of mind leads you to figure he's about to ask her something -- and it probably isn't, "Could I borrow a pen?"
That said, the ballsy little purse Cujo that growls at some Mr. Skeevy probably isn't doing it out of the blue. Dogs do seem able to read even subtle aspects of human body language -- like our tensing up upon approaching somebody we dread talking to -- and they may respond in kind.
However, dogs' perception of people and the world is dominated by their exceptionally powerful sense of smell -- estimated to be between 10,000 and 100,000 times more powerful than ours, according to anthrozoologist and "Dog Sense" author John W.S. Bradshaw.
In other words, though dogs can't read a person's mind, they may be able to smell what's on it -- or rather, the chemical messengers released by what's on it. For example, doggy cognition researcher Alexandra Horowitz explains in "Inside of a Dog" that adrenaline (triggered when a person's afraid or angry) "is unscented to us, but not to the sensitive sniffer of the dog."
Additionally, Bradshaw points out that the types of people dogs are socialized with -- women, men, men with beards, people wearing different kinds of clothes -- make a difference in whom dogs snuggle up to and whom they snarl at.
So, no, your dog is not a leg-humping background-checker. But he can help you see something important about men -- if you look at how a potential boyfriend treats him: with patience or annoyance. And as I often advise, it's also important to put some time (and a lot of observation) between thinking a guy is really awesome and seeing whether he actually is. It's tempting to believe you've found everlasting love, just as it's tempting to believe that your dog is some sort of crystal ball for reading character -- and not responding to how some guy just kneaded all the stuff together for homemade liverwurst and then wiped his hands on his pants.








I do believe animals can sense if a person really likes animals or not so your dog may be reacting to that. Also, I think it's true that an animal can pick up on a persons 'vibe' or intentions. We had a good friend who came to our house regularly so our German Shepard was very accustomed to his visits. One day for some unknown reason, when our friend showed up our dog would NOT stop barking at him no matter how much we tried to get her to stop. She finally settled down and laid in the doorway between the kitchen and the living room. He stayed for about an hour and when he got up to leave, she up and bit him in the groin without so much as a little growl! She knew he'd have to walk past her to get out and she just lay and waited for her chance. It was always a mystery to us why she did that.
Jan at July 4, 2018 10:33 AM
Dogs can probably tell if a stranger is comfortable with dogs in general. If you have a dog, this may be a make or break requirement.
Curtis at July 5, 2018 9:03 AM
Yeah, dogs might be able to sniff out a person's general emotional state, but sometimes you have to filter it through the dog's own emotional baggage - especially if it's a rescue.
Example 1:
Neighbor's doggo was a happy little thing, unless the husband came home wearing a hat, then doggo would go full Cujo. No hat - happy doggo.
Example 2:
Friend rescued a stray. One time he spilled stuff on his pants, had to change, and in doing so, had to take off his belt. Dog saw the belt come off and ran to cower under a table. I know for a fact my friend NEVER mistreated that dog, so that came from the dog's sad (and apparently battered) past.
So dogs can have their own issues that can color their "judgement."
Taylor at July 6, 2018 7:07 AM
What if the dog's owner has a subconscious reaction to another person. The dog picks up on that. Knows what you think before you do.
Richard Aubrey at July 6, 2018 7:42 AM
@Richard Aubrey
That’s probably why the family dog loved all my exs she met equally. Even the jerks. She knew I liked them, so she liked them. She was always wary of strange men but a total cuddle-whore with any man I dated.
sofar at July 6, 2018 9:52 AM
I heard this suggested with a more complicated ending:
The dog didn't like any of the women they dog owner was going with. And they didn't work out. Until the One came along. The dog liked the woman and...it worked out.
So the man in question was subconsciously aware that a woman wasn't going to be The One, no matter what he thought he felt, and the dog picked up on it.
Interesting. Could be possible.
Richard Aubrey at July 7, 2018 3:40 AM
Evidence strongly indicates that drug dogs don't really smell drugs most of the time, either; they just signal when the handler gives them the unconscious signal to signal. Radley Balko has written on this, IIRC. Drug dogs are just an excuse to get probable cause to search a home, vehicle, or person.
Grey Ghost at August 15, 2018 2:35 PM
Leave a comment